Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A man of many faces

Socialist Organiser no. 543, 19 November 1992 · scan p. 14 · Sean Matgamna · about 1,165 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

man of many faces is ex-Labour leader Michael Foot's rebel nephew, Paul, the Daily Mirror columnist and best known member of the SWP. He has, after thirty years in the SWP, a strange and politically ambivalent relationship with "the party" . The SWP placards him for its meetings as the "Daily Mirror columnist" Foot, for his part, operates in the mass media as the soft, reasonable, reformist face of the r... ... revolutionary leather-jacket tough SWP.

It has happened again and again, over many years and it tells us something important about the SWP. It helps explain why ex-SWers can flip over into prostrate reformism. I'll take three examples.

In the 1979 General Election the SWP while proclaiming itself "the socialist alternative" to the Labour Party, declined to put up candidates, backed the Labour Party! It was as if to say: we'll work the "revolutionary" side of the street, in the unions, and leave the politics to the Labour Party. That is what they still try to do.

Since, in contrast to the active left wing of the Labour Party, they had no connection with the living, critical, oppositional rank and file movement in the political wing of the trade unions, all they could do was uncritically support the discredited Labour Prime Minister, Jim Callaghan. It fell to Foot, in a much-quoted interview in the London Evening Standard, to express the SWP's dualism, the approach which left the political labour movement to the right wing, in all its crassness. He said:

"For the next three weeks 1 am a strong Labour supporter. I am very anxious that a Tory government shouldn't be returned, and I shall be going around to meetings we are having telling everyone to vote Labour" (9 April 1979).

My second example is Foot's pamphlet in the Chatto and Windus "Counterblast" series advocating British withdrawal from Northern Ireland.

As we have often proved in Socialist Organiser, the SWP line on Ireland is not what it seems. They call for Troops Out Now, but usually add some impossible conditions in the small print to cancel it out ("look, boss, I'm not serious"). They demand that Britain should first disarm the Protestants, which implies a lot more troops, and troops for the foreseeable future too.

The SWP tells its members that Troops Out would be the beginning of "Permanent Revolution" in Ireland: the Provisional IRA's nationalist struggle will grow over into a working-class struggle for a socialist revolution. This idea is gibberish, but it is central to securing the consent of thinking SWPers for the "militant" Troops Out Now line. It squares the circle and allows them to avoid an understanding that Troops Out without a political settlement can only mean sectarian civil war and repartition.

There is not a hint of this "Permanent Revolution" argument in Foot's pamphlet. He advocates nothing beyond straight British withdrawal, argued on the level of normal bourgeois politics (and argued very badly, with astonishing journalistic ignorance: as someone said, there are so many ABC errors that when you read in this pamphlet that Ireland has 36 counties you do not automatically conclude that it is a printer's error for the correct figure of 32).

The pamphlet shows Foot once again as the right-wing face of the SWP, presenting its real ideas without benefit of the mystifying "socialist" and "militant" phrasemongering that Socialist Worker and official SWP pamphlets use.

he third example, and the occasion for this footnote, is from Tribune last week. Discussing the affairs of the Daily Mirror in an interview, Foot said:

"I'm amazed at how unconcerned the Left is". At issue is not so much the Mirror's voting advice at election times but its tendency "to take at least a reforming position on a huge variety of issues" (Tribune, 6 November).

But... but... surely the SWP, and its best-known member, are not concerned with reforms? Well, no, officially they are not, but others had better be, or else the ecological balance of British working-class politics will be destroyed. "Politics" is for the Labour Party - and reforming journalism for... Robert Maxwell!

Once more you have the crass dualism, the notion that "politics" - in this case, concern with the sort of reforms, and resistance of Tory counter-reform, around which the labour movement can most readily be mobilised now — is for others, in practice for the right wing (and even, retrospectively, for strike-busting Robert Maxwell, while the revolutionaries look after strikes, demonstrations, and economic struggles, and "build the party" The SWP is a hybrid organisation which combines devotion to "building the party" — as a fetish outside of politics and irrespective of politics — with an essentially anarcho-syndicalist idea of working class action (that is, an idea of working-class socialist revolution growing directly out of strikes and workplace organisation, without a broader political struggle). Therefore it has many historical parallels, none of them quite exact.

Despite differences, the parallel between the SWP and the turn-of-thecentury Russian "Economists" is quite striking. These were rather stodgy and mechanical Marxists who believed it was their job to organise the working class in trade unions, make general socialist propaganda, and thus build a working-class socialist party, while leaving current politics - the struggle against the Tsar (king), who then ruled Russia, for political freedom and parliamentary democracy — as the monopoly of the middle class and its politicians.

Lenin and Trotsky pointed out that since the workers must inevitably be concerned with those immediate political questions, an "Economist" policy by the Marxists would simply push the workers into the arms of the bourgeois and middle-class politicians. The Bolsheviks, led by Lenin, combined trade union organising with socialist propaganda and action by the revolutionary party on immediate "reformist" political issues.

In Britain now, the same approach means that the independent revolutionary socialist organisation, the Alliance for Workers' Liberty, combines trade union work with fraction work in the Labour Party and the putting forward of perspectives and policies for the broad labour movement. It means not putting forward policies - such as the call for "General Strike Now" — that are nonsense for the broad labour movement, however useful they may be in creating a militant image for the phrasemongering revolutionaries abstaining from The SWP's antics can only push workers in the broad labour movement into the arms of the John Smiths - especially when, as now, the Smiths show some little sign of life.

The SWP both denounce the Labour Party, proclaiming themselves the socialist alternative to it, and also leave it in uncontested possession of the entire terrain of current working class politics! It is hard to see the real shape behind their contradictory facets. That is where Paul Foot comes in.

In his role of SWP ambassador to the bourgeoisie and the media, Foot often blurts out the truth about the SWP's politics, without the usual "socialist" obfuscation and phrasemongering. Michael Foot's nephew Paul is thus a useful man to have around.

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINST THETIDE

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 543

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →