Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Left must fight for access to ba The Tories' edu

Socialist Organiser no. 537, 8 October 1992 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,035 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Tories want to build a new education system on the By Colin NATHE Section vate sector"

Waugh, Secretary General Education The Tory government elected in 1979 took over an education system whose progressive aspects had already been under attack for three years by their Labour predecessors. Both by measures aimed directly at that system, and through their general assault on public services, they have kept up and sharpened that attack. At the same time they have tried, more or less consistently, to build up a new sort of system within the ruins of the old. Their particular methods of attack, and the shape of that new system, reflect the relation of the leading group of Tories to different sections of their class and to others whose support they want.

The Tory party has been led for the whole period by a group which normally acts on behalf of largescale finance capital — the City, if you like — and which therefore acts sometimes against the immediate interests of other sections of their class, for example industrial employers. To win elections and more generally to mobilise 'public opinion' behind it, this group has also built a mass base, In particular amongst small capitalists in the ser"Their strategy is to use the full powers of the competition and choice to vice sector, people who've recently become self-employed, and some better-off skilled workers - that is, again, amongst groups who don't always want the same thing as big capital.

To use education policy as a weapon on behalf of finance capital, then, the leading group of Tories have had to manoeuvre between these different constituencies. They have done this by weaving their policy from three distinct strands modernisation, back to basics, and consumer choice - each of which they can push to the front when it's needed. These are sets of ideas, worked out by think-tanks, tested by Public Relations Consultants and pushed by the media; but they are also real changes imposed on the education system by Act of Parliament and/or by control of the purse strings. (We shall see that, in terms of such real changes, one strand is stronger than the others.)

irst, 'modernisation' '. Throughout the period, people speaking for UK-based industrial capital have urged the Government to make the education system turn out keener, more technically qualified workers. Sometimes it has responded, for example by setting up the Technical and Vocational Education Initiative in secondary schools and FE colleges, by launching City Technology Colleges, or by saying that information technology must be part of a common core of learning for 16-19 year olds.

But actually the Tories haven't done much about this. It's true that since 1979 teaching methods derived from industrial training (the so called 'skills ethos') have spread through the education system, and that the National Council for Vocational Qualifications (set up in 1986) may eventually be used to align the whole qualifications system (ie in schools and universities as well as Further Education with what "industry' wants. But these developments are not direct results of government policy; and in some ways that policy has gone in the opposite direction, for example, the scrapping of the Industrial Training Boards or the recent reorganisation of the Department for Education so that different ministers deal with A levels and 'vocational' qualifications.

In fact, although the Tories' rhetoric about linking education to 'the world of work' is a partly tokenistic concession to "industry', it has also been aimed at other targets altogether. First, it helped soften up "public opinion' for attacks on progressivist aspects of school curricula, by suggesting that children were being turned against going into industrial jobs. Secondly, it formed part of a broader strategy for managing the mass unemployment the Tories themselves had brought into being.

They needed to (a) camouflage the causes of unemployment; (b) help to hide the real numbers out of work; (c) reassure their supporters, especially after the 1981 riots, that unemployed people's anger was being diverted into safe channels; and (d) intimidate the unemployed themselves. The strategy they chose was to blame unemployment on a lack of skills in the workforce, due partly to the wrong sort of education, and then to build the MSC into a huge agency, accountable only to then, for forcing unemployed people into 'training' schemes such as TS and ET. It's true that in the process the MSC was empowered to intervene in education, for example when it was given control of 25% of the funding for Work Related Non Advanced Further Education. But the fact that they could wind it down when unemployment temporarily dipped In the mid-80s, and then replace it by the cash-starved system of Training and Enterprise Councils, shows that it was never part of any systematic drive to modernise 'vocational' education and training. Sia dads Here to the is a econdly, 'back to basics' or big discrepancy between what the Tories claim to be doing and what they've actually done. E time the gutter press announces progressivist teaching methods politically motivated teachers Labour councils' anti-discrimi tion policies, are depriving child of the "Three Rs" , the Torie government promise to restore ditional 'standards'; and in much of the 1986 Education was about outlawing 'political in ence in the classroom' , while Si dard Assessment Tests for se year olds, especially if linked to formance-related pay, may v "encourage' schools to drill child in basic skills.

However, it's obvious from t spending cuts that the Tories h never had the slightest intention improving basic education for mass of children, in its traditio form or any other. In fact the un lying aim of the whole moral pa about 'basics' is to latch o authoritarian elements in work class consciousness and build th up to a point where they eat i support for teachers and Lab councils, thus weakening any str gle they might try to lead agai

Scan page 9

sic skills for all cation fraud class self-education Pa mplets im AW Socialist

----- pull-quotes -----

state bureaucracy to dis- rupt and then forcibly deregulate the state sys- tem - all, of course, in th cause of initiative, "free'

while also giving still more handouts to the pri-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 537

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →