Neither IRA bombs nor British repression offer any way out For a federal united Ireland!
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-12-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Last week, policemen armed with submachine guns manned roadblocks in London, doing spot checks for Provisional Irish Republican Army (PIRA) bombers.
Thus, Britain moves one small step nearer the conditions which have been normal for over 20 years in Belfast, Derry, and the other towns of Northern Ireland. The PIRA notches up a measurable success. If the roadblocks and other measures fail, they may notch up other, bloody, successes before 1992 is out.
Now is the time for plain speaking, both to the broad labour movement, much of which will go along with the official Tory Government's demonisation of the PIRA, and to those on the left who claim that immediate British withdrawal from Northern Ireland, without a political settlement, would lead to peace in a united Ireland.
The first thing that needs to be said about the situation is that the root responsibility for it rests with this and with previous British governments. The PIRA and its 20 year war, in Northern Ireland and in Britain, is a product of many decades of British misrule in Ireland this century, and of many centuries of oppression before that.
The PIRA is not - despite mindless tabloid abuse - an isolated gang of psychotics. It is backed and sustained by a sizeable part of the Catholic population of Northern Ireland, perhaps by as many as a third of Northern Ireland's Catholics. Without that support, the gangsterism and thuggery with which the PIRA rules some of the Catholic ghettoes would bring it down to destruction very soon. T three of the Northern Ireland he question is why does one in Catholics — and many more than that at times of intense feeling - back the Provos? Because for half a century before 1969 the Catholics were second-class citizens within a Northern Ireland state ruled by the Protestant Unionists.
under British protection.
They were discriminated against in jobs, housing, and local government voting rights; they were subjected to police terror by Protestant-sectarian Special Constables.
Nothing changed until the Catholics revolted at the end of the 1960s in marches and demonstrations for "civil rights" and "British standards" . At first - before the PIRA had come into existence, and when the then-existing IRA proved no threat to anyone the Catholics were met with great police British soldiers took over the policing of Northern Ireland in August 1969, and Britain abolished sectarian Protestant majority rule in a Belfast parliament in March 1972. But Britain continued to sustain the state structures according to which Ireland is divided into six-county (Northern) and 26-county (southern) entities.
By mid-1969 the Northern Ireland Six Counties state had already collapsed into Catholic-Protestant infighting, and, left to its own devices, it would have spiralled into chaos and civil war in mid 1969. The Six Counties state had shown itself unviable by collapsing - but from the day in 1969 that British soldiers, on behalf of the British government, took direct control, British policy has sustained the basic underlying status quo, the two-state structure set up between To sustain that status quo, they have harassed, terrorised, interned and shot down those who oppose it - the Catholic minority in Northern Ireland.
The Six Counties state was supposedly set up to guard Ireland's Protestant minority from oppression by the island's Catholic majority. The Protestant population wanted it. And yet inside the "Protestant state for a Protestant people" (as one Northern Ireland prime minister once put it), Catholics were one in three of the 1.5 million population. Now they are more than 4 in 10.
The artificially created Catholic minority in the Six Counties is a bigger chunk of the Northern Ireland population than the whole Protestant population of Ireland, north and south, are of the population of the island. Catholics were and are a majority in about half the enslaves another not itself be free.
Ireland's ProtestantUnionist workers lost their own freedom."
This way of solving Ireland's Protestant minority problem - by creating a bigger, and artificial, Northern Ireland Catholic minority problem — was only possible because of the brutal power and determination of the British state and the Tory-Liberal government ruling it, after the First World War.
To impose the present settlement, Britain waged a savage war of lawless terror in the south of Ireland. Specially organised thugs — the so-called "Black and Tans" - were set on the rampage. They shot people in the street, systematically destroyed small rural factories (creameries), and burned the whole centres of Cork City and of small towns like Ennistymon.
In one notorious incident, they set ap machine guns at a hurling match and opened fire on the crowd!
When they negotiated with Britain in 1921, the elected representatives of the Irish majority were given the choice of an "immediate and terrible" unequal war, or peace with partition. Partition was presented by Britain, and accepted by the Irish, as a temporary measure. In a few years, the extensive Catholic areas of Northern Ireland - which were conquered territory, the people held against their will - would be allowed to join the South; and — so it was said and believed - the Protestant Unionists would be forced to make a new accommodation with the South.
When in 1925 the "Boundary Commission" met to carry out this part of the 1921 British-Irish treaty, the British and the Northern Ireland Unionists conspired to defend the status quo. Finally, the representatives of southern Irish capitalism accepted it, for a cash payment!
For 50 years, until they revolted in 1968-9, the artificially created Catholic minority in the Six Counties state paid dearly for this betrayal. The Catholics were kept down brutally — treated, as ProtestantUnionists feared they themselves might have been treated in a Catholic independent united Ireland.
They were too frightened of their big Catholic minority, and of its potential ability to "outbreed" them, to treat it fairly. For fear of the Catholics, and in competition with them for scarce jobs, Northern Ireland Protestant workers tied themselves politically to the Northern Ireland capitalists.
Karl Marx knew what he was talking about when he said that a nation which enslaves another can not itself be free. Keeping down the Catholics, Northern Ireland's Protestant-Unionist workers lost their own freedom. T Norther trend ointe in he underlying absurdity of Northern Ireland now is shown in this fact: for 20 years, within the state set up to protect the Protestant majority, Britain has not allowed that Protestant majority to act as a majority, with majority rights because of the 50-year experience of that majority using its power to oppress the Catholics.
Out of this situation come young Trish Catholics to London bringing bombs, death and destruction.
It does not follow from any of this that the PIRA are politically right. The PIRA is a symptom of the malaise of Northern Ireland. It is no part of a solution to it.
It fights for a "united Ireland" in which the Six Counties Protestants - one million of the five and a half million in the island and with their own distinct identity — would simply merge as an arithmetical minority. It would, in other words, swap the present situation where half a million Northern Ireland Catholics are kept against their will in the Six Counties state for one in which one million Protestants would be forced against their will into a Catholic state — and, once "in", , would be kept in by as much force as necessary.
The PIRA calls for Britain to leave — but first to disarm the Protestants! That points to the contradictions at the political hearts of these so-called "Republicans" . They are Irish Republicans in name only! Endlessly talking of a united Ireland, they yet feel free to wage a campaign of widespread murder against the Irish Protestant minority because, ultimately, they look to Britain to coerce the Protestants for them.
massas alsoxheemancipation di all humarbeings without dsiwach ov onsebionirace..
KarlMarki Sociwisn Orgawiser 2D BoyaBRB, LondonSElGANA Newsdesk:1071-63017965 Imer detes prmeports a Monday Editorm bohn/Mahony bstz WIC icoons ITTO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Printer hy killent Press, Ellenbridger Registeren spervspapenet the Post Pifice keltes donoupecesserivrerecn tewigwsoibocialist Organiser andiarern e personal papacıty unless otherwise stated..
Scan page 4
Locked in an obsessive dialogue of bombs, bullets, and, occasionally, words, with Britain, these "Republicans" ignore the central problem for t's been a funny old year on the industrial front. Plenty of INSIDE THE old-style Irish nationalist forces: the opposition of one Northern Ireland - but only of a minority. In the recent southern Irish election, Provisional Sinn Fein got only 1.5% of the vote, which shows how far apart the Catholics on the two sides of the border have grown.
The idea that either the fundeployment of massive resources by the British and European Community governments to change that.
We advocate working-class unity, but we have no simple solution. Certain things should be clear, however. Socialist Organiser No. 545 page 4 process.
The way out of the bloody mess in Northern Ireland is not through trying to "unite Ireland" by force, but through uniting the Irish people, and in the first place Irish workers.
What the PIRA want would be disastrous. If they won, coercing the Protestants into a united Ireland, it would be -or risk becoming - the present situation in Northern Ireland writ much larger. They never can win. Sectarian civil war and a new bloody partition would come long
----- pull-quotes -----
territory of the "Protestant state" "Karl Marx knew what he was talking when he said nation which
Keeping down the Catholics, Northern
Continued on page 4 *The emancipatiomof the workina