Right on readable
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
plays Hawkeye straight nvincing Book Liz Millward reviews That spoiled my impression of Sara Paretsky's new book was going on to re-read an old and much-loved Ross MacDonald straight afterwards. Paretsky suffers by comparison. which is a shame, because the VI Warshawski novels are worth reading. This one, rumoured to be the last, is rather more leisured than the others, and, frankly, the plot did not grip me. Despite that, I enjoyed it a lot.
Initially Warshawski hires on to find an old friend and workmate of her neighbour, and, needless to say, uncovers big business up to the old trick of ripping off the working man. But I was never really convinced that big business was doing anything bad enough to warrant the amount of murder and covering up that Warshawski came up against. Maybe I missed the point, or maybe we've all become immune to Maxwell-style fraud, but I kept hoping to find out what they were really trying to hide.
Better than the main plot is the second strand of the story which involves Warshawski helping to beat off the yuppies who are trying to take over her run-down neighbourhood. This strand is stretched to fit with the main story, and the joins show, but the hatred of yuppies is real enough and makes up for a lot.
The love interest is good too and, for once, Warshawski's lover turns out not to be the bad guy.
Guardian Angel is pleasantly righton in places, but oddly jarring in others. Warshawski falls for a black man - complete with educational asides — but doesn't practise safe sex. She does no housework (good for her) but appears to have an endless supply of silk shirts and the money to have them dry-cleaned. She takes up the cause of her eccentric, elderly neighbour (owner of five out-of-control dogs) against the incoming yuppies (good), but the book is patronising to other working class neighbours who can't 'see through' the surface charm of the yuppies. Ross MacDonald may not be right-on, but no-one gets patronised either.
VI Warshawski has always been a bit self-consciously precious for my liking, emphasising the inessentials of women's liberation, like not being called by pet names or doing housework, while the big issues get less attention. I'd be more impressed by a VI Warshawski who let people call her Vicky, but who didn't need a man (or his secretary) to book things up on a computer for her. Warshawski is emancipated in a thoroughly American, middle-class way - she might not need 'looking after' but she is careful to emphasise that she has successful friends, and eats in expensive restaurants as well as cheap diners. She has a cheap, unfashionable office, but out of 'choice' as much as necessity.
All the carping should not put you off Guardian Angel, which is well worth a walk to the nearest bookshop or library. For all that I moan about her, Warshawski is a credible detective, and the scenes of Chicago low-life are all too grubbily believable. All Sara Paretsky's novels are well-written and well-constructed, and if this one is a bit more laboured than the others, it's still streets ahead of most contemporary bestsellers.
If this is the last of the Warshawski novels, I will be disappointed. OK, so Ross MacDonald's Lew Archer would never have gone back to Mrs. Potter's the second time, suspending disbelief almost to breaking point, but VI Warshawski has plenty of life in her yet. Your fans want more, VI!
----- pull-quotes -----
Guardian Ange/ by Sara Paretsky