Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The left and the London Underground débacle

Socialist Organiser no. 545, 10 December 1992 · scan pp. 15–16 · Dick Walker · about 1,731 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 15

LEFT PRESS

and Peter Stone f you wanted some serious analysis of what went wrong in the recent London Underground dispute you would not have found it in most of the left The Morning Star was clearly the worst. They managed to portray as a victory the acceptance by the RMT leadership of the whole of the Company Plan, which involved flexible rostering, compulsory overtime, the abolition of travelling time, unpaid meal relief and the abolition of seniority, not to mention 5,000 job losses!

The Star's headline after the RMT called off the strike was "Tube bosses forced to retreat".

Obviously, just one more step in the British capitalist class's decade-and-a-half-long retreat... "Defend and advance" as they Socialist Worker was little better. They worked out that acceptance of the Company Plan by the RMT was a disaster. Unfortunately they then confused the issue, saying that the RMT should have gone ahead with the strike on 24 November. They are wrong.

The strike would have been solid in a couple of areas, but in most places the news was bad. Every activist on the Underground shared this assessment, including semi-detached members of the SWP who knew the mood in the depots.

In fact SW doesn't actually argue why the strike should have gone ahead. They simply assert that because there was a 3-1 majority for action there had to be a strike.

It's a bit hypocritical for a small group of people who insist on full strike pay as a condition for all-out action in areas like local government, where their own members are involved, to call on tubeworkers to go into battle with all the odds against them. Assessments of the "balance of forces" are okay on the Islington NALGO strike committee, say, but not, it seems, on the London Underground. One rule for the proles, another for the SWP. Their article was obviously written by someone with a feel for the real situation. The problem was that the comrade tried to have his cake and eat it.

At one point Militant asserts: *We do not believe that the strike should have been called off but postponed until the other unions had had their ballot results". While elsewhere in the same article we read: "Had the strike gone ahead it would not have been totally solid from day one but we would have had enough support to cause major disruption to the service and formed a platform from which to build a strike".

If the Militant are for postponement, why play around with the notion that the RMT should have gone ahead with the action?

As no Militant supporter actually argued that at the time, we can only assume that this paragraph was put in to make it appear that Militant were for the strike regardless.

The function of this two-faced approach is simple. By arguing the case for postponement of the action until the other two tube unions had balloted, Militant can talk to real, live tubeworkers. Throwing in the stuff about the strike going ahead regardless sounds nice and militant to the general reader.

Unfortunately for Militant, Marxists have to tell the truth. And telling the truth means spelling out the realities of the situation.

This is how one tubeworker did that in last week's SO:

"RMT leader Jimmy Knapp sold us down the river. But it was right not to go ahead on Tuesday 24 November. The strike should not have been cancelled but postponed until the ASLEF ballot result.

"RMT organises the majority of the train crew on the two lines which still have guards, the Northern and the Central. On the one-person-operated (OPO) lines, ASLEF has a big majority of train crew.

"Train crew are crucial in deciding the success or failure of any strike. Because of the ASLEF leaders' hostility to action, and the RMT leaders stupidity in calling their strike before the ASLEF ballot result, it was clear on Monday 23rd that the response to the strike was likely to be poor, especially on the OPO lines.

"Because the bosses ly entitled to sack all strikers at a particular workplace, a strike with a small minority of RMT and ASLEF activists out on the picket lines while the big majority of workers went in would have enabled management to carry through a mass clean-out of the best trade unionists. "The sooner any decision to postpone the strike was taken, the better, but even on Monday 23rd it would not have been too late."

Militant's tubeworkers were prepared to tell the truth and argue for postponement at the District Council. It's a pity their paper was not.

How did Socialist Outlook respond?

The article in the latest Outlook by a "London Underground train driver" doesn't really make any clear points at all. The basic argument seems to be: "All of us on the London Transport District Council are good classfighters, we did our best, so leave us alone*.

The argument is contradictory, to say the least.

At one point their comrade asserts: "Readers of Socialist Worker or the London Evening Standard probably believe the incident was a straightforward sell-out by the RMT bureaucracy.

"In fact the leadership played little role from start to finish. The strike was demanded, fought for and organised by rank and file activists around RMT's London Transport District Council, and called off at the behest of the same 100 or so militants."

Let's take this argument at face value.* It raises more questions than it answers. For a start, "was the RMT right to call a strike without waiting for the other unions' ballot results?"

It would seem not: "The [RMT] vote for action revealed a desire to strike, but workers were not convinced we could win without the other unions."

However, that is just a halfthought. In the real world, leading Outlook people — no names, no packdrill - argued straight down the line that it would be wrong to wait for ASLEF.

In fact, it was even against the RMT constitution to propose postponing the strike! [God help us if that was broken! Decisions about calling off the strike or not were up to RMT NEC. We could not let ASLEE dictate to us, etc. etc. ad nauseam.

Within a few days this selfsame great "rank and file leader" went from telling mass meetings "I don't want to hear about ASLEF" to explaining the disaster in terms of "ASLEF are no longer a union".

The simple facts of the matter are this. Socialist Organiser argued long and hard for a united fight. The Outlook people on the Underground dithered. As the strike loomed nearer some of their supporters and fellow-trayellers came to accept our case for postponement to wait for the ASLEF result. But they then backed-down at an open District Council Executive meeting after their representative on the "class struggle leadership" spoke out against postponement, and said it could not be discussed.

The rest is history. The strike was not postponed; it was called off.

The whole of Outlook's coverage had been characterised by a tendency to over-emphasise the objective situation, the balance of forces, while simultaneously downplaying what a conscious and coherent leadership could have done to develop tactics to deal with that objective situation and existing balance of forces. If you don't do this you just end up saying "In these circumstances workers won't fight". This is a poor trade union policy for Marxists.

We believe that any serious analysis of the objective situation would lead to the conclusion that every possible effort had to be put into getting a united strike with ASLEF.

If that proved impossible, the conditions for the maximum number of ASLEF members not crossing RMT picket lines had to be created. Inescapably, this meant waiting for the ASLEF ballot result. (Or for the ASLEF leadership to risk everything by calling off their own ballot while RMT had held back waiting for the result.)

For RMT to go ahead without ASLEF is to propose that the majority of train crew (who are in ASLEF) strike unofficially. If this is the correct approach, why on earth didn't the RMT District Council organise unofficial action themselves? The answer is simple. The RMT decision to strike alone was not serious trade union tactics. It was an ultimatum designed to "expose" the ASLEF leadership.

Outlook's coverage of the dispute is full of praise for the "class fighters" and the "militant minority tradition" of the London transport District Coun cil. Well, self-praise is no praise. And when it merges into covering things up, it becomes something worse.

The fact is that preparations for the strike revealed an appalling state of RMT organisation, with the union's sectional councillors and other activists not being seen, or going sick. The District Council leaders just carried on sleepwalking - until the strike was called off.

Outlook can't hide this problem completely. In fact their own article makes a side reference to it: "In some areas, union reps even resigned their positions and told members to come into work". But the basic picture they present is of a "rank and file leadership" above criticism.

Such stuff may impress the Thirty-Something professionals, with a manual worker fixation, who read and - very occasionally — sell Socialist Outlook. Tubeworkers deserve something better.

* Footnote We don't accept the role Outlook assign to the RMT NEC.

We think LUL's threat of withdrawing the check-off if there were a strike certainly put the fear of god into Knapp. There's nothing that worries a bureaucrat like a threat to his income.

Also:

a) the RMT leadership set up secret negotiations with LUL management to work out a deal to which Underground NEC rep. Bob Crow was not invited until they had been going on for 13 or 14 hours.

b) The RMT NEC, not the District Council, called off the strike. The NEC met on the Monday morning, the announcement of cancellation was made at lunchtime, and the District Council met in the evening.

c) The strike was not called off at the 'behest of the District Council. On the contrary. An open meeting of the DC Exec. was told by the DC leadership that postponing the action was not even an option open for discussion. The RMT Exec. had called off the strike and that was that. Outlook's comrade-withno-name backed them up.

Scan page 16

SOCIALIST

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 545

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →