Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

'Troops must be part

Socialist Organiser no. 545, 10 December 1992 · scan p. 4 · about 551 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

membership continuing to sell-outs and defeats, union SNOIN'M million Irish Protestants to a decline, unemployment rising united Ireland. with little shopfloor resistance te The present messy partition redundancies. And, of course, in was the result of the alliance April, the election result, which of the Irish Protestant minorihasn't exactly boosted rank and ty with the British Tory party. file confidence. The PIRA would, if it could, And yet there have been some create a bigger all-Ireland important fightbacks and even By Sleeper mess - in which a coerced some victories. As 1992 draws to and disaffected minority one a close there is good reason to million strong, would replace be cautiously optimistic. the present half-million Catholic Northern Irish minority — in alliance with those in Britain whom it could coerce or bamboozle into coercing the Protestants.

Everyting the PIRA does old story.

and advocates points not to a united Ireland, not to something better than the terrible reality in Northern Ireland now, but to something worse encouraging. - civil war on the Yugoslav model. unions at Baglan Bay.

The PIRA have the support of a big minority in the Catholic parts of contracts with the big firms.

Slowed in November by a catastrophe. damental situation in Ireland, or the Provisionals' popular support, gives them the right to make war, is ridiculous. The idea that progress in Ireland can be won by murdering Protestants — and that is now, as for many years, the main substance of the war inside Northern Ireland - is not only ridiculous, it is deeply hostile to genuine Irish Republicanism.

The root idea of democratic Irish Republicanism is the idea that the whole people of Ireland, Catholics and Protestants alike, are equal. Nothing on this earth is more foreign to the PIRA than that idea!

The problem in Northern Ireland has been many centuries in the making. Longterm mass unemployment is one of the strongest living roots of the present CatholicProtestant antagonism. Socialists should demand the The Six Counties state as it now exists is untenable, a savage bearpit for all its people. A broader framework, all-Ireland at least, is needed. A federal Ireland, with minority rights of self-government for the Protestant-majority area, seems to us to be the only possible framework that could replace the present failed Six Counties entity. It is the only "constitutional settlement" that both Catholic and Protestant workers in Ireland could subscribe to, respecting each others' rights, and building working-class unity in the before any such "united Ireland" could come into existence.

The British troops uphold an untenable, unjust, oppressive status quo. Should socialists now make "Troops Out" our answer, using the PIRA bombs to give point to the argument? No! British troops out without a political settlement would lead to sectarian civil war and repartition. "Troops out" must be part of a general settlement, or it is a British chauvinist proposal and nothing else - a way of saying that we care nothing for what happens in Ireland.

In the period ahead, the serious left will use the heightened interest in Ireland generated by the PIRA bombing campaign to promote discussion in the labour movement on Ireland - on British capitalism's long-term and ultimate responsibility, and on the necessity for a real solution.

----- pull-quotes -----

of a general settlement"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 545

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →