Genetically engineered animals
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
COLUIVIN
enetic engineering techG niques have made it possible to insert genes from one type of living thing into another, often apparently unrelated, type. Thus, there is the possibility of inserting a gene from some plants into a sheep or of putting growth hormone genes from humans into pigs. We will look later into why people should want to do this. But first, we will consider people's reactions to something that, while apparently bizarre, does not seem worse than many of the other things that are done to animals.
Part of the problem is the terminology used. Even New Scientist ("Guess what's coming to dinner?" by Gail Vines, 14.11.92) falls into the trap of referring to "genetically engineered organisms" when what is meant is organisms containing one gene from another organism", It was ten years ago that a foreign gene was first inserted into an organism. This was a mouse which had been injected with rat growth hormone genes before birth. Consequently, it was twice the size of its litter mates. Now, at least 60,000 "transgenic" animals are produced in British labs alone each year.
Veteran opponent of biotechnology (the new sort — not the old sort of making cheese and yoghurt with mould and bacteria) Jeremy Rifkin believes transgenic techniques will *reduce the whole living planet to commercial property". This more a criticism of the intrusion of capitalist economics than of genetic engineering. Nevertheless, Rifkin has launched the Pure Food Campaign. Its logo, to be displayed by food retailers shows a DNA double helix of the sort found in every cell of every living thing, overstamped with the "forbidden" symbol. The slogan surrounding it reads "We do not sell genetically engineered foods".
Sue Mayer, scientific director of Greenpeace UK, sets the issue within the context of "genetic pollution", the unpredictable spread of DNA from transgenic organisms to others. This, some believe, could destroy the barrier between species. "Do we need a technology that undermines the integrity of nature", she says. But there is no reason why artificially inserted genes should show any greater tendency to escape than any other genes. These genes are, after all, natural genes. Genes do spread across species boundaries naturally and this is how many of these new techniques were developed. However, it occurs almost entirely among bacteria.
Joyce D'Silva of the animal welfare charity, the Athene Trust, points to the ill-effects of traditional animal breeding, giving us crippled broiler chickens and bulls that cannot mate because of their shape. She believes that genetic engineering is unlikely to improve the welfare of farm animals. Once again, this seems a flimsy argument. Logically, there should be a campaign against traditional breeding methods, or at least against perpetuating breeds with particular distressing defects. Already, dog breeders try to eliminate hip and eye disorders from pedigree animals.
Now let us look at the reasons for introducing new genes into living things. In some cases, the purpose is to increase yields. The case is often quoted of the pig with an extra gene for growth hormone. The gene was of human origin, which excites horror among opponents. In fact, human growth hormone is very similar to that from many mammals.
The pig in question suffered badly from arthritis, possibly as a result of its treatment. This is the only ill effect of genetic engineering I have seen mentioned. Other research of this type includes an attempt to increase wool yields by inserting an extra gene for a particular building block of wool into sheep.
Often the motive is to help the organism resist attack by parasites. In Australia, the group working on the woollier sheep is also trying to insert a gene that produces an enzyme called chitinase. This enzyme, which originates from some plants, breaks down chitin, an substance only found in insects. If successful, the gene will allow sheep skin to kill the larvae of blowfly which burrow into it, causing wounds and infection. Other examples of this type involve putting gene! into plants that enable them to produce their own pesticides to kill insects that eat them.
Medical research is another large area. In some cases, genes for useful proteins are put into animals. A British company has produced sheep that make a sub stance in their milk that could b an effective treatment for emphysema. It is difficult to see how this harms the sheep and it is not possible to make it in sufficient quantities by other means.
In other cases, the transgenic animals display conditions similar to ones suffered by humans, such as cancers or cystic sis. Treatments can then investigated before being extended to humans. Some people will oppose this not because it involves genetic engineering but because it involves research on animals, a separate question.
It is a truth missed by most of the arguments about genetic engineering that it is only possiAWL meetings Thursday 19 November "How to beat the Tories" , Leeds AWL meeting. 7.30, Adelphi Hotel. Speaker: John O'Mahony.
"Is revolution possible?"
Nottingham AWL meeting.
8.00, ICC, Mansfield Road.
"Is there a backlash against women?"
Sheffield AWL meeting 7.30, SCCAU, West Street.
Saturday 28 November How to fight and win.
Socialist Organiser rally.
Speakers include: Billy Pye (NUM Executive); Paul Whetton; John O'Mahony:
Jill Mountford and a tubeworker. 7.00, Kingswa College, Sidmouth Street, London WC1.
Five Day School Workers' Liberty is holding a five-day political school, Friday 18 - Tuesday 22 December, in London. ble because of the fundamental unity of life on Earth. All of us, from slime mould to monkey, from cabbage to king, have the same genetic material organised in similar ways. No doubt, there are arguments to be had over the ways genetic engineering is carried out. In part, this can be tackled by laws on animal wel fare. Political and economic The two themes of the course are political economy and our programme.
The economics will cover: why does capitalism have cris the business cycle; unemployment and inflation; the world Sessions on the programme will discus maximum, minimum and transitional demands; the workers" government and the Transitional Programme.
Reading material available from 21 November. Registration costs £5/£2 (waged/unwaged) and accommodation is available in London. To register, contact Mark on 071-639 7965. Also coming up... Saturday 21 November National demonstratio arguments need to be fought out, too, over whether people's livelihoods are threatened by the introduction of cheaper methods of production. But mystical nonsense about "going against nature" is something that no socialist should get tangled up with.
against the Asylum Bill. Assemble: 12.00, H) de Park, London.
Saturday 28 November Burnsall Strikers Support March.
Assemble: 10.30, Fenton Street, Smethwick. Called by GMBU.
abpur Party Spcialists AmMIeN Generai Meeting Labow ki!!
Diane whee
Sait malab December Sheffield Hallam University Stenchessa Mailom Details from LPS c/o 106 Lyham Road hondon SNIDI
Scan page 15
liser