So far, so good, Arthur
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-10-29Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
role of national folk-hero. The transformation cannot explained by anything as simple as the fact that all his predictions about the Tories' plans of the mines have turned out to be (in the words of Nicholas Ridley) "uncal nily accurate". What seems to have impressed the pundit is a new "statesman-like" approach, the cultivation of "public opinion" and (especially) the avoidance of calls Undoubtably, there will be those on the left who will accuse Scargill of going soft. But Scargill is no fool: he surely knows that the 1984/5 defeat has left even the most loyal NUM stalwarts reluctant to commit themselves to all-out strike action without some pretty firm pledges of support from the rest of the movement. And given the present precarious state of the government, the idea of forcing a U-turn without the threat of immediate strike action is not completely ridiculous (last week's promise of a "moratorium" was far from a U-turn but it did demonTo take these considerations into account before gambling everything on a strike call is not a sign of Scargill The wisdom of Scargill's approach so far has been shown by the change in mood amongst rank and file NUM members over the last week or so: miners who had been resigned to closure and tempted by "generous" redundancy pay are now changing their minds. At Parkside colliery in Lancashire (one of the 10 threatened with closure after the 90 days "moratorium") an NUM branch meeting last Saturday voted to reverse its previous position and to resist redundancies using "any means posBut, of course there are dangers: at the emergency meeting of the TUC General Council on Saturday 17 October Scargill was more or less blackmailed into ruling out industrial action for the foreseeable future, in exchange for official TUC backing for a "hearts and minds" campaign in support of the miners. The grandees of New Realism — notably Bill Jordan of the AEEU and John Edmonds of the GMB - proposed a "Jobs and Recovery Campaign", concentraing on a call for "urgent discusssion with the government and CBI about a programme for national recovery". The emphasis of the campaign is to be lobbying members of all parties in the Commons and Lords, buttering up church-people and the CBI and supporting legal moves to block pit closures. Even last Wednesday's lobby was considered a bit too militant it was on a weekday, so might be construed as encouraging solidarity action) and so it had to be played down and the march on Sunday 25 was emphasised instead.
Of course, the TUC's miserable "Jobs and Recovery Campaign" is not going to be enough to reverse the pit closures, let alone force a fundamental change in the government's economic policy. But it should not be simply dismissed out of hand: the idea of generalising the miners campaign into a campaign against the Tories is not a bad one in principle. And anything that helps build the miners? confidence in preparation for eventual industrial action is to be welcomed. So far, Scargill has played his hand cleverly and has certainly gained more from playing along with the TUC than he has had to sacrifice.
This phony war situation can't last indefinitely, but so far so good: the time for criticising Scargill hasn't arrived activity, seems scarcely to he rehabilitation of INSIDE THE exist. That too can begin to change. been little short of UNIONIS Against the widespread miraculous. During the retreat of the left from the 1984/85 strike he was a labour movement - and it is a national bogey man, a threa retreat, no matter what "milto democracy and civilisa- itant" "socialist" and tion as we know it. After the righteously anti-reformist strike's defeat he became a Slogans are shouted -figure of fun, his class war Socialist Organiser has insistrhetoric held up for ridicule ed on the centrality of the as the rantings of an irrele- By Sleeper labour movement, Labour vant dinosaur. Party and trade unions alike, Now, Scargill's back in the for all socialist perspectives.
It is another way of saying "Trades Councils and Labour Parties for precipitate strike action. should launch broad anti-Tor! action committees strate how vulnerable the government is).
campaign going soft — it is simply sensible tactics. groups as u as the usua labour movement affiliates." that the working class is central to all socialist sible". perspectives. There is no longer any reason to doubt who was right in this dispute. W here? The immediate here do we go from focus of the movement must be defence of the miners. The Tories continue with closures: there will most likely be a new attempt at widespread shutdowns in the New Year. Against closures, the miners should seize control of the threatened pits and then conduct a tremendous political campaign around such occupations, building political support and solidarity strikes.
Last week's demonstrations proved that a TUC-called Day of Action on a working day would bring millions of workers out in support of the miners — and in protest at the long chain of past and present Tory atrocities, the latest of which is the proposal to close ten London hospitals. Trade unions and Labour Parties should demand that the TUC take up Arthur Scargill's proposal, and call such a Day of Action.
Trades Councils and Labour yet. Parties should launch broad anti-Tory action committees in every area, drawing in commuworkers can win wide support. Photo: John Harris 000/070
Scan page 5
or activity for the millions of the labour movement, but slogans and activity to "build the party" by recruiting young people who want to fight and have had no chance of learn to understand how to fight, or how to relate to the labour movement. - is also an alternative - on paper, or the SWP, "General Strike!"
not in life - to the necessary political focus and slogans dictated by the situation the labour movement is in: the need to fight for a Labour government.
Yet, the Labour Party remains the labour movement's only alternative to the Tories, and, short of an immediate socialist revolution, there is no way other than by a Labour government to break this Tory Government of big business. Even a general strike would not immediately change that: in 1918, the traitor right wing of the German Social Democracy was, even after soviets had been created, the working-class "party of government".
Denial that there is this necessary political dimension to the labour movement - through the Labour Party, for now - is usually no more than a way of abandoning politics to the right wing.
In fact, the SWP's call for a General Strike to kick out the Tories must translate into either a call for revolution now, or a call for a General Strike to force the Tories to call a General Election! This, we repeat, is not serious politics. It is trifling and slogan-mongering to "build the revolutionary party". It will not build a revolutionary party, but a stupid and irresponsible sect.
The Labour Left is in bad shape? Yes. One reason for that is the decline of trade union confidence and militancy in the 1980s. The revival of that militancy opens up the prospect of a revival of the Labour Left too.
n any case the movement must if it is to develop, and not be a After the pits, the Tory axe is now set to fall on London's hespitals.
The Tomlinson Report into the future of the health service in the capital, backed by Health Secretary Virginia Bottomley, has just been published.
It means that 10 famous hospitals face closure and 20,000 health workers could lose their jobs.
The report includes the following recomendations: • Barts to close as a hospital LAN with accident and emergency facilities. Instead there is to be a day time only health care centre on part of the site. Either Guy's or St Thomas's will close, almost certainly the latter.
The Middlesex Hospital site will close.
Two weeks after Princess Di opened a new multi-million pound clinical block, the Royal Marsden faces closure Some facilities will be transfered to the Charing Cross The Queen Elizabeth Hospi for Children will also close, putting a big question mark over the future of Great Ormond Street Children's hospital.
This butchery is taking place in the name of rationalisation, yet the report provides no answers to some of the major problems facing London's health service. • London's children are missing out on crucial vaccinations and women on vital cervical smear tests as a result of a Organiser over 2 years for treatment.
London has 65% of the bed capacity per person of Paris and 50% that of New York. The final result of the implementation of the Tomlinson report is that 250,000 people will be denied hospital treatment of one kind or another each year.
While useful caring jobs are slashed, the introduction of the market and Trusts into the NHS has only lead to a big increase in the number of managers who are needed to
----- pull-quotes -----
every area, drawing in community