Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Cultural Fro

Socialist Organiser no. 541, 5 November 1992 · scan p. 13 · about 793 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

Gerald Depardieu makes this film almost worth seeing. Otherwise it's a piece of white liberal Hollywood trash 1492 - Conquest Paradise 0 re-inventions we've seen in this fall the Christopher Columbus five hundredth anniversary year, perhaps the most unlikely is Ridley Scott's version of the man as a white Hollywood liberal. Scott would probably jeer at the blackand-white morality of old Hollywood costume dramas, with their good guys and bad guys, but 1492 — Conquest of Paradise is no more objective than they were.

This is not the past, but the past rewritten and re-invented, tidied up to match the sentiments of the 1990s.

Scott's Columbus is a visionary and a dreamer, a man bent on finding new worlds and re-making them to match his visions. It's a conventional treatment of a "great man" At first, people jeer at Columbus; he's an immigrant and an outsider. But with the aid of Queen Isabella, he gets his ships and sets off for the Indies, and after much hardship, emerges triumphant.

Only he doesn't, and this is where the film falls down. In bending the material to the "great man" format, it fudges Columbus's failures. Instead of telling the truth, it twists it, and having lost sight of the story, it degenerates into chaos and violence.

Perhaps no film can do justice to the Columbus story. There is so much myth to contend with, and so many differing versions. What was triumph for some — the Spanish -was disaster for the native tribes of the Americas.

Scott skates over all that by leaving things vague, and by absolving Columbus at least of any blame. His Columbus wants to be fair to the natives, and to treat them as equals. He seeks to learn as well as teach.

The reality, that many natives died of disease, overwork or cruelty, is hidden, or blamed on others, like the evil Spanish nobleman, Moxica.

Moxica is a villain and a typically Hollywood one. He lounges around in diamante-studded breeches, drinks and sneers menacingly at the lowly-born Columbus and his toiling followers. But what proves him to be a barbarian is his torching of Columbus's precious city plans drawn up by Leonardo da Vinci.

Five hundred years later, we're meant to recoil from such vandalism, and we do. But it weakens the film, this constant intrusion of hindsight. We rarely get the feeling we're watching a "then" — the camera itself seems to have the eyes of "now"

The film is too kind to point up Columbus's mistakes. E laving found the West Indies (which he mistook for Asia) he might have been content. But, driven by ambition, he had to oversell his findings, and boast of gold and treasures where there were none, as a means of obtaining backing for further expeditions.

Having received it, he had to produce, and to produce, he had to enslave and harry the natives. To do Scott justice, he does show this, but then lets Columbus off, first by blaming the bloodshed on Moxica, then by wrapping Columbus in the mantle of historical glory.

There are good moments. The sight of the three ships, the Nina, the Pinta, and the Santa Maria, at sea, is splendid and nothing can detract from the first sighting of land after so long and wearisome a journey. The coastline emerges from the mist, green and full of promise, and the exhausted mariners land on the beach and fall to their knees in thankfulness. These few scenes match Scott's deliberately heroic scale.

But then the natives appear, and we're back with the 1990s hindsight. Scott, with lashings of white liberal guilt, shows these people as perfect in their unspoiled Eden. Why? Of course, the coming of the Spanish, and the French and the English after them was an unparalleled disaster for the Indians, nine-tenths of whom were wiped out, and whose way of life was destroyed forever.

For that alone, they deserve our sympathy. They don't need toearn it, as Scott seems to imply, by being Org perfect as well.

The film has its foolish moments. There is much huffing and puffing to lift a great bell into the tower of the newly built settlement. Scott scores this with momentous music, as if it were a great feat of faith and engineering, and then drops it altogether. We never get any sense at all of what religion means to these men, far from home, and facing the terrors of a new world, so the scene has no resonance.

We're often in the dark about what's happening, or how long things last. When Moxica complains they have spent four useless years in Santo Domingo, you wonder why his clothes still look so new.

"This past, is not the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 541

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →