Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why are there no great

Socialist Organiser no. 542, 12 November 1992 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 1,266 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

"The woman artist — for example the Impressionist Berthe Morisot exhibits a SECRÉTARIAT CÁSÍMAR S° BOREAD.

attenicas.

TSIn /9552 maraiss Sigrarue do goite:

Johnson am so sick of feminists saying that they refuse to accept male standards of achievement.

hese wishy-washy fools won't even dmit that Michelangelo was a genius because he was a man.

"Absurd! Insane! It's a recipe for rediocrity". Now everything is great.

o they say that some quilt made by ome woman in Kansas is as imporint an object as the Sistine Chapel.

five me a break"

So says Camille Paglia, an American cademic currently enjoying a best elling 700-page book, packed lecture ours, fawning profiles in the quality ress and glossy magazines and a ntourage of Hollywood admirers.

Cut through the pretentious gloss, nd her message is as simple as it is ¿actionary. There is, she says, "No escape from the biologic chains which bind us"

escape from the biologic chains which bind us".

Men got the genius and women got the womb. "There is no female Mozart because there is no female Jack the Ripper. Revolutionary Art needs violence, a willingness to break the rules like Picasso did, to kill the father... most women have too much empathy to want to be involved in anything like that. They want things to be comfortable, they want to be compassionate" And why is this so? Nature. "In the beginning was nature" opens Paglia's book. This is not the sweet and comforting nature of today's radical feminists. That, says Paglia, is just a surface which hides the wet, murky and demonic powers underneath. Nature is brutal and enslaving. Its "fascism is greater than that of any society" and it has "a master agenda we can only dimly know".

PRÉFECTURE DE POLICE.

PERMISSION

DE TRAVESTISSEMENT.

Paris, le 72 M NOUs. PAtTET DE POLICE• Vu Tordonnance du 16 bromaire an IX (7 notembre 8o0):

demeurant La en outre faltesatios du Comissire de Police d AUTOBISONS 1 Demainelle dlass •Віл 30 davelicement. paraitre aur Spectacles, Bols et outres lieus de réunion cuverts eu pollie.

La présente autorisarico a est salable que pour siz no A compter de ce jour Pour le Préfet de Police LE SOCA • pe se si Thie 19th century French painter Bonheur had to get a police pert dress as a man.

Nature dictates the separate destinies of men and women. " We are hierarchical animals. Sweep one hierarchy away and another will take its place"

Reason is a pitiful little thing in comparison, "a hostage of its flesh-envelope"

All cultural achievement is an attempt to escape the vagaries of nature, to detach oneself from its dictates and impose some order on it.

Men are, apparently, "anatomically destined" for this... because they can write there names in wee on the school wall!

In Pagliaese "concentration", "directness" and "projection" are essential to make are and all these qualities are essentially male as "remarkably demonstrated by urination"

"Freud thinks primitive men preened himself on his ability to put out a fire with a stream of urine. A strange thing to be proud of, but certainly beyond the scope of women, who would scorch her hams in the process.

"Male urination really is a kind of accomplishment, an arc of transcendence. A woman merely waters the ground she stands on. Male urination is a form of commentary... Women, like female dogs are earthbound squatters. There is no projection beyond the boundaries of the self"

Women can't ever see their genitalia, and so"accept limited knowledge as their natural condition" . Men can see their genitalia, and that is the source of their reason. In fact, men invented mathematics to "escape the soggy emotionalism of women" . But because women are nature they do not struggle against it.

Art is men's because art and culture is the male response of women and nature. The "eye" of western art is the male eye following the "arc of transcendence" obsessively into conceptualisation and reason and "hunting and scanning" for women. The male artist turns women into sexobjects in order to fix the power of nature.

Why does all this rubbish get a hearing?

Paglia is a talented self-publicist. She poses outside a Porn Store, leatherclad and whip in hand. She speaks in sound-bits. She makes sensational attacks on Anita Hill.

And, more importantly, she is a woman whom the right can point to and cite as 700 pages of educated authority when they tell us that women have got too uppity of late. She chimes with the backlash against feminism, giving it a pseudo-academic underpinning.

Of course, people instinctively sympathise when Paglia says Michelangelo is better than a patchwork quilt from Kansas. She conjures up visions of committees of the "Politically Correct" reordering curricula and museums, turfing out the DWMS (dead white males) to install the said quilt and no doubt the accompanying dollies and knitted sweater I think Pagha is rigne abour Michelangelo and "greatness" against both some old Marxism and some new driven quality"

feminism.

But feminists in the 1970s, like Germaine Greer and Linda Nochlin offered a very different explanation for why there are so few women artists.

Paglia says: "Women don't have the kind of obsessiveness that produces great are. You have to have this maniacal egomania, you mutilate your social life, all your personal relationships for what you are doing". She assumes she is observing natural eternal truths rooted in biology.

Yet consider women's relationship to the world of art - the everyday material and psychological framework within which training, painting, exhibiting and selling go on. Greer called it "the obstacle race"

The psychological obstacles were summed up by Virginia Woolf when she wrote, about the aspiring woman author, that "The world does not say to her, as it said to him, write if you choose; it makes no difference to me. The world said with a guffaw, 'Write? What is the good of you writing!'"

The same applies to painting. The painter Renoir said in 1881, "The woman who is an artist is merely ridiculous, but I feel it is acceptable for a woman to be a singer or a dancer" The material obstacles were many. Women were excluded from the academies, excluded from apprenticeships, forbidden to draw the nude (which "High Art" from Renaissance until the late 19th century was based on). Aspiring women artists were pushed into painting flowers or still lifes, of cutting up coloured paper or decorative arts.

The art world, from the Royal Academy to the Clubs to the patrons, was a male world.

One incident can illustrate this. In 1983 Hubert Herkomer opened an Art School for both sexes. His diary recounts this incident. "A lady came with her husband who seemed in the depths of misery at the idea of his wife studying in the life" The statement that married women were ineligible for my school had scarcely passed my lips when his entire "The art world was not listening. Women artists through the forties and into the fifties in New York were the victims of a sort of cultural apartheid, and the ruling assumptions about the inherent weakness, derivativeness and silly femininity of women painters were almost unbelievably phallocentric". expression changed, he beamed with delight. "The wife's last appeal was: *But I am fond of drawing; what am I to do if

Scan page 11

women artists?

Organiser Pamphlets from Socialist Organisel and the Alliance fo How the workers made a revolution Socialist Organis 60 pence 1917 (Russian Revolution) 60p plus 18p p&

----- pull-quotes -----

"Paglia's message is as simple as it is reactionary:

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 542

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →