The case for a public sector alliance
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-12-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 15 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 15
T attacks which will be he sheer scale of the launched on public sector workers in the coming period, the more obvious political character of those attacks, and the potential they create for a politicised, industrial fightback across the unions, renders the role of an educated group of revolutionary socialists indispensable.
If the Tories have their way 1993 will truly be a annus horribilis for public sector workers. The Tories are intent on: • a 1.5% public sector pay limitation, cutting the living standards of 5.8 million workers;
the closure/privatisation of the coal industry;
the carve-up and sale of British Rail, Parcelforce, London buses, Companies House, Driver Vehicle Licensing Agency cle Inspectorate;
the 'market testing" of some jobs by September 1993;
the massive extension of market testing in local government and the NHS;
pushing through their education reforms (with inevitable job loss);
driving home their counterrevolution in the NHS, closing wards, hospitals and services (Tomlinson as the most immediate threat);
implementing the Company Plan on the London Underground.
These attacks are part of the Tories' plan to destroy much that was obtained in the decades after the Second World War (a "welfare state', with millions of workers in relatively stable, public sector employment and overwhelmingly represented in trade unions), recasting British capitalism in the image of the red in tooth and claw American model.
If the Tories succeed, tens of thousands of public sector jobs will be destroyed (over the longer term, hundreds of thousands); the pay and conditions of millions of workers will be slashed; thousands will be cast into poverty, now and in their old age; a major social change will have been effected as workers are moved from historically secure to immensely insecure employment; local democracy will be gutted; and the material bases of Labourist politics substantially undermined. And for the service-users in whose name this onslaught will be carried out? Poorer services!
The threat to the trade union movement is immense. With the decline of manufacturing industry, the public sector is now a bigget base for trade unionism than the private sector.
If the public sector is broken up into competing elements, some at least will be fighting for their survival. The Tories know this. They are determined to break up the public sector "monopolies' in order to break up the unions resting on them.
Unions which have recruited and organised public sector workers relatively easily will not find things so easy with private contractors who are vehemently anti-union and whose contracts are dependent on cutting labour costs and keeping the workforce docile.
Breaking up the trade unions and refusing to recognise them has been a central feature of contracting out to date.
In some cases (civil service computing, notably) it seems to have been the major factor in Even where work remains in-house, contracting out squeezes serious trade unionism. The day after the general election, the Financial Times was explicit: "In practice the ability of the unions to hold individual councils to ransom has been considerably weakened by Compulsory Competitive Tendering (CCT). Council or health authority manual workers must now work to targets they agree in contracts with the employer. If they take industrial action and fail to hit those targets, they may lose their contract to the private sector.
'En the 1991 Liverpool strike, the council's manual workers abandoned their action before the white-collar staff, after los ing some contracts to outside companies. It is unlikely that white-collar staff will be able to hold out as long as they did in Liverpool with the imminent extension of CCT to their jobs. The formation of UNISON. increasing as it does the potential for abuse of union power, makes it essential that CCT should continue in public services."
Campaign priorities We should campaign for: • the broadest possible unity public sector workers;
unity of public service workers and users, advocating the democratic control of services and defining those services according to our needs rather than defending the status quo of a mythologised welfare an official national demonstration against privatisation, contracting out, job loss, cuts in working conditions and living standards, and, in the event of such a demonstration not being called, we should agitate for an unofficial demonstration called by Broad Lefts, rank and file groups, SMTUC, Labour Party lefts and as many official bodies of the labour movement as possible;
a cross-public sector day of strike action against service cuts, pay cuts and job loss.
linked to the miners;
co-ordination of unified, legal pay strikes across the public sector to break the 1.5% limit;
for the largest possible conference of civil service trade unionists early next year.
Contracting out is essentially a political attack on the whole working class (which will also devastate the lives of huge number of middle class people.
It therefore requires a militant industrial and political response, uniting service workers and users.
We fight for co-ordinated selective action leading to all out action.
In opposing contracting out we do not accept political responsibility for existing state functions and services. We at all times advocate services defined by and in the interests of the working class.
The existing leadership of the labour movement is hostile to the development of any such strategy. Whatever their differences, the trade union leaderships are all essentially relying on the law and in-house bids. Nevertheless there are small signs of them moving under pressure.
The building of the maximum pressure within unions and for cross-union rank and file links is therefore vital. This should be essentially on the basis of trying to turn our official unions around to fight contracting out. While not fostering illusions in the law, neither should we react kneejerk to the bureaucracy's craven reliance on it. We are for using all weapons appropriate to particular situations. We are for action "with" the bureaucracy where possible, and against them where necessary.
We are for the use of all negotiating processes to delay tender procedures, to complicate specifications and provide some safeguards for members. We oppose trade union involvement in in-house bids, tender review panels and the cutting of jobs and conditions.