Low morals in high places
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-10-08Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 13
Book Stan Crooke reviews Defeat From the Jaws of Victory by Mike Marqusee and Richard Heffernan (Verso, forthcoming)
Defeat From the Jaws of Victory is 1 a tale of people of no principles, no scruples and no integrity. Its characters inspire neither pity nor sympathy in the reader. They are schemers, plotters and shysters who baulk at nothing in their crazed pursuit of the trappings of power. As a work of fiction, the book is less than convincing. Its leading characters are simply too loathsome, too contemptible and too devoid of any individuality to be accepted by the reader as real people.
Far too contrived, for example, is the episode in which a politician has thousands of mugs manufactured ornamented with his face against a background of the national flag — in preparation for his election as the country's leader.
Equally unconvincing is the book's sub-plot about a bunch of gormless students who worm and wheedle their way into the nerve centre of a political party, promptly plunging the party into wrack and ruin.
Just as far-fetched is the character who poses as a media 'expert and lives in a fantasy world of make-believe political campaigns, squandering hundreds of thousands of pounds on launching these fictitious campaigns in an attempt to con the media into believing that they actually exist.
And then there is the liberal journalist — the kind of journalist you might expect to find employed by the Guardian — who writes contrived, not to say untruthful, articles for his paper in order to maliciously denigrate critics of a prominent national politician.
Sadly, however, Defeat From the Jaws of Victory is not a work of fiction. Written by Richard Heffernan and Mike Marqusee, it is the history of the Labour Party in recent years.
The book begins at the Labour Party conference in 1980, when Patricia Hewitt still advocated confrontation with the Tories, and Neil Kinnock preached class struggle. It concludes with the 1992 General Election, fought by a party whose membership figures had collapsed, whose internal democracy had been crushed, and whose politics had become virtually indistinguishable from those of the Tories.
The central figure is Kinnock himself — cowardly, bullying, devious, verbose and arrogant. Around Kinnock there are his clones and acolytes in the Labour Coordinating Committee and its youth wing in the National Organisation of Labour Students.
Along with exposing the (lack of) calibre and moral fibre of those who staffed the Kinnock machine in these years, the book also covers in detail specific incidents: the ditching of unilateralism, the Gulf War, the Party purge, the farce of the national membership scheme and the débacle of the 1992 General Election.
Despite the authors' associations with the magazine Labour Briefing (recently described by the Guardian as "the hardest of all hard-left journals" - one thing you learn from this book is never to trust the Guardian!), the book has much to commend it.
It shows the left the high cost of subordinating political clarity to attempts to curry favour with MPs. It's a lesson that Labour Briefing Ken Livingstone's one-time fan-club — learned (if it has learned it) —very late in the game. Let's hope no-one on the left makes such a mistake in their dealings with the Socialist Campaign Group of MPs and its recently established Supporters' Network.