Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

The greatest strike in modern British history

Socialist Organiser no. 539, 21 October 1992 · scan p. 8 · about 1,007 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Miners celebrate the announcement of the call for a national strike The miners'strike of 198485 was the greatest strike in modern British history. Here below we tell the first part of the story.

n the small hours of Monday March 12 1984, hundreds of Yorkshire miners moved across the border from Yorkshire into Nottinghamshire. Their destination was Harworth pit, and by the evening shift they had picketed it out.

Over the next few days, hundreds of Yorkshire pickets came down over the border again and spread out across the Notts coalfield. Their mission was to persuade Nottinghamshire's miners to join them in a strike to stop the pit closures announced by the National Coal Board chief, Ian MacGregor. Their tactic was to picket Notts to a standstill.

In the great miners' strikes of 1972 and 1974, miners had picketed coke depots and power stations. In 1984, for reasons which we'll examine, it had to be miners picketing out miners. That fact dominated and shaped the course of the strike.

Within hours, 1000 extra police had been thrown into Nottinghamshire against the picketing miners. Within days there would be 8000 extra police - highly mobile, centrally-controlled, semi-militarised police - moving around the coalfields of Nottinghamshire.

The state had spent a dozen years preparing for this strike and everything had been made ready. Plans to beat mass picketing had been refined; police had been trained; special equipment had been assembled; and a national police nerve centre had been prepared and readied for action.

The Tory government had manoeuvred for years to avoid a premature battle with the miners. In 1981 sweeping pit closures were announced. and then withdrawn when a wave of strikes swept the coalfields. The Tories were determined that the battle would come when the government was ready and thought the time right. In 1981 they weren't ready. The labour movement had not been softened up enough. So Thatcher backed off from a showdown with the NUM. In 1984 they were ready. Now they would provoke the miners to fight back by giving them the alternative of surrendering and letting the NCB do as it liked with the industry.

After years of slump and mass unemployment the labour movement was in a weakened condition Its morale was low, its combativity declining, its leaders more concerned to undercut, sabotage and burke militancy than to fight the Tories. The NUM had been weakened too.

Between the miners' bloodless victory over Thatcher in 1981 and March 1984, 40 pits had been closed or merged. Morale had been eroded. The closures of Kinneil (December 1982) and Lewis Merthyr (March 1983) provoked only limited local struggles.

Arthur Scargill was elected NUM president in December 1981 with 70 per cent of the vote; but in January 1982 miners rejected a leadership proposal to strike over pay by 55%. In October 1982 61% of miners voted not to strike over pay and pit closures - despite a campaign by Arthur Scargill for strike action. In March 1983, when the strike over Lewis Merthyr began to spread from South Wales, the National Executive Committee called for a national miners' strike, but 61% of miners rejected the proposal.

Arthur Scargill repeatedly warned miners that the NCB had a secret 'hit-list' of 70 or so pits marked down for closure, but either he lacked credibility with men or the miners no longer had the stomach to defend themselves. "Within days there would he 8000 extra police -highly mobile, centrallycontrolled, semimilitarised police -moving around the coalfields of Nottinghamshire."

That's how the Tories read it. So they decided that the time had come for a showdown with the miners.

In September 1983 lan MacGregor became chair of the NCB. MacGregor had carved up the steel industry for the Tories. In America in the 1970s he had masterminded the employers' campaign in one of the most brutal labour wars of recent American history - the successful war to break the miners' union in Harlan County. MacGregor was to be the Tories' pit-butcher and union-buster. His appointment was undisguised preparation, if not an outright declaration, of war.

But was the NUM ready for war? The election for NUM secretary in January 1984 showed only a small margin in favour of the victorious left-wing candidate, Peter Heathfield, over his right wing opponent John Walsh. The miners still seemed in the mocd to retreat; the militant leaders of the NUM increasingly out of line with their movement.

So the Tories attacked.

On March 1, when local management announced the closure of Cortonwood colliery in Yorkshire, South Yorkshire miners immediately went on unofficial strike. On March 5, with half the Yorkshire miners already out, the Yorkshire area council called an official strike from March 9.

But South Wales miners had come out over the closure of Lewis Merthyr - and Lewis Merthyr had nevertheless closed. More than local action was needed. Miners had been this far towards confrontation before without an all- out fight.

On March 6 the Scottish area council called on Scottish miners to strike from March 9. Polmaise pit had already been out for three weeks against closure.

Now lan MacGregor took a hand, pouring petrol on the fire. On March 6 he told the NUM that 20 pits would close in 1984, that 20,000 jobs would be cut, and that there might be compulsory redundancies.

MacGregor was telling the NUM either to back off, or to try to stop him closing down 20 pits. The Tories, not the miners, chose this fight. But - after the rejection of their proposal for a national strike over Lewis Merthyr exactly a year before - did the NUM national executive have any alternative but to back off and let the Tory juggernaut roll unopposed over the 'uneconomic' pits and coalfields? To their eternal glory they thought they did have an alternative.

On March 8 the executive endorsed the decision of the Yorkshire and Scottish areas to strike, and they endorsed in advance the decision any other area might take for strike action.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 539

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →