What the socialist ett must do
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
The cop who arrested Arthur Scargill in 1984 now says (according to the Daily Mirror last week) "Sorry Arthur". But there are are no replays in the class struggle. • Alance for Workers Lib- n 28-29 November the erty (AWL) will hold its 1992 annual conference. What is the AWL? What is the reason for its existence?
If you want the answer to that question, then take a good look at the picture on this page, and think about what happened in the great miners' strike of 19845, and why. That is one way of understanding AWL and what we in AWL are trying to do. It is a famous picture. In it, Arthur Scargill is being arrested at the "Battle of Orgreave" , on 30 May 1984, where miners fought a long battle with troops of police and with police cavalry at a coke depot outside Sheffield. It was one of the turning points of the 1984-5 miners' strike.
The picture symbolises and what happened in 1984-5. Mrs Thatcher's police thugs beat down the miners with physical violence and they were able to do it because the labour movement left the miners to fight alone.
Graham Bash Vladimir Derer Terry Eagleton Jatin Haria (Labour Party Black Sections)
Dorothy Macedo Joe Marino John Mellroy John Nicholson Peter Tatchell Members of the Advisory Committee are drawn from a broad cross section of the left who are opposed to the Labour Party s witch-hunt against Socialist Organiser. Views expressed in articles are the responsibility of the authors and not of the Advisory Editorial Board.
For the Tories and the police, it was no holds barred. They had been planning and organising to beat down the miners since the early 1970s. They had a centralised, semi-military police operation all prepared. Margaret Thatcher said, during the strike, that if the police needed any laws changed to enable them to beat the miners, then changed they would be.
As the police smashed into picket lines, and became an army of occupation in many pit villages, it was, once again, the situation depicted back in the 1840s in the famous Punch cartoon in which a government "Special Constable" tells a labour movement Chartist: "If you kill me, it's murder. If I kill you, it's nothing"
In 1984, the miners had either to fight in the unfavourable conditions they found themselves in, or let the Tories win a crushing victory over them peacefully. The Tory class warriors controlled the British state, and used it with grim resolve to make war on the labour movement.
All the patronising "sympathy" now - some of it, the Sun's for example, half-gleeful can not undo the effects for the last eight years of the Tory victory over the miners — communities devastated and ruined; jobs lost; and the labour movement, which had played an immense role for many decades in "civilising" British capitalism, marginalised.
There is no substitute for victory! There are no replays in the class struggle! Those who lose suffer the consequences.
Could we have beaten Tories in 1984?
Yes! Despite all the police preparations and all the Tories' determination, they could have been beaten and overwhelmed in 1984 as they had been in 1972 and 1974. It would have been more difficult but it could have been done.
What, in 1984-5, would have made the difference between defeat and victory? Solidarity! General labour movement action! The leaders of the TUC and the Labour Party could, had they backed the miners instead of openly and covertly undercutting them, have rallied the industrial and other support necessary. But they are what they are - tame trade union officials and second-string Westminster politicians. That being so, only an organised network of revolutionary militants in the trade unions, Trades Councils, and Labour Parties, pursuing a common strategy, could have rallied the labour movement to a common battle together with the miners.
That was what was missing in 1984. That was what the miners needed in 1984, and no trade itinued on the emancrpauonor me working. cores also die ecandidaton oi all human beings without distinction of sex or race." Kan Marx Socialist Organisen PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Newsdesk: 1071-639 1965 /atenforrepontswipnday EditorwJohn OMMahpny Published by: WL Publications Ltd, PO OKI823 Londeni SETS ANT Printed titlemtiPresswEdenbridger Registeredias e newsppper athe Post Office Articles do not necessarily reflect unless otherwise stated.
Scan page 4
Socialist Organiser No. 543 page 4
----- pull-quotes -----
Advisory Editomad Board
"There are no replays in the class struggle!"
the viewsiof Socialist Urganiser andiare in a pensonal capacity