Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

75th anniversary of the Russian Revolution of 1917 When the workers seized control

Socialist Organiser no. 541, 5 November 1992 · scan pp. 3–4 · Sean Matgamna · about 3,080 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Sing in the no one. eventy-five years ago someappeared in the world - a state ruled by the working class.

The great swirling mass movement of workers - supported by the poor farmers - seized control in the old empire of the Tsars, kicking the bloody Tsar into his Editorial Board Ginaham Bash ladiminDerer Terry Eagleton Jatin Haria (Labour Party Black Sectionsi Dorothy Macedo pen largo John Mellroy John Nicholson Peter Tatchell Members of the Advisory Committee are drawn from a broad cross section of the left who are opposed to the Labour Party s witch-hunt against Socialist Organiser. Views expressed in articles are the responsibility of the authors and not of the Advisory beata call not of the Advisor e well-deserved grave chasing away the landlords capitalists.

They created new structures of power: workers' councils - in the Russian language, "soviets" -allowed the workers to rule themselves in a direct democracy.

Only once before, in Paris in 1871, had such a state existed -and it had been crushed after two months, drowned in the blood of more than 20,000 workers of Paris, killed by the reactionaries after they regained control.

The Russian workers, learning from the fate of their Parisian predecessors, ruthlessly fought for and held on to power. They fought and won a long and destructive civil war.

With Leon Trotsky in command of their Red Army, they defeated the armies of 14 states - one of which was Britain - sent to crush the workers' revolution.

When the workers finally lost power, it was not to the friends of the Tsar or to invading imperialist armies, but to the state bureaucracy led by Stalin, who crushed all vestiges of working-class socialism in the "Soviet Union The manner or that dereat was strange and unexpected. Stalin's new bureaucratic ruling class pretended to be socialist. The pretence was enormously destructive for socialism. We are only now recovering from that destruction.

Yet, though the manner of defeat was unexpected, defeat itself was not. The Marxist leaders of the Revolution always knew that defeat was inevitable unless the workers in the advanced countries followed their lead and overthrew capitalism.

The ex-Tsarist civilisation was too backward to allow the flowering of a new socialist civilisation on its ruins. To flourish, socialism needed the resources and civilisation of the most advanced capitalist countries. But the workers in countries like Germany - and Britain, where there was a General Strike in 1926 - were defeated. Isolated in Russia's stifling backwardness, the workers revolution was strangled by Stalin.

Today we commemorate and honour the Russian Revolution, those who made it and those -largely the same people - who fought to the death against Stalin to defend it.

Not so long ago we would have had to argue with people who supported the USSR because they thought it was socialist. We would have had to produce facts and arguments to show that the Stalinist system in the USSR was, contrary to its official ideology, the very opposite of what the workers who overthrew the Tsar and the capitalists set out to build. We would have had to brand as monstrous lies the ideas that Stalinism was socialism; that Stalinism and Bolshevism were one; that the totalitarian state in the USSR was a form of working-class freedom.

After the collapse of Stalinism, no-one but a few half-deranged stragglers from the once-mighty army of international Stalinism is prepared to defend the Stalinist system, still less to assert that it was socialism.

The assertion that Stalinism was socialism, the natural result of the 1917 working-class revolution and of any future working-class revolution, is now made almost exclusively by the propagandists of capitalism. They have taken over all the old bloodstained Stalinist lies, as they might take over the stock of a bankrupt competitor, and continue to peddle them.

This poisonous nonsense now comes from avowed anti-socialists, where before it came from sincere but confused would-be socialists. sort!

Stalinism was the murdering negation of the Russian workers' revolution, not its natural development. That fact will slowly became clear again, now that Stalinism outside China has collapsed.

Those socialists who proudly proclaim their adherence to the goals, principles and traditions of the 1917 Russian workers' revolution - as we do now - will make it clear.

The emancipationof the working CHInks aiso the emancipation 04 thumambemus without MII distinction of sex or race." Кан Marx Somalist Orgawisen PO Box 823, London SE15 4NA Newsdeskilo rose re65 Inter delaforepans Vonday Elliora John OlMahor Published by: WL Publications Ltd, PO 3m 823 Londonus ENGRATA Printer wilent Press-EMe duel Roistered as a nonspeper ashielPost Difice Articles do not necessarily reflect the Viewsiof bocialist Urganiser andare in d persohal capacit unless otherwise stated.

Scan page 4

point is simple. The miners do not feel ready to take on almost in the same position as the nurses or other healthworkers, who can't hit profits when they strike. "With 40 million tons of coal stockpiled, what economic clout have we got?" ask many rank-and-file miners.

Since the two big demonstrations in London, this mood has started to change, but only a little. Miners are going to need a little more than promises before they vote to This is a basic fact of the present situation, and there The only way to move forward is to strengthen the miners' own position, or to develop industrial action by other Elsewhere in this paper we look at the case for occupying the pits as a way of strengthening the miners fight, and at moves in the North-West for a Day of Action on Tuesday 17 November in support of the miners.

What about other workers taking action in their own battles, alongside the miners? The picture is not as Slowly but surely, a head of steam is building up in the rail unions, particularly ASLEF, for action over the job losses and depot closures that will result from the pit clo sures. Nothing is definite yet, but many right wingers wh have traditionally backed the ASLEF leaders, and who helped Fullick avoid a fight over privatisation at this year's Annual Delegate Meeting, are very far from The strikes at Drax and Ratcliffe-on-Soar - though mainly by construction workers — show that a fight may be possible in the power stations, which will also face job Outside those immediately threatened by the pit closures, the obvious candidates for opening up a second front are public sector workers who face a pay freeze and The Tories are doing their best to avoid a battle with the firefighters, who are set to win 5% before any wage freeze is imposed. A battle with the post workers looks a lot Uniformed grades have had their offer upped from 2.2% to 2.5%, but that is not going to satisfy the rank and file. The offer is still well below inflation, and prices will rise even faster next year. As one longtime UCW activist put it: "The mood isn't there to accept peanuts".

What seemed like hollow rhetoric from post workers? union leader Alan Tuffin, when at one of the miners' rallies he talked about Mr Major not getting any mail this Christmas, could just turn out to be accurate.

The other immediate possibility of a second front comes from the tubeworkers. This week, RMT members are voting for a series of one-day strikes to stop 5,000 redundancies and attacks on conditions. Let's hope that, this time, the national and local RMT leaders don't lose their bottle like they did this May when they called off strike action. If the post or tubeworkers do open a second front, then all other public sector workers should urge their union to Socialist Organiser No. 541 page 4 Over the last few weeks the pages of Socialist Organiser have been full of appeals for industrial action to help the miners. We have focussed on the NUM leaders' call for a TUC day of action on a working day, which could act as a focus solidarity strikes.

The reason why we have hammered away at this point is simple. The miners the Government on their ow almoct in the came nocition fight.

no point ignoring it or hushing it up.

workers alongside the miners. gloomy as it may first appear. happy.

cuts after the pit closures.

big job losses this year.

more likely. move into action too.

ND

ISIDETHE

UNIONIS not feel ready to take on Many see themselves as the nurses or ather health.

The day cannot be far off now when an IRA bomb in London will kill and maim a sizeable number of people.

The miracle is that it hasn't happened already. Every bomb that goes off makes it more likely, and there are a lot of bombs going off.

Only thin lines of chance, accident and expertise together with the efficiency of coded communication between the Provisional IRA and the police divide these "harmless" explosions from a massacre. A bomb goes off prematurely, a warning is misunderstood or ignored, someone carrying a bomb panics, a bomb is deliberately exploded in a crowd -and you have a lot of dead and maimed people who just happened to be catching a train or having a drink.

Now' culture of the left has no answers.

It has happened many times in Northern Ireland in the last 20 years. I repeat: it will probably happen in London. And there is nothing we can do to stop it happening. All we can do is prepare for it politically.

The left is in no state to face the horrified backlash which will follow a new massacre, as it followed the Birmingham pub bomb massacre in 1974, when the Prevention of Terrorism Act was rushed through Parliament by the Labour government, without a single vote against, and shop stewards in the Midlands took the initiative in getting pro-Irish socialists sacked for their politics. T policy nor serious activity - he British left has neither where Ireland is concerned, nor does it allow honest discussion of the issue. "Troops Out Now" is the best they have, but "Troops Out Now" is not a policy, and the idea that it is betrays a culpable ignorance of Ireland.

"Troops Out" without a political settlement does not imply a united Ireland, still less a socialist united Ireland. It means civil war and repartition.

The new Protestant Irish state emerging at the end would probably be smaller than the Six Counties - though you can't be sure: it would depend on the course of a civil war, on which side could massacre and drive out more of the other's people — but there would still be a second, . "Protestant" ", Irish state. "Troops Out" without a political settlement implies not Ireland united in one state but Yugoslavia, Lebanon, or Sri Lanka and then two Irish states.

Take away the British army now, without a political settlement, and the Catholic/Protestant conflict would still be there, unleashed and murderIreland, where they are only barely a majority overall according to the 1991 census, 54% as against a Catholic 46% and a minority in fully half the land area.

In those circumstances "Troops Out Now" translates into another "demand" "Communal Civil War Now!" It is no wonder that a big majority of the southern Irish and of the Six Counties Catholics - are against the "Troops Out" single-plank policy favoured by the British left, and consider the British left to be blinkered political auxiliaries of the Provos.

That is true, but it is also a misunderstanding. In their own politically incoherent way, the Provos are serious: the British left is not. The British left postures and preens itself with ".... r... revolutionary" phrases about "Troops Out, and damn the consequences!", and fawns on the Provisionals, denying that anyone in Britain has the right even to criticise them. But it is all quite hollow, and has been shown repeatedly to be hollow. T the Brish left has long he truth is that on Ireland been living in an irresponsible fool's paradise sustained by double standards about the realities of the Provisional IRA campaign. Massacres like Enniskillen; the gruesome murder of Irish workers whose jobs, in any way, even remotely, can be said to be "collaborating" with the British or Northern Ireland state; forcing men to drive car bombs to their targets by holding their families hostage - terrible things like that, whose targets are Irish people, Irish workers, have been far away from Britain, and the less spectacular examples scarcely make the papers here. The British left did not have to take notice of things like that, as it notices bombs in It is all unreal. The left can say what it likes. Nobody interferes. It is all of no consequence. Smart operators like the leaders of the SWP, who confuse the skills of an advertising agency technician with principled socialist politics, know it is of no consequence and indulge themselves.

It was not always thus, and in the face of IRA massacres in London it can not continue.

n the early 1970s, when the Northern Ireland "Troubles" were new, things were different. The contrast was brought home to me two weeks ago on the miners' midweek demonstration, when I saw a man unmolested selling the Provisionals' paper An Phoblacht in Hyde Park, with the blackmailing front-page headline, "Britain can stop the bombs".

On the great demonstrations 20 years ago we had our pro-Irish papers ripped up. When Bernadette Devlin, then an MP collaborating with various left groups, went to Pentonville Jail to join the famous demonstration protesting against the jailing of five dockers under the Tory anti-union laws, she was surrounded by a large, very hostile, and threatening crowd, some of whom, on my observation over the two or three days of the "Siege of Pentonville", were seriously committed trade union militants.

When the first bombs started going off in London, early in The British left has double Provisional IRA dier, there are a hundred to take his place". , advised SWP leader Duncan Hallas, in a new inversion of age-old revolutionary rhetoric. Socialist Worker had a front page with the appeal, "Stop the Bombings!"

When the London headquar ters of the Workers' Fight group was subjected to a dawn raid and search by armed police in September 1973, it produced a rare ripple of solidarity. (It was the only such raid; no other left-wing political group has been so raided for many decades). This was London, and it was all very polite. We did not have our place wrecked, as tens of thousands of Northern Ireland Catholic homes were being wrecked by the Army on similiar missions, but it served as a warning to the left. Some of the worst and most arrogant sectarians joined us for a protest meeting at Conway Hall, including the WRP and the SWP (then called IS).

socialists will disgrace themselves off in London in 1973.

After the Prevention of Terrorism Act, the left pulled in its horns. It is a strange fact that the first national demonstration against the PTA — under which Irish people were and are at the mercy of the police -was not organised until the middle of 1975, and not by the bigger left groups but by Workers' Fight and the London People's Democracy under the ragged umbrella of the Troops Out Movement. Susan Carlyle, Judy Smith and I organised it - and little help we got from the left, or from the hostile officers of the Troops Out Movement, then members of the IMG (forerunner of Socialist Outlook and Socialist Action).

When things quietened down, and settled into a long stalemate in Northern Ireland. Around the time of the 1981 hunger strikes, in which ten Republicans died, there was a marked shift on the left, even the Labour Left, to vicarious "Provisionalism" putting the finishing touches to the now smog-thick culture of the left on Ireland: vague support for the Provisionals, and standards about the sionals, and called us Unionists for recognising that the Irish Protestant community also has rights.

This culture can not survive a serious IRA campaign in England. A sign of the times is the SWP's pathetic and cringing Open Letter to the Provos asking them to stop the bombings in Britain, please.

The letter lies about their history. "We have never accepted the view" that the troops are peace keepers, it claims. In fact SW made propaganda in support of the troops in 1969 when it mattered most! Most strong in the letter is the British nationalist double standards. Pleading that British workers do not deserve to be bombed - and of course, they don't -they blandly accept the bombings and shootings Northern Irish workers are subjected to as necessities of war.

The people who wrote this fawning letter made a big fuss when I wrote an angry Open Letter to Gerry Adams after Enniskillen, which was an atrocity against the Irish people killed and maimed, and because it was an attack on a Protestant religious service an atrocity against the whole idea of the equality of all the Irish.

here is a deep anti-Irish the left's abstractly "pro-Irish" politics. One does not react to - or draw conclusions from - an Enniskillen massacre as a human being, or as a socialist, or as an Irish Republican in Tone's or Connolly's or Pearse's sense of that word.

You don't have to take account of the views of the overwhelming majority of the Irish, Protestant and Catholic alike, or even pay attention to the work of Irish academics exploring modern Irish history -the "revolutionary party" is enough. Until the bombs come to... London.

It has been many years since I could listen to a group SWPers or RCPers chanting "Troops Out Now" without the underlying note of brutal British chauvinism jarring on my Irish ears. If things get really hot these "pro-IRA" socialists will disgrace themselves this time - just like they did last time.

I know no easy answers to the terrible conflict in Ireland Only working class unity offers a way out. But I know that the proposal to let the conflict resolve itself in the Yugoslav manner has nothing to do with socialist politics. I know that

----- pull-quotes -----

AGAINST THETIDE By Sean Matgamna

"Only working-class unity offers a way out in Ireland. The romantic Troops Out

If things get really hot, these 'pro-IRA

- as they did when bombs started going

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 541

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →