A general strike against war?
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
In this 1935 article, Leon Trotsky discusses the politics of the Independent Labour Party (ILP), which "promised" to call a Genera Strike to stop the Second World War. The ILP was the core organisation inside the Labour Party until the union-based Labour set up the individual membership-constituted Labour Party in 1918.
In 1932, the Party disaffiliated from the Labour Party, refusing to accept its discipline for its halfdozen MPs in Parliament. It had, perhaps, 17,000 members led by James Maxton MP and Fenner Brockway. It moved strongly to the left and to revolutionary socialism. But the Party stagnated and waster away as the 'Thirties wore on. Maxton died and Brockway rejoined the Labour Party in ending his — generally respectworthy — life in the of Lords.
The question of the general strike has a long and rich history, in theory as well as practice. Yet the leaders of the ILP behave as if they were the first to run across the idea of general strike, as a method to stop war. In this is their greatest error. Improvisation is impermissible precisely on the question of the general strike. The world experience of the struggle during the last forty years has been fundamentally a confirmation of what Engels had to say about the general strike towards the close of the last century, primarily on the basis of the experience of the Chartists, and in part of the Belgians. Cautioning the Austrian Social Democrats against much too flighty an attitude towards the general strike, Engels wrote to Kautsky, on November 3, 1893, as follows: You yourself remark that the barricades have become antiquated (they may, however, prove useful again should the army turn one third or two fifths socialist and the question arises of providing it with the opportunity to turn its bayonets), but the political strike must either prove victorious immediately by the threat alone (as in Belgium, where the army was very shaky), or it must end in a colossal fiasco, or, finally, lead directly to the barricades."
He differentiates, as we have seen, between three cases in relation to the political strike:
(I) The government takes fright at the general strike, and at the very outset, without carrying matters to an open clash, takes to concessions. Engels points to the "shaky' condition of the army in Belgium as the basic condition for the success of the Belgian general strike (1893). A somewhat similar situation, but on a much more colossal scale occurred in Russia, October, 1905. After the miserable outcome of the Russo-Japanese War, the Tsarist army was, or, at any rate, seemed extremely unreliable. The Petersburg government, thrown into a mortal panic by the strike, made the first constitutional concessions (Manifesto, October 17, 1905).
It is all too evident, however, that without resorting to decisive battles, the ruling class will make only such concessions as will not touch the basis of its rule. That is precisely how matters stood in Belgium and Russia. Are such cases possible in the future? They are inevitable in the countries of the Orient. They are, generally speaking, less probable in the countries of the West, although, here too they are quite possible as partial episodes of the unfolding revolution.
(2) If the army is sufficiently reliable, and the government feels sure of itself; if a political strike is promulgated from above, and if, at the same time, it is calculated not for decisive battles, but to 'frighten' the enemy, then it can easily turn out a mere adventure, and reveal its utter impotence. To this we ought to add that after the initial experiences of the general strike, the novelty of which reacted upon the imagination of the popular masses as well as governments, several decades have elapsed discounting the half-forgotten Chartists - in the course of which the strategists of capital have accumulated an enormous experience.
Scan page 11
Socialist Organiser No. 543 page 11