Wrecked by hindsight
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Belinda Weaver reviews The Last of the Mohicans This film is not James Fenimore Cooper's novel transPlated to the screen. It's director Michael Mann's view of it through a fog of anti-colonial attitudes and "politically correct white guilt.
The film is set in 1757, when the battle of the English and French armies for control of the American colonies had already raged fo three years. Cora and Alice, the two daughters of an English soldier, Colonel Munro, are seeking to join him at the fort where the British are besieged by General Montcalm's army. The girls are being led to the fort by Magua, a Huron Indian.
Magua leads them into an ambush by a Huron war party the Hurons sided with the French in the war — and only the intervention of Hawkeye and his two Mohican friends, Chingachgook "In his treatment of the British, Mann seems to be fighting the battles of 1776 rather than 1757. In the novel, Hawkeye scouted for the British."
and his son, Uncas, saves them from death. Hawkeye falls for Cora, but there are many perils ahead, not least a showdown with the evil Magua.
Mann uses the film to settle old scores. He adds a lame sub-plot about British betrayal of a colonial militia, to establish the British as two-faced and self-serving. In the novel, there were no lonely settlers to be massacred; the whole area was wilderness.
The film is also subtly antiFrench. Montcalm, who had been open and generous to the surrendering British, is shown skulking with Magua, as if giving a tacit go-ahead to the Hurons' later massacre of the departing troops. In his treatment of the British, Mann seems to be fighting the battles of 1776 rather than 1757. In the novel, Hawkeye scouted for the British. He was on their side, against the French, but recognised Montcalm's gracious behaviour to Munro.
That didn't suit Mann. Hawkeye has been changed beyond recognition. It's not just his invented romance with Cora; you expect that from Hollywood. It's that Mann seems ashamed of having hero who is white.
The Hawkeye of the novel, who prided himself on his white skin, has gone completely native. Instead of demonstrating his selfreliance and wisdom learned from life in the wilderness, (which included respect for the Indian traditions, even where he disagreed with them), Hawkeye becomes a mouthpiece for one-sided, contemporary, guilt-ridden attitudes, namely, us white guys came along and trashed an Eden. Hawkeye's speech to the ancient Huron, Sachem, is a gem of hindsight, even if it does contain important truths.
Cooper's Hawkeye felt no such guilt. He recognised evil in some white men, just as he recognised in Indians like Magua. But he didn't blame himself for white misdeeds.
Mann seems incapable senting a Hawkeye so luxuriously at ease with himself. Hawkeye has to be thrust into every squabble going, and appear on the right side, in our terms, rather than on his own. Hindsight is the great wrecker of costume drama.
Still, for all that, The Last of th Mohicans is one of the best adver ture films Hollywood has made i a while.
Magua is a great villain, who vows to cut out Munro's heart and eat it. (We're spared the feast.) He and his half-naked, war-painted Indians, with their shaven heads adorned by scalping tufts and feathers, are meant to be fearsome, while Chingachgook and Uncas are reassuring in deerskin garb and long hair. In the book, both had Mohawk haircuts and war-paint, but they've been tidied up for us. They even apolo"Cooper's Hawkeye recognised evil in some like Magua. But he didn't blame himself for white misdeeds."
gise to a stag they shoot for food.
It's been a long time since someone played a hero straightfaced, but Daniel Day-Lewis as Hawkeye rises to the occasion superbly. Luckily, Cora is allowed to be strong and resourceful, rather than a weakling crying and screaming on the sidelines. She's more than a match for Hawkeye.
It's good swashbuckling entertainment. Hawkeye and his friends always have tomahawks and rifles at the ready, and they cut down their foes with deadly aim and dashing cool.
----- pull-quotes -----
white men, just as he recognised it in Indians