General Strike and insurrection
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
The Paris Commune: the importance of the General Strike is that it From page 11 refusal of the leaders of the SFIO, he risks nothing by proposing a general strike to them?
But every Communist worker who has a head on his shoulders must ponder over the crying contradictions of his hapless leaders:
it is impossible, you see, to build workers' militias because the situation is not revolutionary, it is impossible even to carry on propaganda in favour of the arming of the proletariat, that is to say of preparing the workers for a revolutionary situation in the future;
but it is possible, it appears, even today, to call the workers to a general strike despite the absence of a revolutionary situation. In truth, we find transcended here all the boundaries of giddiness and absurdity!
But is the general strike possible in the immediate future? To a question of this sort there is no. a priori answer possible, that is to say, none ready-made. To obtain an answer it is necessary to know how to question. Whom? The masses. How question them? By means of agitation.
Agitation is not only the means of communicating to the masses this or that slogan, calling the masses to action, etc. For a party, agitation is also a means of lending an ear to the masses, of sounding out their moods and thoughts, and reaching this or another decision in accordance with the results. Only the Stalinists have transformed agitation into a noisy monologue. For the Marxists, the Leninists, agitation is always a dialogue with the masses.
But in order that this dialogue give the necessary results, the party must estimate correctly the general situation within the coun try and outline the general course of the immediate struggle. By means of agitation and probing of the masses, the party must bring into its concepts the necessary corrections and exactitude, particularly in everything relating to the rhythm of the movement and the dates for major actions.
The situation in the country has been described above; it bears a prerevolutionary character along with the nonrevolutionary character of the leadership of the proletariat. And since the policy of the proletariat is the principal factor in the development of a revolutionary situation, the nonrevolutionary character of the proletarian leadership checks the transformation of the prerevolutionary situation and by this very thing contributes toward transforming it into a counterrevolutionary situation.
In objective reality there are, of course, no sharp boundaries between the different stages of the political process. One stage interpenetrates with another and as a result of this situation reveals various contradictions. These contradictions certainly make diagnosis and prognosis more difficult, but they do not at all make it impossible.
The forces of the French proletariat remain not only unexhausted, but are indeed still intact. Fascism as a political factor among the petty-bourgeois masses is relatively feeble as yet (much more powerful, nevertheless, than it seems to the parliamentarians). These two very important political facts allow us to say with firm conviction: nothing has been lost as yet, the possibility for transforming the prerevolutionary situation into a revolutionary situation is still entirely open.
But in a capitalist country such as this there can be no revolutionary struggles without the general strike: if working men and women remain in the factories during the decisive days who then will do the fighting? Thus, the general strike is on the agenda. foreseeing the refusal of the leaders of the strike to them?"
But the question of the moment for the general strike is the question of knowing whether the masses are prepared to struggle and whether the workers' organizations are ready to lead them to battle.
Up to the present moment there has been not a single case either in Paris or in the provinces where the masses remained deaf to a call from above.
The greatest case in point is the general strike of February 12, 1934. Despite the complete division of the leadership, the lack of any serious preparation, the tenacious efforts of the leaders of the CGT to reduce the movement to a minimum - since they could not evade it altogether — the general strike achieved the greatest success possible under the given conditions. It is clear that the masses want to struggle. Every class-conscious worker must say to himself that the pressure from below must have been extremely powerful if Jouhaux himself was stirred for a moment from his immobility. True, involved here was not a general strike in the proper meaning of the term, but only a twenty-four hour demonstration. But this restriction was not put by the masses; it was dictated from above.
The rank and file want to fight, the leaders apply the brake. It is here that the chief danger lies; and it may end in a catastrophe.
One should not think, however, that the radicalization of the masses will proceed by itself, automatically. The working class waits for initiative on the part of its organizations. When it arrives at the conclusion that its expectations have been false — and this moment is, perhaps, not so very distant — the process of radicalization will break off and be transformed into manifestations of discouragement, apathy, and isolated explosions of despair. At the periphery of the proletariat, anarchist tendencies impinge upon fascist tendencies. The wine will turn to vinegar.
The shifts in the political mood of the masses demand the greatest possible attention. To probe this living dialectic at every stage -that is the task of agitation.
To determine to what degree the masses are ripe for the general strike and at the same time to strengthen the militant mood of the masses, it is necessary to place before them a program of revolutionary action. Partial slogans such as the abolition of the Bonapartist decree-laws and of the two-year term of military service will find, of course, an important place in such a program. But these two episodic slogans are entirely inadequate.
Above all tasks and partial demands of our epoch there stands the question of power. Since February 6, 1934, the question of power has been openly posed as a question of armed force. The municipal and parliamentary elections can be of importance insofar as the evaluation of forces is concerned - but nothing more. The question will be settled by the open conflict between the two camps. Governments of the type of Doumergueposes the question of power in a Flandin, etc., occupy the forefront only up to the day of the decisive climax. On the morrow, either fascism or the proletariat will govern France.
It is precisely because the present intermediate state regime is extremely unstable that the general strike can achieve very great partial successes by forcing the government to take to the road of concessions on the question of the Bonapartist decree-laws, the two-year term of military service, etc. But such a success, extremely valuable and important by itself, will not reestablish the equilibrium of "democracy": finance capital will redouble its subsidies to fascism, and the question of power, perhaps after a brief interlude, will be posed with redoubled force.
The fundamental importance of the general strike, independent of the partial successes which it may and then again may not provide, lies in the fact that it poses the question of power in a revolutionary manner. By shutting down the factories, transport, and in general all the means of communication, Glossary Engels: Frederick Engels (1820-1895), socialist and close comrade of Karl Marx.
Chartists: The first movement of the modern industrial working class. Active in England, mainly from 1838 to 1848. Demanded the vote for all citizens, including workers, and other democratic reforms. Organised a general strike in 1842.
Belgian general strike: For the right to vote for parliament, in 1893. Russo-Japanese war: In 1904-5 Japan defeated Russia, occupying Korea and ousting Russia's previous influence there. The Russian Government, headed by a Tsar (king) who ruled without any democracy, was weakened, and mass workers' strike: in 1905 forced concessions.
The TUC in 1926: Called a general strike in support of the miners, who were resisting wage cuts and longer hours, but called it off after nine days when it was still growing.
Jouhaux in 1934: Leon Jouhaux was evolutionary manner power stations, etc., the proletariat by this very act paralyses not only production but also the government. The state power remains suspended in midair. It must either subjugate the proletariat by famine and force and constrain it to set the apparatus of the bourgeois state once again in motion, or retreat before the proletariat.
Whatever may be the slogans and the motive for which the general strike is initiated, if it includes the genuine masses, and if these masses are quite resolved to strug gle, the general strike inevitably poses before all the classes in the nation the question: Who will be the master?
The leaders of the proletariat must understand this internal logic of the general strike, unless they are not leaders but dilettantes and adventurers.
The general strike is by its very essence a political act. It opposes the working class as a whole to the bourgeois state.
The general strike poses directly the question of the conquest of power by the proletariat. the leader of the main French trade union organisation, the CGT. He called a one-day general strike on 12 February 1934 (see the second article from Trotsky), but with no follow-up. India: Was then ruled by Britain, and China was ruled by Japan.
Doumergue: Head of the Government of "National Union" set up after the Radical Party government fell in February 1934. It sought special powers to rule by decree, without reference to parliament. A similar government, headed by Flandin, followed from November 1934 to May 1935.
Bonapartist: A regime which raises itself above any democratic control by society, usually by balancing between social classes (so called after the two Bonapartes who were Emperors of France, Napoleon I, 1804 15, and Napoleon III, 1852-71). Thorez: General Secretary of the Communist Party.
SFIO: The Socialist Party.
Petty-bourgeois: Middle-class.
Scan page 13
Organiser
----- pull-quotes -----
"Perhaps Thorez add discreetly that,
SFIO, he risks nothing by proposing a general