Where the left goes wrona on Maastricht
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-11-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
Martin Thomas argues that the Left must oppose the Maastricht Treaty, but in the name of a democratic united Europe, not nationalist Europhobia. S the Maastricht Treaty. The ocialist Organiser is against Treaty calls for a European Central Bank which will wield economic power independent of all elected political control. It continues the process of European integration on an undemocratic, capitalist basis, regulated by haggling between governments rather than by the elected Europarliament which remains powerless.
For socialists to back Maastricht as "not perfect, but the best available" — which is the official Labour Party line — is to give up on the battle for the labour movement to intervene in the process of European integration and to influence it in our interest. Instead, we would just pick the "best available" of the options on offer from the bosses at any given time.
However, the common Labour left version of opposing Maastricht also gives up on Euro-campaigning; instead it tilts at windmills.
Socialist Organiser is in favour of a united Europe, even under capitalism. We refuse to make "Maastricht" , "Brussels" and "Europe" scapegoats for evils which arise from capitalism, not from any treaty or office or geographical unit. When we oppose Maastricht, we oppose equally the immediately available capitalist alternative - continued or heightened barriers between the countries of Western Europe.
But many on the Labour left are against any sort of united Europe. Tony Benn denounces "a federal Europe" of any description, democratic or undemocratic, socialist or capitalist. Others on the left favour a socialist united Europe some time in the future, but oppose all European unity now, under capitalism.
The removal of legal, political, economic and cultural barriers between the countries of Europe will not do away with the evils of capitalism. But it will bring economic and cultural benefits -even now, even under capitalism - and it will make it easier to achieve the cross-Europe workers' unity which we will need for socialism. Isolated national economies are no longer an adequate framework for capitalism, let alone for socialism.
Many on the left also scapegoat "Maastricht" for such evils as welfare cuts - which the Tories were making before the Maastricht Treaty was even thought of - and they look at the political battles over Maastricht through distorting spectacles. To them, somehow, the battles appear to be mainly between them (the antiMaastricht left) and the Eurobosses, with the powerful right-wing bourgeois nationalist anti-Maastrichters as a minor sideshow. Fincher, then the single so or these left-wing anti-MaasEgan "No to Maastricht!" pushes out all the slogans for a working class intervention into the process of European integration - levelling-up of workers' rights and conditions across Europe; cross-Europe campaigns for such demands as the 35-hour week; democratic control by an elected Euro-parliament over EC affairs. They give up on these This version of anti-Maastricht politics is well illustrated by Socialist Outlook of 10 October.
Outlook hails the strikes against cuts in Italy as "the first antiMaastricht strikes" (their emphasis).
But they are not anti-Maastricht strikes! They are "anti-Rome" strikes - directed against the Italian bosses and the Italian government which has ordered the cuts. -In Italy as in Greece (whose recent strikes are also claimed by Outlook as "anti-Maastricht"), almost no-one opposes Maastricht.
When we oppose Maastricht, we oppose equally the immediately available capitalist alternative — continued or heightened barriers between the countries of Western Europe.
Generally, the poorer EC countries see closer European integration (and EC aid for their farmers) as the only way to dynamic capitalist growth; while the richer EC countries (Denmark, France, Britain, Germany) have sizeable capitalist factions who favour "nationalist" economic alternatives (for Britain, a Thatcherite future as an offshore production site with lower wages and less social legislation than the core of the EC, attracting American and Japanese investment).
Nobody in Italy is striking against Maastricht, or even voting against it. The strike wave has been sparked by the Italian government moving away from the Maastricht road by pulling the lira out of the Exchange Rate Mechanism. (The core of the Maastricht Treaty is to make the ERM tighter and tighter until eventually it produces a single currency). In fact, the Italian government's devastating cuts in health spending and pensions -like the similar cuts due to be announced by the British government on 12 November - are proof that the immediate "antiMaastricht" capitalist options are no better than the Maastricht options.
Outlook argues that "monetary union means massive deflation and the destruction of state wel fare systems" . But the EC governments would not have signed the "Euro-monetarist" Maastricht Treaty unless they all wanted cuts anyway. The Treaty adds not a new commitment to cuts - the anti-Maastricht Thatcherites are as pro-cuts as any pro-Maastrichter - but a commitment to coordinated rather than uncoordinated cuts.
The Italian cuts are not imposed by "Maastricht" , any more than the British cuts will be. No EC police threatened to arrest Amato and Major if they failed to make cuts; no EC army threatened to invade their countries! In fact, the only change in welfare provision recently imposed on Britain by the EC — by diplomatic pressure — is an improvement in maternity leave. T onto "Maastricht" or o divert blame for the cuts "Europe" is to let our "own" bosses off the hook aid to poison the fight back with nationalism. All proportions guarded, the superstitious thinking here is rather like the left-wing antisemitism common in the early years of this century, which blamed the evils of the profit system on "Jewish finance capitalists"
The Jewish finance capitalists, the Rothschilds and the Bleichroders, did exist, and they were no better than the gentile finance capitalists — just as the EC exists, and it is no less capitalist than the governments making it up. But to blame the evils of capitalism on the Jewish minority of capitalists was as foolish and diversionary as blaming them on the EC bureaucracy, which is a very flimsy thing in comparison with the national governments and the great capitalist multinationals.
The picture of the Maastricht Treaty as a powerful foreign demon forcing the Italian and British governments to make cuts is a nationalistic myth. All the more so because, on sober calculations, the ERM crisis has made Maastricht unworkable. There is no prospects of the different currencies "converging" on the Maastricht timetable. The Treaty is a piece of paper, of possible value in future diplomatic haggling, but with no force to compel anyone to do anything.
To set up "Maastricht" as the target of working class struggles is therefore to tilt at windmills and divert from the real targets. It is like anti-semitism in a country with no Jews.
Socialists should give no support to the Maastricht Treaty, and we should fight for Labour to use the Maastricht issue to bring the Tories down; but we should oppose any diversion of working class struggles into nationalist "anti-Maastrichtism", and argue clearly for European workers' unity and a democratic united Europe.
Scan page 8
Pamphlets from Socialist Organiser