Abusive men are not powerless, little creatures
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-12-02Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
No.8 ...Workers against Gorbachev Kowalewski on Solidarnose, ...L Movies, Scottish Assembly (1987)$0.90 STARVED. On and on and on? 1987 British Election, ¡BATTEREN Permanent Revolution, DEFIANT Architecture, INLA, 'Perdition' (1987): E0.90 MAGNIFICENT 3-6 are in short supply, but can be obtained at special prices: write in for details Ilusions of Power: the local government left 1979-85.. £0.60 THE 1984-5 STRIKE was rather dismayed by Rebecca Van Homan's article regarding obscene phone calls (SO 542). Whilst I agree with her that better screening and support from British Telecom [BT] would help women in combating obscene phone calls, her lack of any analysis regarding obscene calls was rather remiss, considering tha feminists, including radical, Marxist and socialist feminists, have been debating and making public these types of issues for the past twenty years.
The only suggestion that Van Homan can come up with is that i is most probably men who need tc somehow compensate for their 'powerlessness' in their everyday lives and that this has to be "reclaimed elsewhere' i.e. through threatening women.
This is precisely the stereotypica viewpoint that feminists have bee attacking; the notion of pathetic, little men who are in some sense not responsible for their actions. Who are these 'powerless' men?
Stanley and Wise, who wrote about their experience of obscene phone callers during the 1970s, argue that the men who rang them were in no way pathetic, that the phone callers deliberately and consciously chose to verbally assault women [Stanley and Wise, Breaking Out: Feminist Consciousness and Research, RKP].
Feminists often get accused of placing too much emphasis on women's victimisation, yet the fi that most sexual violence is directed towards women still ne to be addressed.
Liz Kelly, who has researched effects of sexual violence on women, argues that "obscene phone calls are a form of intrusion.. which women cannot anticipate. It is this, alongside the intention to shock, humiliate and frighten women, which makes these calls a form of sexual violence." [See Liz Kelly, Surviving Sexual Violence, Polity Press].
Tighter regulations by British Telecom will not eradicate obscene phone calls, although it may deter a few men, just as legislation regarding other forms of assault, such as rape and sexual harassment, has had very little impact on its occurrence.
I do not subscribe to a universal concept of patriarchy nor indeed: universal concept of gender, both have to be located within an historical and cultural context. However, neither do do I accept the view of obscene phone calls that is reduced to the level of production and the economic sphere. Men's violence towards women pre-dates capitalism. Men's power over women in patriarchal societies result in men assuming rights of sexual access to and intimacy with women, and certain levels of force, coercion abuse being seen as justified.
I have only recently started subscribing to Socialist Organiser and, while I hold with many of your viewpoints, I feel that issues such as gender and race within your editorial are marginalised, which is why, I presume, you feel the need to have such a column as Women's Eye. If you are going to bring up issues such as obscene phone calls within this column, I suggest a more critical analysis is needed.
Antonella Manci North Lond‹