Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The Russian Revolution roused the oppressed

Socialist Organiser no. 541, 5 November 1992 · scan p. 12 · about 1,303 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

At the time of the Russian Revolution, black people in America lived under a version The anti-socialist liars now tell us that the Bolshevik Revolution of 1917 was a crime and a mistake from which nothing good ever came. The truth is the opposite. Before it was destroyed by the Stalinist counterrevolution, the beneficient effects of the great workers' revolution of 1917 were felt all across the world and in the most unexpected places. Black people in the USA then lived under American version of apartheid. Inspired by the Bolsheviks, US socialists adopted a radical new approach to the black struggle in America. In this article, James P Cannon, a leader of the early US Communist Party, expelled in 1928 Trotskyism, describes what the Russian Revolution meant for black liberation in the USA. It is only one of many possible examples. U from the Russians in the Comintern, nder constant prodding and pressure the party made a beginning with Negro work in its first ten years; but it recruited very few Negroes and its influence in the Negro community didn't amount to much. From this it is easy to draw the pragmatic conclusion that all the talk and bother about policy in that decade, from New York to Moscow, was much ado about nothing, and that the results of Russian intervention were completely negative.

The earlier socialist movement, out of which the Communist Party was formed, never recognised any need for a special programme on the Negro question. It was considered purely and simply as an economic problem, part of the struggle between the workers and the capitalists; nothing could be done about the special problems of discrimination and inequality this side of socialism. The best of the earlier socialists were represented by Debs, who was friendly to all races and purely free from prejudice. But the limitedness of the great agitator's view on this far from simple problem was expressed in his statement: "We have nothing special to offer the Negro, and we cannot make separate appeals to all the races. The Socialist Party is the party of the whole working class, regardless of colour - the whole working class of the world" (Ray Ginger: The Bending Cross). That was considered a very advanced position at the time, but it made no provision for active support of the Negro's special claim for a little equality here and now, or in the foreseeable future, on the road to socialism. And even Debs, with his general formula that missed the main point — the burning sue of ever present discrimination against se Negroes every way they turned - was TADE I0 his regard, as in all others, to 125 2 utspoken white Here is a summary pronouncement from a Berger editorial in his Milwaukee paper, the Social Democratic Herald: "There can be no doubt that the Negroes and mulattoes constitute a lower race." That was "Milwaukee socialism" on the Negro question, as expounded by its ignorant and impudent leader boss. A harried and hounded Negro couldn't mix that very well with his Milwaukee beer, even if he had a nickel and could find a white man's saloon where he could drink a glass of beer at the back end of the bar. claim here and now, the road to socialism."

Berger's undisguised chauvinism was never the official position of the party. There were other socialists, like. William English Walling, who was an advocate of equal rights for the Negroes. and one of the founders of the National Association for the Advancement of Coloured People in 1909. But such individuals were a small minority among the socialists and radicals before the First World War and the Russian Revolution. Such was the traditional position inherted by the early Communist Party from the preceding socialist movement out of which it had come. The policy and practice of the rade union movement was even worse. The barred mi body from membership DON Freed. But the days, under the influence and pressure of the Russians in the Comintern, were slowly and painfully learning to change their attitude; to assimilate the new theory of the Negro question as a special question of doubly-exploited second class citizens, requiring a programme of special demands as part of the overall programme — and to start doing something about it. Everything new and progressive on the Negro question came from Moscow, after the revolution of 1917, and as a result of the revolution — not only for the American communists who responded directly, but for all others concerned with the question.

By themselves, the American communists never thought of anything new or different from the traditional position of American radicalism on the Negro question. That, as the above quotations from Kipnis' and Shannon's histories show, was pretty weak in theory and still weaker in practice. The simplistic formula that the Negro problem was merely economic, a part of the capital/labour problem, never struck fire among the Negroes — who knew better even if they didn't say so; they had to live with brutal discrimination every day and every hour. There was nothing subtle or concealed about this discrimination. Everybody knew that the Negro was getting the worst of it at every turn, but hardly anybody cared about it or wanted to do anything to try to moderate or change it. The 90 percent white majority of American society, including its working class sector, north as well as south, was saturated with prejudice against the Negro; and the socialist movement reflected this prejudice to a considerable extent even though, in deference to the ideal of human brotherhood, the socialist attitude was muted and took the form of evasion. The old theory of American radicalism —ed our in practice to be a formula for saction on the Negro front, and incidentally • senient shield for the dormant racial prejudices of the white radicals themselves.

The Russian intervention changed all that, and changed it drastically, and for the betEven before the First World War and he Russia • Revolution, Lenin and the Boldistinguished from all the other of apartheid tendencies in the international soci: labour movement by their concern problems of oppressed nations and minorities, and affirmative support struggles for freedom, independence right of self-determination. after the revolution of and as a result of the revolution."

The Bolsheviks gave this support to all "people without equal rights" sincerely and earnestly, but there was nothing "philanthropic" about it. They also recognised the great revolutionary potential in the situation of oppressed peoples and nations, and saw them as important allies of the international working class in the revolutionary struggle against capitalism. After November 1917 this new doctrine with special emphasis on the Negroes began to be transmitted to the American communist movement with the authority of the Russian Revolution behind it. The Russians in the Comintern started on the American communists with the harsh, insistent demand that they shake off their own unspoken prejudices, pay attention to the special problems and grievances of the American Negroes, go to work among them, and champion their cause in the white community. It took time for the Americans, raised in a different tradition, to assimilate the new Leninist doctrine. But the Russians followed up year after year, piling up the arguments and increasing the pressure on the American communists until they finally learned and changed, and went to work in earnest. And the change in the attitude of the American communists, gradually effected in the [wenties, was to exert a profound influence in far wider circles in the later years. list and vith the lational of their and the

----- pull-quotes -----

"The best early socialists were free from prejudice, made no provision for active support of the Negro's special

"Everything new and progressive on the Ne question came from M

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 541

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →