Considering the circumstances
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-12-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
fighting desperately to hold the line.
the debate on smacking children have read and re-read Sigrid Fisher's article, "Why mothers are desperHouse, Cardiff. ate" (SO 536) and nowhere Then came the miners. can I see the words, "I think smacking kids is a good thing". On the contrary, she states: "The arguments against smacking are indisputable: displays of violence by someone in a position of trust and power over a vulnerable minor are abuse..."
And yet Belinda Weaver (SO 537) and Janet Burstall (SO 544) respond, at least in tone if not in words, as if she does stand before profit. condone it.
Sigrid deals with one aspect a very large one, of the circumstances in which children get hit: the fact that they are born into a society which puts all the onus of their trade unions and the Labour Party.
upbringing and care on an isolated, private family unit, and ideologically on one cle (see page 15). member of that unit - the mother — while providing little or no support.
It is a society which tells front are long gone. girls at school that it is their role in life to have children, whether they want them or not; which provides poor sex education, fails to provide failsafe contraception, allows abortion only to the rich and then punishes her when she carries out her "role in life"
When children are born because they are wanted rather than the done thing, and when they and their carers are treated and provided for with the importance and respect they deserve then the number of smacked children will certainly decrease.
Marxists look at society as it is, in all it s horriblenss, in order to work out how to change it. They do not start from where they wish it were. To treat Sigrid as if she condones smacking because she dares to look at the world as it is and tries to deal with one reason as to why, is grossly unfair.
Both Belinda and Janet say that "circumstances are no excuse" . I think it is perfectly legitimate to look at the desto have kids when they are barely more than kids themselves, in incredibly impoverished conditions where even the most basic necessities of food, shelter and warmth are not provided by a society that dictates that girls will have babies. Not all smacking happens because of recession or poverty. To say so, suggests that only working class people smack their kids which is clearly not the case. The fact that middle class families send their kids to public schools where beatings and floggings are routine shows this. Janet and Belinda accuse Sigrid of not dealing with the cases of smacking which are done routinely or because parents think it is a good thing. But they don't deal with it either.
Janet says: "We do not content ourselves with arguing for a fundamental change in social conditions in order to combat rape. We propose specific measures and we argue against the ideology of male domination which feeds rape". Neither Janet nor Belinda say what were the specific measures they would have carried out against people who smack their kids. Education? A fine? A custodial sentence? A care order on the child? Or just arguing against the ideology of adult domination which feeds child smacking? If a child is raped then the rapist should get done for rape. If a child is battered then the batterer should get done for battery. Which of these measures would Janet or Belinda give to the parent who clips their daughter round the ear for refusing to eat her cauliflower, and which to the parents who, due to recession, have to bring their family up in the single room of a bed and breakfast and whose "inquisitive" and "curious" child's fingers are about to explore the exciting prospect of a boiling kettle?
Not all smacking is on or anywhere near the same level as abuse. It certainly is not analgous with rape. And many a parent who smacks his or her child for being naughty and refusing to listen to reason will defend that child to the death should it be in any way threatened with harm or abuse. Would Janet or Belinda treat that parent under the same law as that used for batterers and
Scan page 5
Camden Council: no money to rehouse the homeless... Organiser
----- pull-quotes -----
FORM Jean Lane continues
perate circumstances of fami- lies, some of whom are forced
"Marxists look at society as it is ... They do not start from where they wish it were