Onto the defensive
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-10-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
W the strike went decidedly ith the start of November, onto the defensive. After months of chipping away, the Coa Board finally claimed a breakthrough with scabbing in North Derbyshire. The NCB offered a massive Christmas bribe to miners — who had not had a wage packet for eight months, and were now suffering serious hardship — if they returned to work. By November 19 the NCB was claiming a record 2,282 miners returning to work on a Monday.
The NUM was organising a series of regional strikers' rallies. These showed the tremendous continuing determination of the hard core of "Ramsay MacKinnock' sat on the fence throughout the strike the strike, but also their bittern about the official leaders of lab At Aberafan on November 13 a symbolic noose was dangled in front of TUC general secretary Norman Willis; Ramsey MacKinnock' was pilloried for refusing to speak at the rallies.
Now there was a growing note anguish in Arthur Scargill's appeals: "We have to translate reso lution into action. I am not going te appeal to the barons of the TUCI want to ask the ordinary men and women of this country to give industrial action support to this union. "How much longer can you stand to one side and see this union battered? We are asking you to come out now and stop scab coal being delivered into power stations" (Birmingham, November 14: SO 206).
The labour movement was shamelessly leaving the NUM to its fate in the struggle against the government. So the Tories pressed relentlessly on.
On November 30 the Tories delivered what they hoped was a knock-out punch. Tory lawyer Herbert Brewer was appointed by the High Court as receiver of the NUM's finances. Brewer declared, "I am the NUM"
Legally, he was the NUM. But there was another NUM, not the notional legal entity now embodied by the High Court in the unlikely figure of the former Tory councillor, but the 140,000 striking miners and their families. And that NUM refused to go down t blow. They refused t union's money, whic moved overseas.
appeals: 1 am not going to appeal to the barons of the TUC - I want to as industrial action support to this union.
Four days previously, on November 26, the High Court had fined the TGWU £200,000 (to be paid by December 10) for supporting the Austin Rover strike without a ballot in Tory-prescribed form.
But the TGWU would not pay the fine.
Unfortunately, it would not do anything positive either. The meeting of its executive in early December decided to take no action against the threat to the union. If passive endurance could beat the der the ne surrender the they had Tories, then the TGWU would The politics of Socialist Organiser have done the workers of Britain a great service in 1984. But passivity We stand — even defiant passivity — is not enough. Workers' Now Arthur Scargill's efforts to rouse the labour movement and to make it aware of what was happening reached a new peak of desperate urgency. Again and again he £1.50 plus appealed for industrial action to back the miners: "There must be the most massive mobilisation of industrial action our movement has socialist ever known, and we must have it Omaniser now. "There is no other way to stop the court's attempt to destroy the NUM" (SO 209). STABNED, Other voices on the left augment- BATTERED, ed and supplemented Scargill's. "DEFINES Tony Benn (reportedly on the private urging of Scargill and MAGNIFICENT Heathfield) called for a general strike. So did Dennis Skinner.
MINERS But the TUC leaders did nothing Faced with jeering, baiting demands from Mrs Thatcher and her press that he do so, Neil - THEMS STRIKEKinnock denounced pickets "violence' Things were going badly for the miners, but, despite all the miners" Magnificent difficulties, the Tories were still scared of a second front. That was Miners shown very clearly by the careful way the courts handled the TGWU, 75p plus 34p using an official called the 'Queen's Remembrancer' to take £200,000 rather than seizing the union's All roms whole funds. Despite everything, POIBIOR 8213, Turn to page 12 ondon SE15-NA
Scan page 12
janiser From page 11 even a limited initiative from other unions could have swung the balance against the government.
Socialist Organiser proposed a campaign for a recall TUC, whic might call the leaders to account for their failure to implement the decisions of September. A campaign for a recall TUC could be used to focus discussion of the miners' strike in the trade union branches. We argued that, if a full general strike were not possible immediately, then as a first step a 24-hour general strike should be called by the pro-NUM unions or even by the NUM itself.
The NUM leaders followed up their November rallies with a speaking tour in the pit villages during December. The back-to-work drive tapered off, collection increased as Christmas came nearer, and at Christmas itself the pit communities celebrated with defiant solidarity. Despite all the hardships, many strikers and many strikers' wives insisted that it was their best Christmas ever, because of the warmth and comradeship. Instead of isolated families each slumped in front of their television, whole communities came together to support each other and celebrate.
But the turn of the year brought back the grimness.
As if to rub brine in the miners" wounds, the Tories marked New: Year's Day by giving peerages to Len Murray and former electricians' leader Frank Chapple — the symbols and representatives of everything in the labour move. ment that had combined with the slump and effects of mass unemployment to allow the Tories to impose the sufferings of a tenmonth strike on the miners and their families, and would ultimately allow them to win the strike.
The steady dribble back to wor was now usually to be measured in hundreds per day. Neil Kinnock decided that the strike had gone near enough to defeat for him to visit a picket line (by chauffeur-driven car) in the same way that he might attend commemorations for the Tolpuddle Martyrs.
But the miners were very much alive. The indomitable spirit of defiance of capitalist 'normality' was still strong.
At Kiveton Park the strike started to break up seriously from January 21, after 10 months out and five months of heavy police occupation of the village.
When people set out together on a difficult, testing struggle, and some of them break and give up or change sides, those who continue to fight are forced to think hard and define for themselves and others just what they think they are doing. Albert Bowns did that when Reg Moss, a branch official at Kiveton Park, started scabbing in late January and allowed the Daily Express to proclaim the fact and use him agains. the strikers. Albert Bowns published an open letter to Moss — and to others who had given up the strike — in Socialist Organiser:
Reg Moss had said he wanted to return to 'normal life' . But: "What is normal about having to accept mass redundancies? What is normal about having to accept pit closures on economic grounds (possibly Kiveton Park)?
"What is normal about craftsmen being de-skilled..? In effect, what is normal about running to accept every crumb which the management might condescend offer us?
"That is the normality" which you will have to return to if the rest of us follow your example.
indomitable spirit of defiance of capitalist 'normality' was still strong."
*The Kiveton Park NUM was directed to fight against this kind of 'normality' and will continue to do so until the final outcome" (SO 214).
Socialist Organiser tried to present an accurate picture of the stages the strike went through as it unfolded. We refused to voice any of the pessimism or defeatism rampant in sections of the left (in Socialist Worker, for example.
Even so, by February 6 we had to admit: "Whatever the exact number of new scabs, it is true that a steady stream of strikers seem to be giving up and letting themselves be driven back to work.
Inevitably this drift back puts pressure on the strikers and encourages Thatcher's belief that her lust for the NUM's blood can be satisfied" (SO 215).
In this adverse situation, South Wales NUM official Kim Howell floated the idea of a return-towork without an agreement The NUM executive did not even discuss the idea and Kim Howells was removed from his job as area NUM spokesperson.
But the damage had been done.
And then the TUC stepped in with its final blow.
Frickley, Yorkshire, ( O Stect, not rich to homing. n February 19 seven TUC Street, not even bothering to conceal their glee that they were back in contact with the people who had just sent Len and Frank to the House of Lords. They eagerly took on the job of acting as messenger boys to the NUM. The message from Thatcher said, in essence: 'Surrender, or else. No negotiations no concessions: surrender!"
When the NUM rejected this docament, the TUC let it be known that they were washing their hands of the miners, and retired to let Thatcher urge her surrender terms under the title of the TUC document'.
Few things in the strike were more sickening than the cat-and-mouse games played by the government rom November to the end. First they offered the Christmas bribe to needy miners, and howled with indecent glee when some miners deserted the strike. They were showing their displeasure with Scargill's undemocratic methods, said the press, as the broken men slunk back to work.
Then the Tories played the game of the on-off negotiations, raising the hopes of the miners and then, having softened up a few, slamming the door and waiting for more miners to give in. Having said for months that the NACODS deal was on offer to the NUM, they withdrew it at the point, at the end of the strike, when Arthur Scargill said he would accept it.
The Tories now did not want a setdement. They wanted to shred the NUM.
Commenting on the great Dublin lockout of 1913, the employers" leader in that struggle, William Martin Murphy, cynically identifier the fundamental disadvantage for labour in any long industrial war of attrition. The workers, he pointed out, soon have difficulties getting enough to eat; the employers rarely have that problem. By March 1985 Britain's glorious miners had that problem.
The Tories had all the resources of the ruling class at their disposal. The miners, some 2 percent of the labour movement, had to fight 100% of that centralised ruling class power with insufficient support and sometimes downright sabotage from the leaders of the other 98%. That was the cause of the defeat.
On March 3 the eighth NUM conference since the strike began met to decide what to do. South Wales proposed a return-to-work without an agreement. Arthur Scargill opposed the return to work, and so did the executive. They argued instead that, with over 50 percent of miners still out, the strike should continue until 700 sacked strikers got their jobs back.
The majority of delegates felt that there was a danger that a big acceleration of scabbing would further erode the union's bargaining power on the 700 (and everything else, and result, ultimately, in a return to work with the union in tatters. They decided to stop that happening.
Starved, battered, but still defiant, they voted by 98 to 91 to return to work without a settlement, but as a still-intact union.
To go back without the 700, and fight for their reinstatement in local negotiations, was a bitter and agonising decision to have to take. In the circumstances the conference had little viable alternative. This Although the strike was over, the continued was confirmed a few days later when the first wave of Labour cou cils failed to deliver on their promises of opening up a second front, and instead collapsed ignominiously.
Once the decision was taken, Scargill and the left-wingers on the executive urged a united return to work, and most areas went back on Tuesday 5th.
Kent, and a few pits elsewhere, stayed out for a week after the national return to work. Polmaise, in Scotland, the first pit out in 1984, did not go back until Tuesday March 12, after one year and four weeks on strike.
"The greatest strike in British history was over. But the miners" strike was one battle a war, and the war is far from over."
The greatest strike in British history was over. But the miners' strike was one battle in a war, and the war is far from over. "The fight goes on", said Arthur Scargill after the decision to return had been taken. The NUM has been forced to retreat to 'guerrilla' struggle— "like the Resistance in World War 2", as Scargill put it.
It was a defeat; and what we said during the dispute about the heavy implications of a defeat for the whole labour movement was true. But it was not just a defeat; nor was the struggle in vain. As SO (219220) said:
"The 1984-5 miners" strike will inspire not only future generations but this one. The miners have shaken Britain and remodelled the political landscape. Class conflict, class bitterness and class hatred on FREE STICE CHT LET TH PHERE-STAND-ALON campaign to free jailed miners a level not seen here for a very long time have been brought into the cen tre of British politics. The ruling class starved men, women and children for a year, and now Mrs Thatcher gloats in public over her triumph. But the miners' strike has stored up memories and hatreds -not only among miners and their families - that the ruling class and the Tories will live to regret.
"Tens of thousands have learned that capitalism is a soulless system that sacrifices people for profit; tens of thousands of new militants have learned to hate capitalism and those who run it.
"Coming out of jail after a week of being locked up simply because she insisted on picketing, despite police "cautions' and despite bail conditions, Nottinghamshire striking miner's wife Brenda Greenwood spoke the language and expressed the feelings that live in thousands who have gone through the miners' strike:
"This is not, as the editorial writers fondly believe, the language of the past, or of a stage in the history of the labour movement which the miners' strike has brought to an en It is the language of the future.
"The shattering experience of being sent to prison will be etched on my memory for as long as I live. But I am in no way deterred, nor has my spirit been broken.
"The time has come for the working class of the 1980s to stand up and be counted. We must not be afraid to face the machinery of the state head-on in defence of our rights.
"We must fight on every front in defence of all the rights and standards that have been won for us in blood, sweat and tears by the working class of the past.
"It is our duty to defend, protect and uphold all these rights and stan dards, and it is our proud heritage t hold them in trust for future genera tions of our class.
Scan page 13
Organiser Television Derek Morris reviews After the revolution... less domestic violence, fewer Broad accidents and definitely no desperate businessmen setting light to warehouses for the insurance. But what of human beings? taste for "entertainment" based on these things? Perhaps ghoulishness goes too deep to be "cured". Anyway, why not be intere ed in death, heroism, trage sympathy? They're part of
----- pull-quotes -----
"There was growing "There was growing anguish in Scargill's
the ordinary men and women to give
"But the miners were very much alive. The
TERRY FOR FRENCH FRENCH
London's Burning, Sunday 8.45, ITV