[Norman Lamont says "Unemployment is a price worth…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Norman Lamont says "Unemployment is a price worth paying beat inflation". This adds great urgency to the need to drive tl Tories from office and replace them by a Labour government. the same time we must fight them every inch of the way, contesting every job, fighting every closure.
Trade unionists need to learn from the experiences of earlier struggles to prevent workplace closures and job losses, many Timex workers occupy their factory over forced redundancies, April 1983. Occupation Charing Cross Hospital 1992. Although mobilising public opinion is important especially against attacks on the Health Service it cannot be the sole method of which occurred in the years 1979-81.
To challenge and undermine the bosses' case for closure (or job losses) is the necessary starting point: for workers to decide to moun a campaign in defence of their jobs they have to disbelieve and reject management's case. They have to believe that there is an alternative. In the private sector the standard argument for a workplace closure is that i is running at a loss. But, especially where a company owns a number of sites, artificially creating a loss — on the books! - at one particular plant through accountancy techniques is the easiest thing in the world Claims that a factory is running at a loss are often a cover-up for other motives: for a decision to switch production to a low-wage area, for example, or a failure on the part of management to plan investment. The purpose of challenging manage ment's case for closure is not to give the bosses good working class advice about running their business. Rather, challenging and undermining the employers' arguments is a means of attacking their "credibility" exposing their dishonesty, boosting the confidence of the workforce and beginning to harness broader support for a fight by exposing the weakness of management's case.
But exposing the weakness in management's case can never be enough by itself. struggle. Photo: John Harris.
When the British Aluminium Com pany announced the closure of its plant in the Neath Valley in 1981 for example, the unions ripped the company's arguments to pieces. Within six months of the initial announcement, however, the plant had been shut down. E save jobs is crippled unless any xperience shows that the fight discussion about redundancy is stifled at the outset: severance pay is one of management's favoured methods of undermining resistance to job losses. Some workers foolishly accept comparative riches now — or the hope of them — in return for the griping poverty of the dole in the near future.
Discussion about redundancy terms saps morale, as it assumes that jobs will be lost. It opens the door to the myths of management and the media that huge severance payments will allow redundant workers to live a life of luxury or open small businesses. In fact, 50% of workers made redundant receive no statutory redundancy payments at all. Those workers who do receive large payments soon discover that they are counted as "savings" to stop their welfare benefits.
With only a few exception, efforts by workers to save jobs and prevent workplace closures have raised the question of when to take industrial action, and what form of industrial action.
Typical exceptions were some of the campaigns to save NHS jobs and prevent hospital closures in the early 1980s, when the Tories' dismantling of the NHS had hardly got off the ground.
In 1982, for example, proposals to close the Prince of Wales Hospital in Cardiff and to slash £52 millions from the NHS in Wales were defeated by mobilising public opinion without taking strike action.
But the advance of the Tories' attack on the NHS, coupled with the deepening economic crisis, has undermined the effectiveness of mobilising "public opinion" as the sole method of struggle. the company was as devious as I thought, they would make the excuse that they might have kept the plant open had it not been for our action. I didn't want to given them any excuses so my advice was — keep on working"
Shop stewards at the Storeys factory in Essex who managed to save most of the jobs at the factory when its closure was announced in 1981, followed the same logic as Helen Monaghan: "The stewards got the commitment of the members to continue normal work they believed was essential, because they felt that any form of industrial action would play straigh into the hands of the directors of Storey Brothers."
----- pull-quotes -----
CHALLENGING MANAGEMENT' ARGUMENTS
FIGHT TO SAVE EVERY JO
SUPPORT US.