Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Many parents smack because they think it is right

Socialist Organiser no. 544, 2 December 1992 · scan pp. 12–14 · Gary Scott · about 1,840 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Ithough on the surface and Sigrid Fisher [SO536 540] might seem to be talking about different issues, there is a significant point that Sigrid Fisher is, in my opinion, missing. The easiest way to illustrate this is to compare SO's fundamentally accepted ideas on rape with the views that Sigrid has expressed on however much we may understand the social conditions which produce men who commit rape, we do not excuse rape. Sigrid says she does not excuse condone smacking. So far so good.

However, SO would also say that we do not content ourselves with arguing for a fundamental change in social conditions in order to combat rape. We propose specific measures, and also we argue against the ideology of male domination which feeds rape. Belinda's article specifically puts the case against the ideas about children which condone smacking.

What Sigrid does not concede is that smacking is not simply a response to provocation/stress (the rapist's justification she me on, 1 was sexually frustrated etc.). Smacking is considered to be fair enough, and many parents smack, not out of any great anger or frustration, but because they believe that this is the right way to treat children, to shape them, to mould them, to bring them up.

In all sorts of ways, adults underestimate children, and abuse their sense of autonomy and self-esteem. Many adults particularly underestimate the intensity of children's emotions, and their level of comprehension. Adults talk to children, or more often fail to talk to them, ignore them, in a way which interacting adults would find offensive.

Because children are so dependent on adults, and because they are not as articulate, it is important that socialists defend the rights of children, including their right to personal respect that we stand up for eagerly in the cases of women, blacks, gays and other oppressed adult groups.

I suggest that passing comments about the social pressures which lead individuals to abuse members of these adult groups would generally not go unchecked in SO.

Janet Burstall Australia

Scan page 13

Blade Runner, recently re-released in director Ridley Scott's own cut, is a famous sci-fi movie set in 2019.

This is the future, and it's hideous, claustrophobic. The sets are dark and steamy; people grub for a living in an overcrowded hell.

Harrison Ford plays Deckard. man hired by the Tyrell Corporation to kill four of their escaped replicants. These custom-built humanoid slaves are trying to get their four-year life span extended.

For me, the film raises the question: what does it mean to be human? The replicants want more than anything to live; compared to the "real" people we see, they're the only true humans in the movie.

Other people see it differently. Is it about God? Is it trying to show the wreck and ruin unbridled capitalism will on humanity?

Judge for yoursell. T most enjoyable films I've he Crying Game is one of the seen in ages. It's well-constructed, and full of surprises. It starts out with an IRA kidnap, but it isn't really about the IRA. Songsifor com ockasto socialistsoNoml.

früerad enhand Jessi Everything no in ve win.

Nays sorben peelentures Wealt conquer ail Helprems Neween moven derafrid Heijustones now averago!

hiyaJolma willisure redeep us hisorings deny pompkent Arthur scarAssmen Tony Bennnasmussertisthes Wed keep methin forever, He is endshowerthe rest.

fonock relpuempptabea ohn wilhearnae Golden Vitoris sand emill beneatan. L rotsia mo viankiskswow insinners. Do nptiheed aword hey say! bundena Johmfers oursewsur Leading us to victory!

bindit wilcome rotty Minest ill tell you this, pal niRan kissımyducking arse!

JP Wathieson It's the story of Fergus, an IRA volunteer, who discovers he's been wrong to join up, that he doesn't have the nature of a killer, even for a cause he believes in.

When he and his gang kidnap Jody, an off-duty black British soldier, Fergus is the only one who treats him kindly. The rest of the gang are harsh or indifferent. To them, Jody is not a person; he's a tool to be used, someone they hope to exchange for one of their captive comrades. They don't want to think of him as human; if they did, they couldn't use him.

Despite the strangeness of their situation and the power imbalance between them, Jody and Fergus connect. Sensing that he is to die, Jody asks Fergus to contact Dil, his lover in Britain, to pass on a last message.

When Fergus makes contact with Dil, he feels attracted. Yet when Dil reciprocates, Fergus's guilt about Jody's fate makes him hesitate.

By this time, the IRA have been pushed into the background. The film focuses instead on the odd courtship that springs up between Fergus and Dil. What happens between them helps him understand who he is and what he wants in life.

The IRA are not really central to the plot; they're the device that sets it in motion. Director Neil Jordan seems to have placed Fergus in the IRA more from the drama inherent in the situation than from any desire to work through the issues.

Issues are raised, but they're not dealt with; they're merely stated for the record. Fergus fights the British because he doesn't think the British should be in Ireland — end of story. Jody's reason for joining up is even briefer — it was a job.

Neither Jody nor Fergus seem what they're meant to be - soldiers in a war. Fergus, who's volunteered, hasn't thought things through. He hasn't accepted, or perhaps he hasn't realised, that joining up will turn him into something he doesn't want to be — a person who could kill another person, and think nothing of it.

The rest of the gang are like that, in spades, and they start to worry about Fergus - none more so than Jude, the woman who lured Jody into the trap. Jude is the hardest of these hard men, so it's a wry joke when the rest of the gang expect her to be "womanly" when they expect her to comfort the prisoner, to make the tea.

Jody simply isn't like a soldier. He's slack and soft, and trusting, terribly trusting; he's more babe in the wood than British Army. You wonder how someone so open, so vulnerable, could have survived Army life at all, much less active service in Northern Ireland.

Of course, Jody has to seem human, or we wouldn't care him. We have to be made to see he isn't hateful.

But if that's the point Jordan is trying to make — that the British (especially the put-upon Black British) are people too, just like us Irish — it's a weak point. Wars aren't stopped by appeals to people's humanity.

Jody may not be hateful to us, but he's hateful to most of the gang in the film. They hate what he stands for, and they have a right to. In IRA terms, it's Fergus who's out of line. If that puts him on the side of "humanity" (and Jordan seems to think it does), that's still no answer to the questions raised. The conflict isn't as simple as that.

After all, there's little humanity in the status quo in Northern Ireland, with its random bombings and tit-for-tat killings. Fergus may find his own redemption in rejecting the hard man philosophy, but that's still no answer for Northern Ireland.

Jordan is really more interested in the personal, and he does full justice to Fergus's shifts and scruples. Fergus is low key and likeable; his diffidence is winning. Yet he seems out of it, disconnected. It's hard to believe he volunteered for the IRA. It's hard to imagine him caring enough about anything to risk his life for it.

Yet he does risk his life, he does learn to care. He's redeemed. Don't miss it.

ga Book Gary Scott reviews A Radica Lawyer in Victorian England: WP Roberts and the Struggle for Workers Rights by Raymond Challinor * his book covers much of the ground covered by Challinor and Ripley in "The Miners' Association" (reviewed in SO 543). It deals with Roberts' battle against the Bond (a harsh employment contract adopted by mining bosses during the middle of the last century) and also deals with the interaction of Chartism and the trade unions.

WP Roberts came from a middle class background. His father was vicar of Chelmsford and, later, master of the local grammar school. Though not especially wealthy, he was able to send his son to Charterhouse Public School.

WP Roberts began his career as a lawyer dealing with conventional cases, and, politically, he supported the Tories. By 1837, however, his political views had changed. He became one of the leading figures in the newly-formed Bath Working Men's Association, and spent the rest of his life fighting for workers' rights.

As a delegate to the 1842 Chartist convention he helped draft and present the second national petition and in 1848, at mass demonstrations before the presentation of the third and final Chartist petition, he appealed to Irish rebels to make common cause with the Chartists against the British government.

Throughout his life he supported the creation of co-operatives and friendly societies. He was treasurer of the Chartist Land Company and was to die in 1871 at Heronsgate, where the first settlement of the Land Company had been situated.

WP Roberts is remembered mainly for the legal work he carried out for the Miners' Association. Engels said of him, "he conducted a crusade against despotic Justices of the Peace and Truck Masters such as had never been known in England... the name of Roberts became a terror to the mineowners... such was the dread of this... lightning Attorney General who seemed to be everywhere at once."

WP Roberts' work clearly shows that the legal fight for workers' rights can strengthen trade union organisation. After the defeat of the coalowners over the repressive system known as the Bond, workers who had previously been submissive gained confidence and began to form union lodges. The Durham Miners' Association came to life and miners at Wearmouth colliery had painted on their banner - and it remains today - the courtroom scene of WP Roberts breaking the Bond.

As well as telling the story of a neglected figure in labour history, Challinor sheds light on the methods used by the state to defeat working class and republican movements.

The book covers a lot of ground, dealing with events like the Newport Uprising and the case of the Manchester Martyrs, and the state's response to such events, issues that are particularly relevant today, given the attacks the labour movement has been facing. Challinor underlines the need for socialists to understand how the law is used to undermine workers' rights, and the way in which the law can be used to fight for workers' rights.

The book ends with the optimistic prediction: "when that happens, perhaps the spirit of WP Roberts will against stalk the land."

Scan page 14

gani:

----- pull-quotes -----

smacking children. SO's view of rape, as I understand it, it that

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 544

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →