THE GREAT STRIKE divided And something
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-10-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
during police rush to get a scab day shift into the pits NOTT MINERS FOR THE STRIKE VIC TO The Notts miners who did strike felt they rote less successful areas out of a job he militant, fighting part of the NUM now had to appeal for basic working class solidarity in defence of their jobs and their communities first to other miners, to members of their own union. That solidarity was refused them.
Scab miners crossed picket lines, sheltered behind the police, played the media's game against the strikers, and used the bosses' courts against their own union and its embattled members and leaders.
Notts scabs claimed they scabbed because they were refused a national ballot. That was the "good reason', not the real one. It keyed the Notts working miners into the Tory propaganda offensive against the strikers, and it allowed the scabs to think of themselves as peaceful democrats and not as scabs. The real reason was that they were scared by the daunting battle ahead, they didn't feel their jobs were threatened, and they had been doing well under the area incentives scheme.
They made a religion of the national ballot because they needed a respectworthy excuse for refusing to help the threatened miners to defend their communities.
A majority of both South Wales and Notts voted against the strike. That's what they had in common in March 1984, though their motives were most likely very different. The magnificent or le-year stand that the miners of Wales can look back on in March 1985 pinpoints where the difference between them lay -ed by pickets from the striking areas. The press and politicians set up a tremendous din, telling the riners that they should not strike without a national ballot. The ballot was democracy and anything else was not democratic.
Newly elected Peter Heathfield put the issue squarely when he said this about the demand for a national ballot: 'Can miners in successful areas have the right to vote miners in less successful areas out of a job?"
To make a national ballot the essence of "democracy" here was to make democracy into a tyranny, and to deny the right of a minority -if miners who wanted to strike were in fact the minority: an opinon poll said that 62% wanted to strike - to Organiser absence of gut class loyalty among the majority of prosperous, unthreatened Notts miners. Only a minority of Notts miners had the selfrespect to stand with their class.
The scabbing in Notts shaped the strike. As well as supplying coal throughout the strike, the 'working miners' gave the NCB a powerful hard core of scabs to build on. Without Notts the Leicestershire and other scabs would not have counted for much. When Notts went back to work on Monday March 19, after one day out, the NCB could claim that 42 pits were working normally.
With the miners split, the fate of the strike would be determined by the outcome of battles on two fronts - the battle of the pickets against the centrally controlled semi-militarised police, who turned some coalfields into something like police states, and the political battle in the labour movement for solidarity from non-miners. In the battle for solidarity the propaganda front was the decisive one.
Never in the living memory of the continued on page 10 defend itself.
The call for a national ballot was never a democratic demand, but a demand to repress and straitjacket the militants.
Once the militants had struck they had every right to appeal for basic working class solidarity to other workers - and in the first place to miners. South Wales, which voted not to strike, showed what was possible here.
Of course a united NUM would have been better by far. The fundamental thing about the NUM in March 1984 was that it was not united, and nevertheless its leaders and militants had to fight back against the well timed Tory offensive.
----- pull-quotes -----
else was new - organised scab- herding, on a va scale backed up by a very loud barrage of propaganda.