Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Talk, talk

Socialist Organiser no. 544, 2 December 1992 · scan p. 14 · about 1,200 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

/ e live in a capitalist world. Production is social; ownership of the social means of production is private.

Ownership by a state which serves those who own most of the means of production is also essentially "private"

Those who own the means of pro duction buy the labour power of those who own nothing but their labour-power and set them to work. At work they produce more than the equivalent of their wages. The difference (today in Britain it may be more than £20,000 a year per worker) is taken by the capital ist. This is exploitation of wage-labour by capital, and it is the basic cell of capitalist society, its very heart-beat.

Everything else flows from that. The relentless drive for profit and accumulation decrees the judgmen of all things in existence by their relationship of productivity and profitability.

From that come such things as the savage exploitation of Brazilian goldminers, whose life expectancy is now less than 40 years; the working to death — it is officially admitted by the government! — of its employees by advanced Japanese capitalism; and also the economic neglect and virtual abandonment to ruin and starvation of "unprofitable" areas like Bangladesh and parts of Africa. Fety tore cal on protest sock rom that comes the cultural ety force-fed on profitable papFrom it come products with "built-in obsolescence" and a society orientated to the grossly wasteful production and reproduction of shoddy goods, not to the development of leisure and culture.

From it come mass unemployment, the development of a vast and growing underclass, living in ghettos and the recreation in some American cities of the worst Third World conditions.

From it comes the unfolding ecoaccept their own exploitation and abuse, and to prevent real democratic self-control developing with the forms of what they call democracy. They use tabloid propaganda or — as in the 1984-85 miners strike — savage and illegal police violence, as they need to. They have used fascist gangs when they need to, and will use them again, if necessaryAgainst this system we seek to convince the working class - the wage slaves of the capitalist system — to fight for socialism.

Socialism means the abolition wage slavery, the taking of the social economy out of private ownership into common cooperative ownership. It means the realisation of the old demands for liberty, equality, and fraternity.

Under socialism the economy will be run and planned deliberately and democratically: market mechanisms will cease to be our master, and will be cut down and re-shaped to serve broadly sketched-out and planned, rational social goals.

We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under workers' control.

The working class can win reforms within capitalism, but we can only win socialism by overthrowing capitalism and by breaking the state power - that is, the monopoly of violence and reserve violence — now held by the capitalist class. We want a democracy much fuller than the present West minster system — a workers' democracy, with elected representatives recallable at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and managers' privileges.

Socialism can never be built in one country alone. The workers in every country have more in common with workers in other countries than with their own capitalist or Stalinist rulers. We support national liberation struggles and workers' struggles worldwide, including the struggles of workers and oppressed nationalities in the ex-Stalinist states of Eastern SICIENICE COLUMIN recognised that humans ince it has been generally Devolved from some prehuman but definitely nonhuman apes, people have speculated as to how our peculiarly human character could have developed. For instance, how did language arise? Our closest relatives are capable of learning sign language (they are physically incapable of making sounds like us) and even of using it in quite inventive ways. But they do not use their signs in the way that humans use words.

So why and how did our ancestors, perhaps similar to the modern chimpanzees, take the first steps towards the sort of communication that allows us to discuss why and how our ancestors.... etc, etc!? Evidence is, unfortunately, scanty. What little there is has been discussed by such anthropologists as Robin Dunbar (New Scientist two weeks ago) and Marxist Chris Knight* Dunbar looks at the differences between human and primate societies for clues. He notes that in the social species of baboons and chimps a considerable period of time is spent in mutual grooming. Intense social bonds are thus formed which give primate bands a highly structured nature. The many complex social relationships of primates are reflected in the relatively large size of the part of the brain, the neocortex, to conscious thought.

There may well have been an advantage to being able to live in large groups and thus favoured the evolution of a large neocortex to be able to handle the enormous amount of social information entailed. Dunbar points out that baboons and chimps, who are ground living species with a need to live in large groups for protection, have the largest neocortices for their body weight of all but ourselves. Here Dunbar carries out an intriguing comparison. Extrapolating from the size of the typical group of chimps or baboons, he calculates a typical group size for a primate with a neocortex the same size as our own. This gives a figure of about 150.

Looking at sizes of actual human groups, he finds that the "clan" grouping of huntergatherer people average about 150 in size, that archaeology suggests populations of 120150 for Middle Eastern villages of 8,000 years ago, that fighting units in the British (and Roman!) armies number some 130-150, that small companies undergo a change when staff exceed about 150 and so on.

But if grooming holds primate bands together, what would this mean for the hypothetical ape with a humansized brain? Dunbar estimates they would have to spend about 40% of their time grooming. This would seriously limit their ability to get enough food to eat. So Dunbar looks for a more efficient way of carrying out the functions of grooming and comes up with language. By comparing human and chimp group sizes, Dunbar estimates we need a means of communication about three times as efficient as grooming, which can only involve one groomer and one groomed. Dunbar claims that most conversation groups are made up of one talker and three or four listeners. Any larger and the groups tend to fragment. The groups tend to talk about social matters of "gossip". Surveying people in his university's refectory, Dunbar claims that gossip takes up some 70% of conversation time.

Language may well have largely developed not to aid hunting and gathering of food but to cement social relationships back at the camp. All this is, of course, speculation supported, to some extent, by circumstantial evidence. But it is interesting, nevertheless, perhaps because it is a form of gossip! * Who was kind enough to send me several papers by himself, including one on the origins of human language.

From Friday 18 to Tues. day 22 December the Alliance for Workers' Liberty is holding an intensive political school. This

----- pull-quotes -----

for Workers Liberty School

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 544

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →