Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Syrup and mush in Calcutta

Socialist Organiser no. 540, 29 October 1992 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 851 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

bustice forw AVE Chamnell4 er periods in one of Britain's The days are long gone when hameiserved. fe sentec es. prese-mangeri to longermor shent- have commtted. Belinda Weaver City of Joy C tyrdom in the Calcutta ity of Joy, a story of marslums, is a caring, sharing 1990s movie.

It's made by the same man, Roland Joffe, who made The Mission and The Killing Fields, both of which had martyr heroes. Joffe obviously has a thing about martyrdom.

The film is adapted from TV, Tuesday 3 lowewabeL Bpma iV an di movies coulm sentas tortes win ww.hach "justice" was equated with pplce action.

Lifiek ismnokıfekreand thespplkcre emennot puste ii hey we nowtmely anda systemeticedyin counmnt thie ic entainiconnivas cerot awyers megistranes and uid gesw/ ast numbers p/mpent peppielhave beem Dominique Lapierre's book of the same name, but a lot has been changed. The Polish priest character was dropped, probably for box-office reasons, and replaced at centre stage by a minor character, the American doctor, Max.

We're meant to sympathise with Max, who has fled from hi-tech American medicine to India in search of the meaning of life. He eventually finds it in selfless work at a free clinic in the Calcutta slums.

To get to that point, Max has to be converted, and the film is helanoleda by ciompiisemt law counts cting onthe sag so of llicensed mo li cemiors.i SpuIe Aftentie erposuremnthe cpurts ofenlonçu sertes ofmpoice frameupsmof rüst peoplemrasonnectowwch RA bombangsthe credo ac ymoflk he mp pilicewismart mts weste b doven eo enteryCanel14ks Jostice far AVEN notr improven thes policer images lt tellisathe is torin ofl Sefes Kisrko whp waswa lrpadlel manci liorai7 yeprs forma crimecher paltinot about that — how Max comes to see that the best of life is there, in the slums, with the downtrodden, the poor-buthonest, the outcasts and the lepers.

Yes, it's one of those movies. It glorifies the slums, it glorifies human suffering, as a school in which people learn to forget themselves and their problems, and to make life bearable by working together as one big communal family.

The flaw in this jewel is gangsterism. Most of the slumdwellers are prey to a corrupt Godfather who dictates their lives — who will work, who will have a roof over his head. His tentacles are everywhere.

Max, as the American in the white hat, chastises the Indians for their fatalism in succumbing to the Godfather, and urges them to fight. He's condescending, and rude to them, and ignorant as well. His methods lead to disaster. It's not Max's aggression that changes things, but luck and solidarity. Yet part of the film's message is that the slumdwellers needed a Max to get them going. If Max was looking for martyrdom as a way of assuaging his existing sense of guilt and hopelessness, he certainly found it in the script of City of Joy, which shows him up as an ass.

The film's other main character, the rickshaw puller, Hasari Pal, is meant to represent the values Joffe admires — family loyalty, integrity, and the acceptance of a lowly lot with dignity and patience.

"It's nauseating watching a Western film-maker go mushy about the triumph of the human spirit over adversity when his own spirit never has to know suffering."

He's the "ideal" peasant, a perfect martyr. Joffe would have no sympathy with a grumbling slumdweller, or a dishonest one - they wouldn't match his condescending view of the "greatness" of "little" people.

City of Joy is a sickly movie, preaching a lot of sanctimonious claptrap. It's nauseating watching a Western film-maker go all mushy about the triumph of the human spirit over adversity when his own Western spirit never has to know want, or hunger, or suffering. If Joffe wants a hair shirt, there are monasteries to accommodate him. He should keep his reactionary garbage to himself. living.

"There are socialistic messages bosses jeopardising safety for profit, and downright anti-Tory propaganda"

So to London's Burning. Not a very highbrow treatment of the above themes, perhaps, but it isn't just ghoulish. You don't get those close-ups of bloody injury there are in Casualty. Instead, exciting accident locations with people rushing around, efficient or hysterical, depending on whether they are emergency services or members of the public. An lots of socialistic messages about bosses jeopardising safety for profit, and downright anti-Tory propaganda.

Currently, Blue Watch are campaigning against merger with another station, because they know it's about cutting costs, not about better service for workers or public. "What are we going to do about this merger business, sub?" asks one firefighter. Sub: (indicating staff noticeboard) "We'll have to get the Union onto this. Of course, we usually only bother with them at the annual pay review, but..." etc.

Another good thing is the actors whom it would be hard to imagine in any other role. But, if you see them on a demo in the coming weeks, (as you are apt to, them being such right-on people) don't be disappointed not to find them in big, blue overcoats, darling. They're only actors, after all.

Scan page 14

iser

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 540

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →