Throw off the slavery of the market!
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-10-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
LOSE
tand whet tabou Party sock ahould do novi Why Labour 75p plus 1 The politics of Socialist Organiser We stand Workers' Liberty E1.50 plus 10853 Organıser STARVEU BATTERED O TANT MAGNIFICENT TPOI MINERS TAC 1384-5 STRIKE Magnificent Miners 75p plus 34p p&p All Proms PO BOx 823, Lomdon SIE 15-407 Martin Thomas indicts the capitalist market economic of the Tories, and argues f the-socialist alternative democratic planning. H Millionaires "need" three or omeless people need houses.
four mansions.
Hungry children need food, and in the prosperous industrialised Britair of 1991 some half a million children still go hungry for lack of cash every month. Millionaires "need" banquets in expensive restaurants.
Barefoot children, or children whose feet have grown need shoes. Imelda Marcos "needed" thousands of pairs of shoes.
The free market tallies supply and demand, more or less. But it always ranks the whims and indulgences of millionaires as more urgent than the needs of the poor - because demand is only effective if backed up with cash.
And the existence of millionaires and poor people is a logical, inevitable result of market economies.
The person with more money can buy goods at the cheapest price, at the best time, and then resell at a profit. The poorer person, living hand to mouth, cannot choose when and where to buy, and has to pay higher prices.
Once the richer person has reached a certain level, he or she can became a capitalist by buying not just goods but the labour power of other people.
A week's labour produces two or three times the value of a week's wage — and the employer pockets the gain. The rich become richer on a grand scale, and the poor poorer. In modern capitalism the greatest, quickest fortunes are made not by employing productive labour, or by trading goods, but by borrowing and lending money between productive capitalists.
This "casino economy" is not an aberration, but a logical product of market capitalism.
Inequality between those who have something to sell in the market beak only their own labour poweris only half the inequality generated by the market system. Children, old people, parents or carers occupied full-time by care duties, and people unable to work because of sickness and injury, all count for nothing in the market. They are dependent on the "other" system which the free market needs as back-up - the family.
Children, women, old people, disabled people are natural losers in the free market economy. Their "dependent" status also fosters all sorts of mistreatment and injustice in the private, shut-away family circle.
All welfare satety nets in a market economy are limited by the axiom that a market must hurt in order to work. In Gore Vidal's phrase, "It is not enough that I should succeed. Someone else has to fail".
And the market's distribution of hurt and punishment is very rough justice indeed.
Ross Johnson was boss of RJRNabisco, a huge food and tobacco corporation in the US. He had little or no interest in improving production — his one new product venture was an expensive flop — and he spent millions on salaries, expenses, bonuses and flashy offices and company planes for himself and his cronies.
Financiers saw the company as ripe for a buy-out. Johnson was pushed out, and a "leaner" management was brought in. Here was the market "punishing" inefficiency as il is meant to do.
Yet Johnson didn't really get punished. He got a huge pay-off, and went off happily to start a new business. Hundreds of RJR-Nabisco workers who did their jobs well and conscientiously, and who had no share in Johnson's debauches, were punished. They lost their jobs. The story is told in a best selling book, Barbarians at the Gate.
The blind, half-random, penalisin! of inefficiency does give a market economy some dynamism and drive towards efficiency and growth. But it is very erratic.
Crises are built in to the system. At one time everyone strains the limits of their credit to buy and invest more — at another everyone holds on to their cash, and saves it for a better day. Both boom and slump, once underway, tend to snowball.
In the crisis, unsold stocks of goods, and unemployed workers capable of producing more goods, stand alongside terrible shortages and poverty. That, again, is no aber ration; it is a normal, regular product of a market economy. In a market economy, people do not meet each other as people. They meet each other as breadwinners and dependents (in the family) or as appendages of such-and-such amount of money, goods, or labour power. In the market economy, money buys everything — and the corollary is that human needs and wishes "buy" nothing (outside the family). Markets make a bleak, brutal, heartless world. They make a world in which human beings are slaves to production.
Free market economics assumes an "economic man" (homo economicus). ("Economic woman" and "economic child" are back stage...). The "economic man" can choose different foods, different clothes, different gadgets. But he cannot choose a viable environment policy; decent public transport, health or education; control over his working life; or security of livelihood.
Technology has progressed far enough for us not to have to make the choice between the cruelty of the market and the oppression of rationing. Production of the necessities of individual consumption food, clothing, housing - requires only a small proportion of the present productive resources of humanity.
Given the overthrow of capitalist rule, the democratically-planned reorganisation of production, and the shift which will follow in human nature, away from capitalist competitiveness and acquisitiveness, we can distribute such things free, with no more worry about people taking too much and wasting it than there is today at the dinner table of a halfway prosperous working class family or in a subsidised works canteen. The production and distribution of those items of individual consumption will become a routine and minor chore, and no longer a degrading competitive scramble. The bulk of our time and energy, no longer taken up by that scramble, will be given over to providing communal facilities and enjoying leisure in whatever ways we individually choose.
The day we finally whittle market forces down to nothing will be the day that the pre-history of humanit ends and our true history begins.
Scan page 5
liser
----- pull-quotes -----
WHY LABOUR-
stand for
"Given overthrow of capitalist rule, and the democratically planned reorganisation production we can distribute things free