Pro-choice, not anti-foetus
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-10-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 14
Be live in a capitalist world. Production is social; ownership of the social means of production is private.
Ownership by a state which serves those who own most of the means of production is also essentially "private"
Those who own the means of production buy the labour power of those who own nothing but their labour-power and set them to work. At work they produce more than the equivalent of their wages. The difference (today in Britain it may be more than £20,000 a year per worker) is taken by the capitalist. This is exploitation of wage-labour by capital, and it is the basic cell of capitalist society, its very heartbeat.
Everything else flows from that. The relentless drive for profit and accumulation decrees the judgment of all things in existence by their relationship of productivity and profitability.
From that come such things as the savage exploitation of Brazilian goldminers, whose life expectancy is now less than 40 years; the working to death - it is officially admitted by the government! — of its employees by advanced Japanese capitalism and also the economic neglect and virtual abandonment to ruin and starvation of "unprofitable" areas like Bangladesh and parts of Africa. Fbeht and barbarism of, Irom that comes the cultura society force-fed profitable pap.
From it come products with "built-in obsolescence" and a society orientated to the grossly wasteful production and reproduction of shoddy goods, exploitation and abuse, and prevent real democratic selfcontrol developing with the form: of what they call democracy. They use tabloid propaganda or - as in the 1984-85 miners strike - savage and illegal police violence, as they need to. They have used fascist gangs when they need to, and will use them again, if necessary.
Against this system we seek class — the wage slaves of the capitalist system - to fight Socialism means the abolition of wage slavery, the taking of the social economy out of private ownership into common cooperative ownership. It means the realisation of the old demand: for liberty, equality, and fraternity.
Under socialism the economy will be run and planned deliberately and democratically: market mechanisms will cease te be our master, and will be cut down and re-shaped to serve broadly sketched-out and planned, rational social goals.
We want public ownership of the major enterprises and a planned economy under workers The working class can win reforms within capitalism, but we can only win socialism by overthrowing capitalism and by breaking the state power → that is, the monopoly of violence and reserve violence — now held by the capitalist class. We want a democracy much fuller than the present Westminster system - a workers' democracy, with electec representatives recallable at any time, and an end to bureaucrats' and managers' privileges.
Socialism can never be built in
PLATFORM
rary Cooper's article defendMing free speech for lanti-abortionists (SO 535) was absolutely right. To treat anti-abortionists as if they are fascists, as the SWP and Socialist Outlook do, is dangerous and counter-productive.
It is also to have a very poor understanding of what motivates "pro-life" campaigners, and how they can be won away from antiabortionism. It indicates the warped thinking of some on the left when it comes to campaigning for abortion rights.
Socialists give unequivocal support to a woman's right to choose an abortion. We are in favour of a woman's right to control her body. The right to abortion follows from this. Much of the left expresses its support for abortion rights — and opposition to groups such as SPUC and Life - far more negatively.
The issue is sometimes presented as being far more about a complete disregard and contempt for the foetus than about positive support for women's autonomy.
This anti-foetus approach is perhaps best exemplified by the Revolutionary Communist Party. At Workers' Liberty '92, last July, an RCP member, contributing to session "political correctness', argued that campaigns for reproductive rights' were causing unnecessary confusion, since 'repro ductive rights' is just a more complicated way of saying 'abortio rights.
The RCPer was reminded by a Socialist Organiser supporter, Janine Booth, that reproductive rights were about more than abortion, that a woman's right to control her body goes beyond the right to choose an abortion.
Some on the left talk as though the struggle for women's rights is a vendetta against the foetus! This does nothing for women and only serves to outrage anti-abortionists and make it impossible to reason with them.
Serious socialists reject such bigotry. We should also reject the idea that the only way to relate to anti-abortionists is to 'no platform' them. Many 'pro-life' activists have good left-wing instincts. Some are ir the peace movement, or the labour movement. They are motivated by concern for human life and a belief in equality which they seek to apply to the unborn. They are, however, politically misguided into believing that what they see as the abortion problem can be solved effectively through legal restrictions and bans.
A socialist response to this should not be simply to shout "bigot!" We should welcome their concern for human life. We share it! One of the reasons we oppose the capitalist system is that it treats human dispensable commodities.
We should welcome their belief in equality, but seek to persuade them that there is no equality between women and men when women are forced to continue with pregnancies they do not want, something which men will never have to endure.
Above all, we should not say that we are "in favour of abortion". We do not rub our hands with glee when government statistics show an increase in the total number of abortions. It is not abortion per se that we support but the freest possible choice.
The way to win over anti-abortionists to a pro-choice position is to convince them that restrictions and bans lead mainly to dangerous illegal abortions rather than fewer abortions. The way to achieve fewer abortions is through social policies which help to eliminate the causes of unwanted pregnancies.
This means that the left should campaign for: higher levels of child benefit, especially for single mothers; wider availability of free contraception; publicly provided free childcare; policies to end the stigmatisation of single-parenthood and "illegitimacy.
It is with policies such as these, not with 'no platform' tactics that the left can win people away from the dangerous dead-end of 'anti-abortionism' and towards the struggle