Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

[Belinda Weaver disagree with Sigrid Fisher (Won ten's…]

Socialist Organiser no. 537, 8 October 1992 · scan pp. 12–13 · about 1,234 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

Belinda Weaver disagree with Sigrid Fisher (Won ten's Eye, SO 536) that women only sr nack I their children because of intolera ble pressure, or out of desperation. Far from it. Many women smack their children regularly. A smack on the bottom for this, a slap for that, a clip round the ear for something else — it's all part of the daily routine in many families, often the first resort, not the last.

Sigrid feels compassion for the mothers, but expresses very little for the children who've been hit. Yes, some mothers have a very rough time, but they are not powerless creatures with their children; on the contrary, they're all-powerful, and many women regularly vent their rage and frustration on their children.

Anyone who claims otherwise must have averted their eyes in supermarkets. and playgrounds and doctors' waiting rooms. They must have closed their ears to the sounds of blows and cries. Violence against children is everywhere. People may tut-tut about it wher they see some frazzled mother lashing out, or if they see battered children on the news, but for the most part mild, continuing violence against children is condoned, not condemned. Society is more likely to tut-tut if you don't smack your kids.

"Violence against children is everywhere. People may tut-tut about it when they see some frazzled mother lashing out, or if they see battered children news, but for the most part mild, continu ing violence against c hildren is condoned, not condemned."

Sigrid says tut-tutting is not what these mothers need, but we need to teach women (and men) that it's wrong to slap kids, whatever the circumstances. Children are small, defenceless.

and totally dependent on their parents.

To punish them physically simply for being children (that is, curious and determined) is terrible.

"Circumstances" are no excuse. The man who beats his wife, the racist who beats up a black person, the scab who breaks a strike, can all claim they were desperate, that circumstances drove them to it. It doesn't make their actions right.

-And hitting children is worse than any of those — because the person hit is so small and defenceless and dependent, and they have no-one to go to for comfort or support. The person who should understand comfort them — the parent — is the attacker. Children can't reason as well as adults. If you've been the victim of a racist attack, you blame your attacker. Small children blame themselves. Of course, parents get angry. I don't deny that. But getting angry doesn't mean you have to hit out. You can separate the feeling (anger) from the act (slapping). When I feel angry with my child, I either leave the room for a moment to yell, or I thump the bed, or l try to make a joke of it. It is hard not to lash out, but I never want to do it. Many people say a slap here and there doesn't hurt, or that children easily forget. That isn't true. Small children don't understand why they've been hit. Their minds and memories aren't developed enough to link what they did with the punishment they get. And why should children be less horrified than adults by a sudden slap? How would you feel if a loving partner suddenly thumped you without warning?

Children may suppress memories, but they don't forget. Many children grow up feeling bad or shamed by beatings. Why? Because if someone you love hits you, you feel fury, surprise, disappointment, resentment, outrage. At first you can't believe it. But because children love their parents and are so dependent on them, they believe (unless they are very strong, or are given other support) that they must have deserved it, that their parents must have been right to hit them.

"'Circumstances' excuse. The man beats his wife, the racist who beats up a black person can all claim they were desperate, that circumstances drove them to it. It doesn't make their actions ri And hitting children worse than of those."

If children are often hit, they soon learn to find excuses for their tormentors by blaming themselves. They grow up fearful, lacking confidence and self-esteem. They either continue to behave like victims, and get tangled up with people who abuse them, or they becom abusers themselves. their own children.

Parents who don't hit their children were either not hit themselves or have faced up to how much the beatings hurt them, and have resolved not to do it to their own kids. The ones who feel angry are the lucky ones; they can break the cycle.

If, as Sigrid says, it's wrong for teachers and nursery workers to hit kids, how can it ever be "right" for mothers? Isn't it worse if they do it? A child can get away from a teacher, but not from a parent. Parents who slap their kids usually feel they own them, that children are theirs to do with as they will. This is wrong. Children are human beings, and belong only to themselves.

Because the family is seen as private, people are reluctant to intervene when kids get slapped, just as they avoid getting between husband and wife in violent rows. Yet the attitude "They're my children, and I can do what I like with them" is terribly wrong, and can be a cover for all sorts of abuse. Children should not always be forced do what the parent wants.

As a child, I was regularly hit because I was a poor eater. I hated cauliflower, but was forced to eat it. The beatings didn't make me like cauliflower, so what were they for? To ensure my parents' will prevailed — nothing else. They showed me who was boss. But I never doubted that. And if I had, what good would it have done? There were no other parents for me, no other hom to go to. They already had absolute power over me, so why go on proving it?

Yet parents do it time Power corrupts.

Too often, parents make it hard for a child to be "good" '. They leave expensive videos or stereos near little fingers, which then get slapped for exploring. Is a curious child "naughty" for trying to find out about things, or is the parent wrong for leaving precious things in child's reach? I think the parent is wrongMany parents refuse their children any autonomy. The parent is always there correcting, interfering, controlling. When the child does something the parent disagrees with or finds inconvenient, a row or a slap follows.

If children are not doing something life-threatening or dangerous, but are merely playing safely (though not as the parent might wish), why not let them get on with it without interference?

That way parents and children would have less stress in their lives.

Removing the stress mothers face would help a lot in reducing violence against children. But it is also important to teach people that it's wrong.

If it does happen, the parent should apologise, not for getting angry (which often can't be prevented) but for taking out the anger on the child. The myth of mother love hides the violence that often forms part of the mother/child relationship. Until we face it, and defend the rights of children to live free from violence and fear, we are failing the weak and defenceless.

Scan page 13

er

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 537

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →