Health, education, full employment: The rich can pay
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Billions are siph A necessary? Can we afford re cuts and a wage treeze better public services?
Cuts are "necessary" , and decent wages and services "too expensive" " only because the capitalist system puts profit first. It ranks the privilege, lux ry and gain of the super-rich above the basic needs of the majority.
Figures published in the National Accounts shed light on this. They show total outpu in 1991 at £452 billion* The figure is very rough-andready, for a dozen reasons, but it will do for a start. The National Accounts show £330 billion going to "income from employment" (mainly wages), €58 billion to the self-employed and £64 billion to profits.
Eidlitorial Board wranam Bash ladimif Derer Terry Eagleton Jatin Haria (Labour Party Black Sections)
Dorothy Macedo Joe Marino John Mcllroy John Nicholson Peter Tatchell Membersi at the Alisor committee are drawn rome oron cross section of the left who are Brone lite at oratio witch-hunt against Socialist Organiser. Views expressed in articles are the responsibility of the authors and not of the Advisory Editorial Board.
The figures need to be adjusted in at least four ways: for taxes paid to the state; for interest payments made by the state; for social security and welfare payments made by the state; and for the fact that a chunk of what is shown in the National Accounts as "wages and salaries" is not workers' wages. but the salaries, directors' fees, and so on, of the upper class. If we reckon that chunk as 15 per cent of the total, then we get a new breakdown.
Workers' net wages come to £157 billion, and the net income of self-employed people in small businesses to £27 billion. Social security and welfare payments, mostly to the working class and middle class, total £76 billion. The rich control f42 billion in profits after tax, dividends, and so on, and f42 billion in personal income. (Official figures shov that the top ten percent have about 25% of all personal income, so f42 billion, or about 10% of the total, is probably controlled by the top three per cent or so).
The state spends £29 billion on health, £23 billion on education, and £12 billion on other services such as local authority social services.
It spends £24 billion on military purposes, £12 billion on the police, courts, prisons, and so on, £7 billion on administration, and £11 billion on debt interest.
To put it another way: the average worker produces output worth about £16,000. They get about £8,000 net wages from which they can buy goods worth £6,000, paying £2,000 to the state in VAT and other sales taxes. £3,500 goes to the rich, and £7,000 to the state. Of that €7,000, about £3,000 comes back in social security and welfare payments, f2,500 goes to health, education, and so on, "Could a government which wanted full employment — in contrast to one which class — find that £14 billion? Easily!"
and t1,500 goes to maintaining the machinery of capitalist rule.
There are four million unemployed. To employ them would cost about f24 billion (their wages, less the taxes and National Insurance they would pay to the state). The state would save at least f10 billion in social security, so the net cos would be £14 billion.
Could a government which wanted full employment - in contrast to one which uses unemployment to discipline th working class — find that £14 billion? Easily!
The rich have f42 billion of income which could be taxed. British companies pay out a much bigger proportion of their profits in dividends than in other countries. A total of t22 billion is paid out in dividends, mostly to the rich: why not grab some of that money? Or why not cut the £24 billion military budget?
The way National Accounts are calculated, public service workers always appear less pro ductive than private-sector workers. They are assumed to produce output equal to their gross wages, while private-sector workers produce the equiva lent of their bosses' profits too.
Even on that basis, however, and even assuming all the four million unemployed become state employees in hospitals, schools, colleges, libraries, nurs eries, public works projects and so on, they would produce extr output of about f44 billion. That is the equivalent of a 50% increase in both health and edu cation budgets, with £17 billion to spare.
In fact, in a capitalist economy, four million unemployed would find jobs through many fewer — one million, maybe — being taken on in public service and projects. The jobs would "multiply" because the increased public activity would generate increased activity in firms supplying the public sector and firms producing goods consumed by the new public sector workers. The initial net state spending needed would be nearer f4 billion than £14 billion, and the new output nearer £60 billion than £44 billion. (Or more: full employment means higher productivity: less unusec capacity and smaller overhead expenses in proportion to production).
The sums are hypothetical, because in reality a governmen BANK POVERTY planning such a huge boost to jobs and services would face a catastrophic collapse of capitalist "confidence" and a flight of capital overseas. Either it would capitulate, or it would move to a different, socialist economy. with a different basis of accounting.
What the figures prove beyond doubt, though, is that no absolute lack of resources is behind the cuts, but the demands of profit.
* All the figures here omit, for simplicity, several items included in the National Accounts. People who own their home are assumed in the National Accounts to have an income equivalent to rent for the home (and an equal expenditure): these "imputed" incomes and expenditures are omitted. The income and expenditure of pension funds and life insurance companies are also omitted.
A much more detailed and thorough examination of the National Accounts is included in a recent book edited by Paul Dunne, Quantitative Marxism, Polity Press.
me elandi patiand tie working classas also the emancipation op anshumanbeligs without duskinction pisenarrace Karl Marx Socialist Organiser PЛBe 825, London SENSANAT Newsdesk: 071-655 0965 Latest date for reports: Monday Editors John OMahpny Published by: WL Publications Ltd, PO B0ж8231 London SENSINA Printer byat titlent PresswEdeinidge Registered as e newappper anthellest Officer the views of Socialist Organiser and are in a personal capacit unless otherwise stated.l
Scan page 4
AWL CONFERENCE Organiser
----- pull-quotes -----
uses unemployment to discipline the working
STOP LLOYDS AKING PROFITS OUT OF