The miners divided
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-10-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
labour movement had the police behaved as they did in the miners' strike. They concentrated in large masses, deployed and controlled from a centre at Scotland Yard. They set up roadblocks to stop Yorkshire miners moving into Notts and Kent miners into the Midlands. They stopped, searched, and arrested at will. They used thuggery and violence on a scale not known in any modern labour dispute in Britain.
They behaved as wreckers and bully-boys in certain pit villages as if they were understudying the British army in the Catholic parts of Northern Ireland.
And something else was new -organised scab-herding, on a vast scale backed up by a very loud barrage of propaganda.
Many railworkers and dockers refused to move scab coal. On March 29 the transport workers' leaders recommended a total blockade of all coal. But decisive solidarity lay in the hands of the power workers and steel workers to give or withhold - and they withheld it. On March 21 the power unions (including the GMBU) advised their members to cross miners' pickets. Steelworkers, fearful for their industry and bruised and battered from their own 1980 strike, crossed miners' picket lines, The propaganda war against the miners was waged fiercely so as to limit and to try to stop workers supporting the miners, Picketing miners who were at the receiving end of the violence that police officials had spent years preparing for, were pilloried and denounced as purveyors of mindless and gratuitous violence. Miners fighting for their jobs were denounced as undemocratic because they were on strike without sanction of a national ballot - and those who denounced them were industrial autocrats and dictators who were using massed armies of police to try to force the miners to accept the ruin of some of their communities!
Though Labour its support to the miners, the high-profile leaders of the Party hemmed and hawed, joined in the calls for a national ballot - the cutting edge of the propaganda war -and denounced violence, meaning pickets who stood up to the police. By Monday March 26, when the NCB claimed that 38 pits were working normally, the strike had reached a steady level. The strike would strengthen slightly after the NUM conference on April 19, but the contours of the battlefield were already visible, the areas of strength and weakness of either side known, the balance of forces stabilised. An unbudgeable minority of miners - the NUM said about 25,000 - refused to strike. Scabbing miners, picket-crossing power and steel workers, and far too limited general solidarity, forced the miners to dig in for a war of attrition. They knew it would take time. They could not have guessed just how long their war of attrition with the Thatcher government would be.
The 1974 miners' strike lasted just over a month - from February 9 to March 11. Just over a month after the start of the 1972 strike, Saltley coke depot was closed by mass pickets and the government was on the run.
By late March it was already clear that 1984 would be a much longer and more grim affair. Miners talked about "staying out until Christmas" . The Times reported (April 18): "Mrs Margaret Thatcher is willing to spend any amount of money to ensure that the Government is not agajn defeated by the miners' union" . Chancellor Nigel Lawson would later publicly explain that the money spent on beating the miners was a "worthwhile investment" . They would spend over f2 billion on it directly, with indirect losses of perhaps another £3 billion.
Arthur Scargill appealed to workers: "Stop merely saying you support us. Come out and join us. We are facing a fundamental challenge to the whole working class, not merely miners. We are facing the organised might of the state machine" (Nottingham, April 14: SO 175). already a long one by usual standards): but it was marginal. Notts suffered a drift-back after the High Court, on May 25, ruled the strike unofficial in the county: by late August only 20% of Notts miners were out, as against maybe 40 or 50% at the peak. In Staffordshire the strike was fraying at the end of May, and over 50% were scabbing at every pit except Wolstanton by early August. Lancashire weakened.
In the vast majority of pit communities, however, the strike was solid, and becoming more determined and confident.
This was a strike in which something in excess of a hundred thousand workers and their families found themselves up against a pitiless, relentless, determined government which had all the advantages on its side; entrenched power and wealth; the police; the deprivation and sometimes hunger that gripped miners and their families a few weeks into the strike. To stay in the fight the miners and their families had to find in themselves reserves of strength, determination, fortitude and creativity. The mining communities had to rouse themselves completely and throw everything they had into the class war. The strike had to become more than a mere strike. And it did.
The outstanding new thing in the miners' strike was the involvernent of the women of the mining comrnunities.
Women's pickets were a regular feature of the strike, and on May 12 the streets of Barnsley were swamped by an exuberant women's demonstration.
Repeatedly the pit women would cite the women's peace camp at Greenham Common as an inspiration. Direct links were made between the normally somewhat isolated, conservative, male-dominated pit villages, and feminists who might never before have seen class struggle as anything central to For a lot of people. the strike shook up their ideas in a way that normally happens only in great semi-revolutionary struggles like a general strike. Opposed to the Tory class-warriors, the police chiefs, the Fleet Street editorialists eulogising the heroic scabs, here at last was something more than the quibbling, middle of-the-road, trimming whines of Michael Foot and Neil Kinnock. The miners were a pole of opposition, and inevitably they became a magnetic their families to let her offer them as human sacrifices to her savage god, Mammon, the god of profit and lucre; and shocked at the will of the police to use any means necessary to beat the pickets. They started to think about alternatives to Thatcherism.
Jenny Dennis, from Kiveton Park, Yorkshire, told SO in November: "Mining communities are traditionally male-dominated. It's the men that work and the women that do: having babies, washing and making snap is our lot. Then it changed. "It was as though we'd been sleeping for hundreds of years. We awoke, we realised a new political awareness. "Organising food, raising money, speaking. Men have acknowledged that we, as women, are vital to that victory. We're an active part of that struggle, side by side with our men in the battle's frontline.
"We are witnessing something amongst the women which I can only compare with the suffragettes. We are living and making history. We won't return to the status quo. We can't. "Personally it has made me realise that not only must we fight our injustice but others too.
"Because we have lived through media lies we ask ourselves: What other lies have they made?' "Look at the injustice in Ireland. What really happened in Toxteth?
----- pull-quotes -----
their ideas in a way that normally happe only in great semi- revolutionary struggles like a general strike."