Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Anti-racists protest against racist attacks in Germany. Economic…]

Socialist Organiser no. 544, 2 December 1992 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,291 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Anti-racists protest against racist attacks in Germany. Economic and social oppression in Europe will not be fought by nationalistic slogans policies "No coupled Europe to Maastricht" must be coupled with "yes to Europe"

The Maastricht Treaty is mainly the mark, the franc, the pound, and so on — with a single European money.

Socialist Organiser objects to the Maastricht Treaty because the European Central Bank which the Treaty proposes is to be "independent", i.e. run by bankers with no democratic control over them. In other words, the Treaty is a blueprint for a sort of "Euro-monetarism", with Euro-bankers imposing tight limits on public spending and no chance of a democratic comeback against those bankers.

We believe that the European labour movement should fight for the European Central Bank, and all the machinery of the European Community, to be under the democratic control of an elected European Parliament. The labour movement should demand that the Central Bank's control of credit be used to rebuild public services, basic industry, and jobs, across Europe.

Workers' rights and conditions should be levelled up across Europe, to the best existing standard, not levelled down.

The cost should be met by taxation and confiscation of the wealth of the rich, and by cuts in military spending. The existing European Community tax - Value-Added Tax, a tax which hits harder at the poor than at the rich - should be replaced by progressive direct taxes on incomes, wealth, and property.

A struggle for this alternative to Maastricht could unite labour and working-class movements across Europe, and get them all moving for the same demands.

However, the great majority of the people saying "No to Maastricht!" would not want our alternative at all.

Margaret Thatcher, bit, and the Sun say no to Maastricht, and yes to a Britain which will be a cheap offshore European production site for American and Japanese multinationals, with lower wages and less social legislation and fewer workers' rights than the continent.

The French fascist leader Jean-Marie Le Pen, and the majority of France's big right-wing party, the Gaullists, say no to Maastricht, and yes to bigoted French nationalism.

A sizeable minority of the German bosses and bankers say no to Maastricht, and yes to a looser European Community in which they can dominate by sheer economic strength, without being tied down by formal political structures for unity, and without having to pay out a lot of money to poorer European countries like Ireland, Portugal, Spain and Greece to help them join an integrated European economy.

None of these dominant mainstream alternatives to Maastricht is any good from a socialist point of view. That is why, in France's referendum on Maastricht, the French revolutionary socialists of Lutte Ouvrière called on workers to abstain — "neither yes with Chirac, nor no with Le Pen!"

11 million French voters did abstain, and nearly one million spoiled their ballot papers as a protest.

Unfortunately, most of Britain's Labour Left has different ideas. They have been campaigning round the single slogan "No to Maastricht!" , and next Saturday, 5 December, they will be gathering in London for a conference. All their campaigning over the past year indicates that, although the conference is titled "Alternatives to Maastricht" , serious alternatives are precisely what they will not discuss!

The conference, organised by Ken Livingstone, features Labour rightwingers Bryan Gould, Austin Mitchell, and Peter Shore among its main speakers. Shore is a member of the ultra-Thatcherite Bruges Group! Apparently Livingstone and his friends believe that saying no to Maastricht is an issue which overrides all divisions between right and left, and all questions about what our alternatives are.

They will make speeches about the terrible welfare cuts implied by Maastricht's Euro-monetarism — as if the Tories who shut pits and hospitals so casually needed to sign a treaty in Holland in order to continue their cuts!

They will use "Maastricht" "Brussels" ', and "Europe" as scapegoats and lightning-rods — targets on which to divert the anger and resentment which should really be channelled into a fight against the Tories and the British bosses. They will be vague about what they propose positively - but they will suggest, again and again, that looser ties in Europe, less integration, and continued barriers between countries, will at least ease or reduce the pain. They will talk about "British sovereignty" and the needs of "our" industry.

In short, they will not say straight out what they all said ten or fifteen years ago "Britain should get out of the European Community" but they will get as close to it they can.

This is to tilt at windmills, because Maastricht has become largely a dead letter.

And it is wrong for socialists for more fundamental reasons, too.

An "independent" Britain, firmly separated from Europe, is a stupid idea under capitalism and utter nonsense under socialism.

Modern technologies and methods of production long ago outgrew the limited framework of the European nation-states.

The bosses know it. That is why they have been trying to create a united European economy — slowly, clumsily, and with constant difficulty because of their national rivalries.

From a socialist point of view, too, a more dynamic united European capitalism is better than a stagnant, divided European capitalism. It is certainly better than a divided European capitalism lurching into trade wars and then shooting wars, as in 1914-18 and 1939-45. A more dynamic capitalism does not guarantee better conditions for the workers, but it does mean there is more room for a fight than in a stagnant, backward capitalism.

We are against a united Europe being capitalist — but we are not against a capitalist Europe being united! Even under capitalism, European unity would bring advantages. More workers moving from country to country; more workers speaking several languages and familiar with several cultures; more similar conditions for workers all across the continent - all these factors must increase the chance of building a united European labour movement.

And that united European labour movement is essential for socialism. Capitalism can be developed in single countries, separated by high MUS barriers from the rest of the world. It can only be a backward, inefficient sort of capitalism, but it is possible.

Socialism in a single country is utterly impossible. For socialism, we need to be able to produce enough for everyone to live comfortably, and to do it without anyone being exhausted and overworked. We have to take the best productive and technological achievements of capitalism, and build on them — not go backwards. -In Europe, already closely intermeshed by capitalism, it is nonsense to imagine even starting on socialist development in a single country alone. The workers of that country would either spread their cause to the other countries, or be crushed by the surrounding capitalist powers.

To combat nationalism, and build European workers' unity, is the most important task for socialists everywhere on the continent. Those who campaign against plans for a united capitalist Europe by objecting primarily to it being a united Europe, rather than to it being capitalist, are only helping the nationalists.

albhumanseigs without Assist quali set ovirage..

Kakl Mari SaalistOrgewisen PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Newsdesk 07-63b796b Latest date for reports: Monday Editorshine Mehra Published by: WL Publications Ltd, PO Box 823 London SE15 4NA Printed by Tridant Press, Edenbridge Registered as a newspaper at the Post Office Articles do not necessarily reflect de viewswof biocialist Organiser andarevna personal capacity unless otherwise stated

Scan page 4

ser

----- pull-quotes -----

T about replacing the different West European currencies —

SCHLUS MIT DER ASYL BAT

"To combat nationalism, build European workers' unity, is the most important task for socialists everywhere the continent."

he emancipatiomof the warking, classis alsa the emancipation oil

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 544

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →