Why Labour lost, a
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-12-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Olympia and York, the world's biggest property topical capitalis debauche 7h eere rushi inn gone bust. sordid waste. Billions of pounds were spent on who are there have been tempted in only by long hospitals and local authority housing were crumdecaying backwater" keptialive by pisteamou licly-owned construction corporation to carry out 1992 closes, labour move- the ment is reviving — but we still face a Tory Government. Why?
And what are the prospects for change? This analysis is extrac ed from a document discussed and adopted at the Alliance for E ning the General Election, the Tory ight months after convincingly winGovernment is in very deep trouble, more seriously split — on Europe — than the Tories have been in living memory.
They are adrift, rudderless, on key questions helpless, and led by a "second eleven" leadership widely believed to be out of its depth.
But, having adroitly and deliberately "got the election over with" before the economic slump broke to its present intensity, the Tories are constitutionally entitled to stay in power for the next four and a half years.
They are faced with Her Majesty's selfgutted and loyal opposition, John Smith's Labour Party. Were they faced with a vigorous and serious opposition — even an old-style right-wing Labour opposition — their chances of surviving anything like four and a half years would be very slim.
As it is, unless rank and file revolt erupts to change the political relations in Britain, the Tories are securely - helplessly, but securely — in power.
Our major political focus for a long time before the April 1992 election was on helping to secure a Labour victory, and advocating the entire left should do the same.
We argued that it was the only calculable able defeatism. way of getting the Tories out and beginning to turn the tide that has been flowing against the working class and the left since the beginning of the 1980s.
We spread no illusions in the Labour leadership, in its policies or even in its ability to win the election. Warning that Kinnock could ruin it, we did what we could to layers around themselves. secure a victory for the political labour movement over the Tories.
There was no alternative policy for the tant core of the labour movement, and E8 billion wasted in Docklands blocks for the civil service.
A monument to aside plans drawn up by local people for redevelopment of the docks area to include low-cost debauched nousing and small industrial units which would rovidwanoal obs. They setup elopkjands Development Corporation, free of all democratic capitalism control, and promised big tax breaks and lush proms to property developers ondon's Docklands, the showroom of There were few jobs for local people, but, for the Tories, that was just too bad. People had to ACHER SIN MAN adapt to the "enterprise culture", not vice versa. nipnewshops grab a slice, without any planned relationship of company, who built Canary Wharf, has effectively Cowary Wharts At per cent empty, the dements lavish marble-panelled offices while schools, ent free periods and anyaypturnamust dema bone bling.
veyin the future with 20 percento a pfice At he one men shout iome lice all space vacant in the central area of the city. building land, nationalise the big property compaAt best Docklands will become "a gradually nies and building companies, and set up a pubof governent money fortrensport Inksand by a democratically decided national building pro-government agreements totake therempty office grammei (SD 2IApriF)
BLANK MEANS
NECESSARY Los Angeles: a mirror of Britain's capitalist future broad labour movement - other than to defeated the Tories despite all their advanaccept defeat in advance on the basis of an tages as the party of the ruling class. The a priori calculation that the Tories could wretched Tory-understudy act which the not be beaten. Had we expressed this Labour and trade union leaders decided on in the early 1980s and have pursued since defeatism in the most radical possible tones only emphasised the natural superiority of of loud denunciation of the Labour leaderthe Tories as a ruling party. ship, in the style of the sectarians, it would Labour had no policies, no experience, no have been no less a cringing and unforgiv- credibility - and they had abjured and thrown away opportunities like the Poll T won the preceding three elections, he Tories won the election, as they Tax and unemployment to build a mass movement against the Government, instead fundamentally because they are the of siding with the Government against all those who dared to challenge it, from the ruling class organised to rule — able, by their social dominance and wealth, and the miners through to Poll Tax demonstrators. fact that they are the natural rulers of the Underlying this is something far more system, to cluster all sorts of subordinate profound: the crisis of a political labour movement which never (as a mass moveA radical opposition, even without going ment) got beyond reformism, and then beyond the framework of capitalism, could began to disintegrate, failing to regenerate still have rallied a majority around the mili- itself on a higher plane as it might have Yugoslavia: from In the early 1980s the Tory Government brushed break-up to bloodbath T in 1991. Croatia and Slovenia declared he old Yugoslav federation broke down independence, and Serbia went to war against them.
In 1992 the fighting spread to Bosnia-Herzegovina. This republic, with its mixed It was more like enterprise barbarism. It was a population of Orthodox Serbs, Catholic Croats, and Muslim Slavs, has been ripped apart into Serb areas (ready to be annexed asøciel need lawas asickeni by Greater Serbia) and Croat areas (ready be annexed by Greater Croatia), with only tiny enclaves remaining to the Muslim community, which was over 40 percent of the population.
In 1993 the danger looms of war spreading to Kosovo — where an Albanian population is held subject by Serbia — and to Macedonia. Albania, Greece, and Turkey could be drawn into the conflict. done in the early 1980s.
As Labour became a mass party, it marginalised the revolutionary factions, whose sectarianism, made it easier. Labour's "socialism" was vague and ceremonial, while its real politics were a late 19th-century, left-Liberal belief in some state intervention to ease the evils of capitalism. T ken with the post-war consensus. he Tories who won in 1979 had broThey had learned from their own defeats and helplessness in the early 1970s, and come back to office determined to use the governmental and state power to fight and win the class struggle.
least free of West European societies where the labour movement is concerned. Over and above the "natural" effects of the Massive Western military intervention — demanded by the left-Labour weekly Tribune, for example — might halt the bloodshed for now, but would not bring a democratic solution. A big-power intervention would be concerned not about democra but about re-establishing trade and investment at minimum cost. It would ride roughshod over any minority demand that seemed too costly to grant or weak enough be suppressed.
Only a movement uniting workers from all the Yugoslav nations, on a programme of consistent democracy — self-determination for all nations, the broadest possible voluntary federation, local autonomy for minorifies - can bring peace.
Socialists in the West should do all we can to help socialists, democrats and peace activists in ex-Yugoslavia — and to force Britain's mean-spirited government to open its door to refugees.
Scan page 9
ld how we can win In July John Smith was elected leader of the Labour Party, to continue Kinnock's slump, the Tories deliberately devastated whole industries because they wanted to smash up the labour movements based on them: we see a vengeful echo of this now in the decision to wipe out the mining communities.
Against this Tory onslaught, general working-class struggle and a General Strike was the necessary answer. It did not come, and it proved impossible for the revolutionary socialists to make it come.
A terrible feeling of its own impotence seemed to grip the broad labour movement, whose leaders had been demoralised and pushed into cringing defeatism by the 1970s. Successive Tory blows ensured that this posture continued - with heroic exceptions like the great miners' strike of 1984-5 —and is only now being shifted.
Events did not go the way they did inevitably or mechanically. At various turning points things could have gone differently. To take one example: the miners' strike. If the deputies (pit foremen) had struck, as they nearly did, the miners could have won. If the dockers (picked off three years after the miners) had struck for more than brief periods in conjunction with the miners, we could have won. If the local government Left in Liverpool, even so late in the day as 1984-5, had fought and combined with the tradition of attacking the left but not the Tories Mister Smith miners, we could have won. If... If...
All such "ifs" point to the question leadership.
At the core of the failures of the labour movement is the failure of the left - the real left. For about 25 years the British working class went through waves of politically headless industrial militancy, powerful enough to thwart the plans of the ruling class again and again. The Labour Party was unique of its kind in its openness; the trade unions were loose and ramshackle and not well policed by the bureaucrats. Tremendous possibilities existed for the building of a powerful revolutionary socialist — Trotskyist - party integrated with the mass working-class movement. B marked, scarred, and mutilated by ut the Trotskyist movement was Stalinism. It was organised in the 1950s and '60s as a Stalinist-type automaton party (the Healy organisation), and then, as the Healy monopoly was broken, by a series of such organisations, less grotesque than the Healyites but on the same lines — the SWP, Militant, etc. It was sectarian, trying to lay down the law to the broad labour movement, shop stewards and Labour Party rank and file alike, and devoid of the idea - central to our politics since Marx and Engels - that the revolutionaries must help the broad labour movement evolve, organising "the party" in the process. "Trotskyism" was primitive in its ideas, or, in reaction against the primitive dogmas, formless, shapeless, and boneless. It was a divided, confused, ultra-left, Stalinoid and sectarian "Trotskyism" '. The bureaucrats and the Stalinists were left in "So now we know we're ruled by a bunch of incompetents who would probably fail GCSE Economics and wouldn't know how to run a whelk stall What a pity that the Telegraph, Mail, Sun etc didn't tell us all back in April." (SO, 5 October)
control under a hail of usually incoherent denunciations, to do what they did Today socialism seems to be a depleted force. But it is the pseudo-socialisms that are a depleted force, including the Stalinist counterfeit of socialism which for decades linked "socialism" with horrors and monstrosities. The destruction of that "socialism" is good!
As a forest fire makes the ground fertile, the destruction of that Stalinist "socialism" together with the greatest crisis of capitalism in two generations, creates the conditions for a new growth of real working-class libertarian socialism. In the beginning was the critique of capitalism!
We are the bearers of that socialism, and of the unfalsified tradition of the Marxist movement. We are the bearers of the ideas that alone will fructify working-class struggles and enable them to avoid needless catastrophes such as that which the British working-class movement suffered in the 1980s.
weatherweGraor drenching bucketfuls, it was possible to have a sense of the sun rising after the long cold Arctic night through which the labour movement has come. The whole political mate Isi changing Aginst the widespread even ev ronine labourunovemem and it is a retreat, no matter what "militant", "socialist", and righteously anti-reformist slogans are shouted - Socialist Organiser has insisted on the centrality of the labour movement, Labour Party and trade unions kerfor allencialist werswer ves les issus centraliamall soci asy ere is ino mongeta doubt who was right in this dispute.
Cut off from the rhythms and logic of the class struggle, sectarians like the SWP jump in now, at the first stage of the labour ovemem stevivalwith the mas advanced of all slogans (short of "Revolution Now!") But if by a miracle the TUC were to declare a "General Strike Now", it would probably be a flop.
The ground has not been prepared. The our movementis only limited confidence in itself and in what it might do. General Strike Now" is a proposal to abort the movement which began with the big demonstrations!
Such "left" shouting is not the way to promole thereboun pement towards eral industrial confrontation with the Tories, It is a way to brand the left as toyawn and irrespons le The movement must — if it is to develop, and not be a mere splutter of indignation be a two-pronged movement escalating trade union action and solidarity around defence of the miners and on such questions as hospital closures, combined with a political campaign against the Tories, and within the labour movement against the right wing. (Socialist Organiser, 29 October).
anuary Boris Yeltsin decrees price rises in Russia, sending basic living costs to three, four or fin times what they were before, and putting 90% of Moscow's population below the official poverty line.
The army takes over in Algeria to forestall election victory for Islamic fundamentalists.
100,000 march against fascism in Paris, and 100,000 in Milan.
Militant expels its long-time leader Ted Gra who starts Socialist Appeal.
• AEU and EETPU ballots for a merger March • FW De Klerk wins big majority referendum in April • Tories win General Election May • Big public sector workers' strike in wins improved pay deal.
Riots sweep Los Angeles after a white jury acquits police shown on videotape beating up black man.
Ine Denmark votes against Maastricht Treaty:
Over one million workers in South Africa strike in protest at the De Klerk government's policies. uly John Smith elected Labour Party leader.
Tory "White Paper" proposes that, over time, all schools should be transferred from Local Education Authorities to central government control and made to seek business sponsorship. ugust Around four million workers in South Africa join protest strikes.
In Rostock, in north-east Germany, thousands cheer Nazi thugs as they burn down a refugee hostel. eptember Troops of the South African "bantustan" of Ciskei shoot dead 28 peaceful marchers. France votes narrowly "yes" to Maastricht, bur nearly one million people spoil their ballots in protest.
The European Exchange Rate Mechanism falls apart: the pound and the Italian lira are devalued. Bank of England wastes £10 billion on trying to defend the pound.
Arthur Scargill reveals that the Tories intend to close "up to 30 pits". The real figure will turn out to be 31. ctober Labour Party Conference offers no radical response to the Tory crisis — but does vote to keep Labour's trade union link.
Mass strikes and demonstrations in Italy to protest against cuts imposed by the Italian gov ernment after the lira fell out of the Exchange Rate Mechanism. Big demonstration in Britain against pit closures.
Tomlinson Report recommends closing several London hospitals and axing 20,000 health workers jobs. ovember Tory government announces a 1.5% pay limit — an enforced cut in real wages — for public sector workers. "Iraqgate": a court hearing reveals that the Tory government was secretly arming Saddan Hussein while he massacred the Kurds and while the Tories said publicly that arms sales were against the law. 350,000 march against racism in Berlin, and 150,000 in Bonn.
Scan page 10
CHRISTMAS SPECIAL: THE REAL SOUL OF CHRISTIANITY
----- pull-quotes -----
Workers' Liberty conference on 28-29 November.
A series of anti-union laws were enacted, their cumulative effect making Britain the
"Things could have gone differently. If... If... All such "ifs" point to the of leadership.
AIN* RETT ISI INOTHER FINE ESS
he habiour movement evives