A hero killed by Britain
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
S traitor who died on the gallows al ir Roger Casement was a British Pentonville jail in July 1916. And he was an Irish hero, the sixteenth of the "Sixteen Dead Men" killed by the British after the Easter Rising. But Casement, who from the dock denied that he, an Irishman, could be a traitor to Britain, was much more than an Irish hero.
Of the 16 men killed in cold blood by the vengeful British state almost all, though they had broad sympathies, were narrowly Irish in their active political concerns. Casement and James Connolly were the exceptions. Connolly, though Ireland was central to him, saw Ireland as only one part of a world-wide socialist and anti-imperialist struggle. Casement had spent his entire life championing the victims of colonialism and oppression throughout the world - Africans in the Belgian Congo, enslaved Indians in Latin America, and then his own people, the Irish.
And when they hanged him at 52, he had had quite a life. Single-handedly, he had exposed and brought to the attention of the world the unbelievable savagery with which the Belgian king's servants were treating the people of the Congo, which was effectively a private estate of the king, the people his serfs.
He then did the same work in exposing the equally savage treatment British capitalists were inflicting on the native Indian population in the Putamayo.
Casement's was a fine, heroic and selfless life and in the years before 1914, Casement was widely known for the hero he was. Resigning from the British Civil Service, he devoted himself to securing Irish independence and therefore worked against the British Empire. He wrote pamphlets explaining that the British Navy's control of the seas, which was then almost absolute, should not be tolerated by the rest of the world. He had a rather one-sided view of imperialism, believing that Germany was relatively progressive.
When the Protestants of north-east Ulster, encouraged by the British Tory Party, organised an Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF) for armed resistance to the British Liberal Government and the All-Ireland Home Rule Parliament it was trying to set up in Dublin, Casement was one of those who organised an Irish Nationalist Volunteer Force to win Home Rule.
Soon war broke out, and he went to Germany, where he published denunciations of Britain's role in the world and tried to induce captured Irish prisoners of war to form an Irish brigade to fight with Germany against the British -the sort of work Pilsudski successfully did in creating a Polish legion in alliance with Austria against Russia, which occupied most of Poland.
Casement failed. On Good Friday, 1916, he landed off a German submarine on the coast of Kerry intent on getting the planned Irish rising, which he believed doomed without Germany's help, called off. He was captured immediately, and imprisoned in the Tower of London.
At his trial, where he made a magnificent 'speech from the dock', he was confronted by the Unionist Attorney General, FE Smith, a leader of the UVF, who had, two years before, on the eve of a war, organised the importation of guns from Germany with which to fight the British Liberal Government! "If treason prosper, none dare call it treason!"
Casement's reputation, the consistency of his activities whether for the Congolese, the South American Indians or the Irish, and the fact that he had influenced friends able to bring pressure to bear on the Government on his behalf, created problems for that Government, which was determined to resist the pressure for a reprieve and hang him.
They solved it by circulating pages Casement's alleged diaries which seemed to show him to have been energetic homosexual all his life.
Whether the diaries are genuine or were forged by the British secret service dirty tricks department is still a subject of argument: there is no argument but that the diaries were used to hang Roger Casement. You could say that Roger Casement was the last man hanged in Britain for alleged homosexuality!
They buried him in quicklime in the yard of Pentonville jail, refusing to give the body to the independent Irish state set up in 1922. One of the first acts of the Labour Government when it took power in 1964 was to give up Casement's body, and he was re-buried in Glasnevin Cemetery in February 1965.
Kenneth Griffith's Timewatch account of Casement set out to restore his pre-1914 reputation. Griffith is a Welsh actor whose TV 'histories' are idiosyncratic to say the least. His view: on the Northern Irish Protestants — "Planters' — would embarrass the less rabidly chauvinist of the Provisional IRA! He refers to Casement's judge, Rufus Isaacs, and Lloyd George as *the Welshman and the Jew" as if there could be no such thing as a Welsh Jew. Even so, Griffith did a good job, and for the splendid contempt he expressed for the royal mass murderers and the other coiners of human blood into gold whom Casement exposed I would forgive Griffith a lot. sentiments of the 1990s."
The film is filled with anachronisms. Columbus's brother tells him the local natives are too weak for the work, and that black slaves are needed, decades before black slavery in America began. The same brother utters the memorable words, more California than Columbus, "I've always been here for you" , not to mention his outburst, "For Christ's sake!" , a sure route to the stake in Spain under the Inquisition.
The film is also too violent. Bloodshed, torture and combat do not have to be so graphically shown. Too often, film-makers use it because they can portray it realistically. Rarely do they ask themselves whether they should.
In Scott's view of history, a great man found the Americas, but then people killed the Indians and destroyed the rainforests, making Columbus look bad. Luckily, Scott came along to salvage his name. End of story.
Yet Columbus himself is not what matters. What matters is what happened since, and why. For that, you need history books, not Hollywood.
Scan page 14
ier ORGANISIN
----- pull-quotes -----
Television Timewatch,
but the past rewritten and re-invented, tidie up to match the