Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Karl Marx and his ideas By Vladimir Lenin

Socialist Organiser no. 544, 2 December 1992 · scan pp. 10–11 · Vladimir Lenin · about 1,978 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

In order to change the world, socialists need to understand it socialists need to Marxism. For many decades now a sort of pidgin "Marxism" has been used by the rulers in the Stalinist states as the basis of their state religion. In the west, a synthetic pastiche of Marxism spread in the universities, completely divorced from the working class and its struggles. Real Marxism has been bowdlerise The revolutionary Marxism of Marx has been the property of small groups, starved of resources and under relentless pressure from the Stalinists and bourgeoisie. The "Marxism" of many of these groups fossilised into unthinking dogma. Serious socialis need to go back to the exts of the original teachers of revolutionary Marxism. Here we print the first in a series by Lenin, outlining the basic ideas of Karl Marx and Frederick Engels. If you want to be a better fighter against capitalism — study it!

transposed and head." [Capital, Vol I]. and eclipsed.

translated inside In full conformity with Man's materialist phi losophy, and expounding it, Engels wrote it Anti-Dühring (which Marx read in thi manuscript): "The unity of the world does not consist in its existence... The real unity of the world consists in its materiality, and this is proved... by the long and laborious development of philosophy and natural science...

Motion is the form of existence of matter.

Never and nowhere has there been or can there be matter without motion... Matter without motion is just as unthinkable as motion without matter... If we enquire...

Marx was the genius who continued what thought and consciousness are, the ideological currents of the whence they come we find that they are nineteenth century products of the human brain, and that man Marx's teaching himself is a product of nature, developing in and along with his environment. ObviMarxism is the system of the views and teach- ously, therefore, the products of the human ings of Marx. Marx was the genius who contin- brain, being in the last analysis likewise ued and completed the three chief ideological products of nature, do not contradict the currents of the nineteenth century, represented rest of nature, but correspond to it.' respectively by the three most advanced coun [Anti-Dühring] tries of humanity:

Again: "Hegel was an idealist; that is to say, • classical German philosophy; for him the thoughts in his head were not more • classical English political economy; and or less abstract reflections [in the original: • French Socialism combined with French Abbilder, images, copies; sometimes Engels revolutionary doctrines. speaks of "imprints"] of real things and processThe remarkable consistency and unity of con- es; but, on the contrary, things and their evoluception of Marx's views, acknowledged even by tion were, for Hegel, only reflections in reality of his opponents, which in their totality constitute modern materialism and modern scientific the Idea that existed somewhere even prior to the world."

Socialism as the theory and programme of the In his Ludwig Feuerbach — in which Engels labour movement in all the civilised countries of expounds his own and Marx's views on Feuerthe world, make it necessary that we present a bach's philosophy, and which Engels sent to the brief outline of his world conception in general press after re-reading an old manuscript, written before proceeding to the chief contents of Marxby Marx and himself in 1844-1845, on Hegel, ism, namely, the economic doctrine of Marx.

Feuerbach, and the materialist conception of Philosophic Materialism history, [the German ideology] — Engels writes:

"The great basic question of all, and espeBeginning with the years 1844-1845, when his cially of recent, philosophy, is the question views were definitely formed, Marx was a materialist!, and especially a follower of Feuerbach; of the relationship between thought and existence, between spirit and nature... even in later times, he saw Feuerbach's weak Which is prior to the other: spirit or side only in this, that his materialism was not nature? Philosophers are divided into two sufficiently consistent and comprehensive. great camps, according to the way in which "epoch-making" significance consisted in his For Marx, Feuerbach's world-historic and they have answered this question. Those who declare that spirit existed before having decisively broken away from the idealism nature, and who, in the last analysis, thereof Hegel, and in his proclamation of materialfore, assume in one way or another that the ism, which even in the eighteenth century, espeworld was created... have formed the idealcially in France, had become "a struggle not List camp. The others, who regard nature as only against the existing political institutions, primary, belong to the various schools of and against... religion and theology, but also... materialism." against every form of metaphysics" (as "intoxi[Ludwig Feuerbach] cated speculation" in contradistinction to "sober philosophy"). Any other use (in a philosophic sense) of the "For Hegel the thought process (which he terms idealism and materialism is only confusactually transforms into an independent ing. Marx decidedly rejected not only idealism, subject, giving to it the name of "idea") is always connected in one way or another with the demiurge [creator/ of the real... In my religion, but also the views of Hume and Kant, view, on the other hand, the ideal is nothing that are especially widespread in our day, as well other than the material when it has been as agnosticism?, criticism, positivism in various forms; he considered such philosophy as a "reactionary" concession to idealism, at best as a "shamefaced manner of admitting materialism in through the back door while denying it before the world."

(On this question see, besides the above-mentioned works of Engels and Marx, a letter of Marx to Engels, dated December 12,1866, in which Marx, taking cognisance of an utterance of the well-known naturalist, T. Huxley, who 'in a more materialistic spirit than he has manifested in recent years" declared that "as long as we actually observe and think, we cannot get away from materialism," reproaches him for once more, leaving a new "back door" open to agnosticism, and Humeism).

It is especially important that we should note Marx's opinion concerning the relation between freedom and necessity: "Freedom is the recognition of necessity. Necessity is blind only so far as it is not understood" (Engels, Anti-Dühring).

This means acknowledgment of the objective reign of law in nature and of the dialectical transformation of necessity into freedom (at the same time, an acknowledgment of the transformation of the unknown but knowable "thing-initself" into the "thing-for-us," of the "essence of things" into "phenomena").

Marx and Engels pointed out the following major shortcomings of the "old" materialism, including Feuerbach's (and, a fortiori, the "vulgar" materialism of Buchner, Vogt and Moleschott)

it was "predominantly mechanical," not taking into account the latest developments of chemistry and biology (in our day it would be necessary to add the electric theory of matter);

it was nonhistorical, non-dialectical (was metaphysical, in the sense of being antidialectical, and did not apply the standpoint of evolution consistently and all-sidedly;

it regarded "human nature" abstractly, and not as a "synthesis" of (definite, concrete-historical) "social relationships" - and thus only "interpreted" the world, whereas it was a question of "changing" it, that is, it did not grasp the significance of "practical revolutionary activity:"

Dialectics Marx and Engels regarded Hegelian dialectics, the theory of evolution most comprehensive, rich in content and profound, as the greatest achievement of classical German philosophy. All other formulations of the principle of development, of evolution, they considered to be one-sided, poor in content, distorting and mutilating the actual course of development of nature and society (a course often consummated in leaps and bounds, catastrophes, revolutions).

"Marx and I were almost the only persons who rescued conscious dialectics... [from the swamp of idealism, including Hegelianism] by transforming it into the materialist conception of nature... Nature is the test of dialectics, and we must say that science has supplied a vast and daily increasing mass of material for this test, thereby proving that, in the last analysis nature proceeds dialectically and not metaphysically this was written before the discovery of radium, electrons, the transmutation of elements, etc.l."

gain, Engels writes:

*The great basic idea that the world is not to be viewed as a complex of fully fashioned objects, but as a complex of processes in which apparently stable objects, no less than the images of them inside our heads (our concepts), are undergoing incessant changes, arising here and disappearing there and which with all apparent accident and in spite of all momentary retrogression, ultimately constitutes a progressive development — this great basic idea has, particularly since the time of Hegel, so deeply penetrated the general consciousness that hardly any one will now venture to dispute it in its general form.

But it is one thing to accept it in words, quite another thing to put it in practice on every occasion and in every field of investigation.

In the eyes of dialectic philosophy, nothing is established for all time, nothing is absolute or sacred. On everything and in everything it sees the stamp of inevitable decline;

nothing can resist it save the unceasing process of formation and destruction, the unending ascent from the lower to the higher — a process of which that philosophy itself is only a simple reflection within the thinking brain."

Thus dialectics, according to Marx, is "the scice of the general laws of motion both of the ernal world and of human thinking." This revolutionary side of Hegel's philosophy as adopted and developed by Marx. Dialectical aterialism "does not need any philosophy towing above the other sciences." Of former lilosophies there remain "the science of thinkg and its laws formal logic and dialectics." Dialectics, as the term is used by Marx in conrmity with Hegel, includes what is now called e theory of cognition, or epistemology, or loseology, a science that must contemplate its bject matter in the same way - historically, udying and generalising the origin and devel›ment of cognition, the transition from nonnsciousness to consciousness.

In our times, the idea of development, of evotion, has almost fully penetrated social coniousness, but it has done so in other ways, not rough Hegel's philosophy. Still, the same idea, formulated by Marx and Engels on the basis ¡ Hegel's philosophy, is much more compreinsive, much more abundant in content than e current theory of evolution. • A development that repeats, as it were, the stages already passed, but repeats them a different way, on a higher plane ("negation of negation");

a development, to speak, in spirals, a straight line;

a development in leaps and bounds, trophes, revolutions;

"intervals of gradualness";

transformation of quantity into quality;

inner impulses for development, imparted by the contradiction, the conflict of different forces and tendencies reacting on a given body or inside a given phenomenon or within a given society;

interdependence, and the closest, indissoluble connection between all sides of every phenomenon (history disclosing ever new sides), a connection that provides the one world process of motion proceeding according to law... ...such are some of the features of dialectics as a doctrine of evolution more full of meaning than the current one.] ates A materialist — as distinct from idealist — here does not mean a brutal, Thatcherite grabber, nor does idealist mean someone with high ideals. Philosophical materialism is the belief that matter is the sole reality, and mind a special function of matter. Philosophical idealism, holds the opposite, that mind, ultimately the mind of God, is the fundamental reality.

Ludwig Feuerbach was a German philosopher who in the 1840s counterposed a crude materialism to the then-prevailing religious idealism. George Hegel was an idealist and the leading German philosopher in the early 19th century.

Agnosticism here means a denial that it is possible to know one way or the other. Hume was an 18th century English philosopher who taught that only ideas exist.

Scan page 11

st Organiser No. 544 page 11

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 544

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →