Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Accidents will happen T what they seem"

Socialist Organiser no. 544, 2 December 1992 · scan p. 4 · about 609 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

"historic" and "inalienable" links between the Labour Party and the trade unions. They appeared to close the door on any major changes in that relationship, but some of us at least had an inkling that things were not what Despite all their declarations of commitment to the link the union barons also voted to throw everything into the melting pot and set up a review into every aspect of the Various factors were at work. The main union barons were asserting themselves against the new Smith leadership - telling him that he could not simply expect them to rubber-stamp everything he did. It had 'become known' that Smith himself "favoured" the end of the block vote. Morris, Edmonds and Tuffin were also reflecting pressure from their own rank and file who want to keep the link. The union leaders were endorsing the "principle' of collective trade union representation in the Party, the better to be able to gut that representation of any real substance.

They didn't so much want to keep the link' as to bureaucratise it and thus immunise themselves and John Smith against the influx of any inconvenient rank and file The problem for the Morris/Edmonds axis is that instead of putting some gutless, unprincipled, slimy, left faker who would do their bidding in charge of the review, they put in place someone who actually believes in some form of collective, trade-union representation in the This "dangerous red' is Lewis Minkin, an academic fron Manchester University, one-time left-winger, former adviser to Neil Kinnock, virulent anti-Trotskyist, and a man with an obsessional desire to collect trivia about the Labour Party and its relationship with the unions — a As a result, Minkin has actually tried to do what he was His report is unlikely to please anyone. GMB boss John Edmonds is already stabbing one of Minkin's closest collaborators, Tom Burlinson of the GMB, in the back. Burlinson's own region has disowned their man's great work. On the right, Labour MP John Spellar, an old friend of Eric Hammond, was apoplectic. "The report talks of collective representation in a way that went out fashion in the Daily Worker in the fifties."

Minkin's proposal to put all trade unionists into one pool as 'registered sympathisers' in an electoral college system for the selection of MPs will mean the beginning of the end of collective trade union branch representation And giving the MPs a guaranteed 20% say in policymaking is a very big step backwards indeed. It makes one MP's vote worth about the same as those of 6,000 rank and file trade unionists. (A unique form of one member, Unless Minkin is forced to dramatically rewrite the report so that it is unrecognisable in its present form, what we could see at this year's union conferences and then at Party conference, is a three-way split — hardline supporters of breaking the link, the Minkinite middle-ground, probably supported by people like Tom Sawyer of NUPE, and principled defenders of a collective trade No group is guaranteed a majority. Remember, a poll General Secretaries this September declared Minkin's favoured option of trade unionists becoming registered supporters' a non-runner by a very big margin indeed.

What started as a stitch-up looks like fast becoming a Things are rarely INSIDE THE The appearance UNIONIS this week of a draft report on the future of relations between the Labour Party and the unions serves to underline this old pearl of wisdom.

At this year's Labour Party conference the GMB, TGWU and UCW delegations threw their weight behind the left and voted to defend the they seemed.

union/Party relationship. heir is beginning be heard

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 544

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →