Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

A socialis scientist

Socialist Organiser no. 542, 12 November 1992 · scan p. 14 · about 858 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

O Son save night, wan ne hundred years ago, on born one of the most interesting British scientists - John Bardon Sanderson Haldane. Not only did he perform research vital to at least four different though related areas of science, but he also carried out research into poison gas defence in the First World War and research into survival of trapped submarines during the Second A communist, he believed in telling people what science was doing so that they could make informed judgments. For years, he wrote a popular science column in the Daily Worker. Later, he was to leave the Communist Party, at least partly because of Stalinist attacks on science Late in life, he left Britain to work for science in newly independent India and became an Indian citizen. His career is all the more remarkable because he had no formal science qualifications.

His childhood was exceptional. His father was himself a scientist who involved John in his experimental work. As a child, therefore, John found himself asked to make experimental dives or to accompany his father down mines to investigate the circumstances of explosions.

Going from Eton to Oxford to study maths, John attended zoology lectures "for relaxation" Already interested in genetics from his attending a lecture (as a boy of nine!) on the rediscovered work of Mendel, he, with his sister, the novelist Naomi Mitchison (who died recently, aged 92), carried out studies on inheritance amongst several hundred guinea pigs. He was also helping his father with the maths in his work on the properties of haemoglobin. When the First World War started, JBS enlisted as an officer in the Black Watch. He became Bombing Officer, greatly enjoying his work. At the same time, he developed a distaste for killing which extended in later life to animals.

Later, he worked with his father developing more adequate defences to the chlorine gas that was starting to be used in war. This involved his breathing quite a bit of chlorine, typifying JBS's approach to experimental science. Rather than use animals or humans who perhaps did not understand the risks involved, he preferred to use himself and his colleagues. However, he was never opposed to the use of animals in research, where necessary.

After the war, he taught physiology at Oxford, carrying out research on himself that required his drinking hydrochloric acid, among other unpleasant chemicals.

Moving to Cambridge, he was a pioneer in the field of biochemistry, as well as doi ig important work in the mathematics of inheritance. One of his discoveries is now helping with the mapping of the human genome. He also produced theories of the spontaneous development of life from the "primordial soup" of the early Earth's oceans.

-During the 'thirties, the experience of the rise of fascism in Europe drove JBS towards the Communist Party. His experiences in Spain led him to campaign for effective air-raid precautions in Britain, something resisted by the Government of the day.

Despite his association with the Communist Party and his writing for the Daily Worker, (banned during the period of the Nazi-Soviet Pact), JBS was regularly consulted by the wartime Government over scientific issues including dangerous work for the Navy.

His work on escaping from submarines was heroic enough. It involved staying in an airtight tank until CO2 levels were very high and then trying to use the escape apparatus available in a submarine. Later experiments on submarine escape required sitting in ice-cold water, breathing lots of CO,, under pressure. JBS was undoubtedly risking his health and, on one occasion, his life when he suffered convulsions and unconsciousness, through oxygen poisoning. On another occasion: he badly injured his back.

After the war, Haldane continued working at University College, London, where he had been throughout the 'thirties. His loyalty to the Communist Party was tested by the Lysenko affair in the USSR. Lysenko's unscientific views on genetics had been allowed to prevail for political reasons but, worse, holders of the orthodox Mendelian views, such as JBS knew to be correct, were persecuted. Vavilov, director of the USSR's agricultural research since the '20s, was to die in a prison camp.

JBS was silent or circumspect on the Lysenko affair for a long time, hiding behind the uncertainties surrounding reports of what was happening in the USSR and not wishing to give comfort to the enemies of "communism". Eventually, he spoke out, though the delay in doing so does not reflect well on him.

By 1950, it seems he was no longer a CP member, though he continued to consider himself a Marxist. Later in the '50s, he was to emigrate to India to help build up their scientific research capabilities. He stated that he no longer wished to live in a country that invaded other countries (this was just after Suez).

A few years later he had to return to Britain for treatment for cancer of the rectum. With typical good humour and pugnacity he wrote a poem that started, wish I had the voice of Homer, to sing of rectal carcinoma... He died in 1964, leaving his body to be dissected by Indian medical students.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 542

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →