Socialists and th
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
The 1926 General Strike. Betrayed by the trade union leadership who, as Trotsky pointed out, went along with it the better to A labour movement has at last fter a long prostration, the begun to rise up off its knees, roused by the inhumanly casual brutality with which the Tory Government proposed to throw 30,000 miners out of work in the middle of the worst economic slump for 60 years.
The two big October marches for the miners - 100,000 on a weekday, and then 200,000 at the weekend and a token solidarity strike by a few hundred power workers are so far the high points of the revival of the labour movement. Socialists will now combine a political campaign against the key Tory measures of the 1980s — destruction of the National Health Service, anti-union laws, and so on with a drive to win active solidarity for the miners and promote industrial action in other disputes, and thus help develop the labour revival, which is so far only in its early, tentative stages.
In these circumstances, the idea that the left should focus its activity around a campaign for an all-out "General Strike Now" would not merit serious discussion were it not for the fact that it is raised by the biggest organisation on the revolutionary left, the Socialist Workers' Party (SWP).
The size of the SWP can not make "General Strike Now" a sensible project. It does make it necessary to discuss the question seriously. One way of doing this is to bring in examples of how the General Strike was raised or discussed by serious Marxists in the past; and this we do with these extracts from the work of Leon Trotsky.
Most of those who have been shouting for a General Strike Now seem not to know what it is they are proposing. If they ponder Trotsky's opinion, expressed here, that the General Strike is the most advanced slogan short of revolution, then young SWPers might understand the reception their call for a "General Strike Now" has received from trade unionists.
In the two extracts published here, Trotsky shows that the General Strike must grow out of the previous struggles and mobilisations of the labour movement. It can not be arbitrarily evoked without that preparation — not by the leaders of powerful labour movements, and still less by very small revolutionary organisations.
Trotsky shows that a serious General Strike must normally end in crushing defeat either for the bosses or for the workers. Where, as in the second extract here, Trotsky favours propaganda and agitation for a General Strike, he links it with such things as the arming of the working class in preparation for a struggle for state Other possibilities exist - for example, when the bourgeois state (the state, not just the government) is in disarray, concessions by the bourgeoisie, as in Belgium in 1893, when a general strike won the right to vote for the workers.
Trotsky writing nearly 60 years ago can not, of course, analyse the situation in Britain now for us. That we do for ourselves. Nor should we go to Trotsky for dogmatic recipes and extrapolations. Trotsky's work is best taken first as a valuable record of past discussions, and then as a model of how revolutionary Marxists who take ideas seriously approach such questions and how they analyse reality.
The SWP's demagogic left phrasemongering will be of some use if it sends serious socialists to the study of this important question.
LAY NATUR control and end it as soon as possible JASO That is why a gene ticularly in the old : tries, requires a Marxist accounting crete circumstances.
and if, at the same time, is calculated not for decisive battles, but 'frighten' the enemy, it can easily turn out mere adventure."
(3) Finally, there remains a general strike which, as Engels put it, 'leads directly to the barricades'. A strike of this sort can result either in complete victory or defeat. But to shy away from battle, when the battle is forced by the objective situation, is to lead inevitably to the most fatal and demoralizing of all possible defeats.
The outcome of a revolutionary, insurrectionary general strike depends, of course, upon the relationship of forces, covering a great number of factors: the class differentiation of society, the specific weight of the proletariat, the mood of the lower layers of the petty-bourgeoisie, the social composition and the political mood of the army, etc. However, among the conditions for victory, far from the last place is occupied by the corral strike, parapitalist counpainstaking of all the con-
----- pull-quotes -----
"If a political strike is promulgated from above,