Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Frame-ups in place of arguments

Socialist Organiser no. 537, 8 October 1992 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 1,195 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Organiser is responsible for the anyone else connected with the "faked ballot papers" Labour Independent on Sunday confound when counting the votes find out what we had to say in this year's Labour Party about it.

National Executive Committee We have not rigged any balelections. lots. We have not "targetted"

David Blunkett is then quot- David Blunkett: to us he is jus "particular groups" — though obnoxious — of the ex-socialonly one group is mentioned ists on Labour's NEC.

unconstitutional and undemo- to ballot-rigging on principle.

contracting-out, and against the government with a socialist pro- startine c ampagn ia ginesi tipe mublicesecter mar -tieni weicas does, is like demanding that a pirippie the dverriment tat budgie lay duck eggs. Socialism - une iB1 acka oolurbor Pawty icpnAher itwosests parliamendary working-class self-liberation, the tepense. wd was esrongenonata majorıtyatanouh splj suor le wur abolition of wage-slavery and should call an election to restore duced by parliamentary reform, irade inimik goR cufting oma now. It is a long way off. But the is today (or ever could be without unsa engi the newiw-formyew rachng-pun abud publip-se serious left). angign Groupn Mers. mime native to fighting back is abject spoii-democrnlimi: oy Pake surenler, Tentabour movemem rustaas night-wirg unionmeadem an "unrealistic" minority boldly asıtowight phose battles and wve can allaşirikes.

toryus certain wouid bendiotic leaders are an exceptionally fee- launching the idea, the minority r victon/wsitoadml defeatin ble and crawling example of the species. John Smith chooses not want to fight and transforms them to campaign; but even he could from scattered, frustrated individAnd, probably, rousing the Labour becomes a bigger minority, and nionw endersithatitheyaise tha even on its miserable current Sometimes "radical" demands towards reviving its membership Tories out!

John O'Mahony Last week's piece by Stephen Castle, "Fake votes in Labour poll" (Independent on Sunday, 4 October 1992), defied all the rules of journalistic fair dealing.

Citing the unsubstantiated opinion of unnamed "Labour Party workers in Sheffield", that David Blunkett has been "targetted" by Socialist Organiser (Alliance for Workers' Liberty), Castle offensive:

implies that Socialist Party officials claim they losing its effect;

Led sounding off about striking — actually increased; who use "these disgraceful, to be involved in strike action.

From pagez® reezewiley arad kmdentowomten gucjass mitstepsı tell lutar 1 1990. recible emthor.

That all seems a long way off atiles om hospi tail cipsurery conipr paysarmimmedatel The oniy alteribmla lign yonvinaTo finde trat right and left - paint it.

fenreven do enyisage and jarn apivance.

The whole Tory gang should go!

The rab om atmo ve fuh s pend demand of the Labour and trade Try taNmane campangnwor it cratic methods".

No evidence is cited, except the opinion of unnamed partisans accusing their political enemies. Since charges like this tend to stick, all ideas about "innocent until proven guilty" are thus stood on their head. And all this is done — Socialist Organiser is charged. convicted, and subjected to Blunkett's pseudo-magisterial pontification in the pages of the Independent on Sunday -without us having been invited avan to affar a otainht cren w vuer a suaigue "guilty" or "not guilty" plea tr the charges! Neither Castle no tacted Socialist Organiser to one - and not the most We are completely opposed onathe L iwou ender stam mon sense. To demand "a Labour gramme", as much of the left state tyranny - cannot be intronot even by a Labour Party much more radical and militant than it a fundamental making-over by the However, even a right-wing can camppaign lagewis : il тев.

Britain's right-wing Labour De forced into direrent choices.

Party for active campaigning policies will be the first step Apart from that, the story, as Castle tells it, simply does not add up. We make socialist propaganda and help to organise the left in the trade unions and the Labour Party. Ballot-rigging to oust Blunkett and others — aside from the democratic rights and wrongs of it — could not serve our goals. We would have to be naive to think it would speed up the revival of the left, idiots not to know it might lead to scandal and hinder that revival, and fanlo to thinl mnannh hallah could be faked to unseat Blunkett, who came second in Even more absurd is the motive attributed to us. We backed the Campaign Group NEC slate, but in terms of the ideas we exist to promote we are scarcely less at odds with the Campaign Group than witl Blunkett, on Europe for instance. Yet we rig ballots to help the Campaign Group NEC slate?

When "obvious fakes" are and its policies.

hatanenms cheate hement Toresm kelLerims notuniits bese coniteniright wowa Betevennat ingic tampo tane Eleteats onita atfom - onkeeping Laboue tanyipeyowgnaywon piner §sunsh herL eeds Kopfenencer octansu Nelworkl some revival of the Labour Left. Every big campaign starts with spelling out what needs to be done and launching the idea. By gathers round it the people who uals into a force for change. It makes the idea more than just an idea. Now is the time to start. Labour must fight! Get the discovered, the question arises, and serious reporters ask it: who benefits? The answer in this case is: those in Sheffield who are attempting to expel ten alleged Socialist Organiser supporters there. Did Castle see the fake ballots?

Finally, David Blunkett's idea that Socialist Organiser rigs ballots because we can't win the argument with exsocialists like himself is as dat as the rest of the concoction. Overawed by Thatcher, Labour's leaders have, in pursuit of office, spent a decade purging and cudgelling the Labour Party into the chilled blue understudy of 1980s Toryism we saw at Blackpool. And what has happened? All the old capitalist lunacies — world slump, economic catastrophe in Britain, nightmare growth of European fascism, the re-emergence of sharp national antagonisms within Europe — start to erupt again!

Three lost elections, and now a half-dead party unfitted by its leaders to face the conditions of the 1990s! Arguments? Witch-hunts, expulsions and frame-ups are the arguments these disappointed political insolvents must rely on against their socialist critics. Stephen Castle's article was a good example of the "arguments" of David Blunkett and his friends!

Watching Kinnock, Beckett, Blunkett and others under the TV lights at Blackpool — exsocialists who betrayed their own convictions, politically gutting themselves, in pursuit of office, yet failed to win itI was reminded of an old Irish proverb: "Woe to him who does evil, and is poor after it".

oatacted-by Socialist aniser on the telechone on 6 October, David Blunkett said he had no evidence that Socialist Organiser supporters were connected with any ballot-rigging.

Scan page 5

NALGO HAIGO CONFERENCEOF THEELEFT T Conference that he Socialist meets again in Chesterfield on 17 October will be the mos important that has ever been held.

For that day socialists rganisel Europe, the end of the cold war and the emergence of a 'New World Order' run from Washington, have been used to justify the burial of all forms of socialism and of a politically activi trade-union movement.

But at the moment when capitalism has apparently achieved greatest victory, the prospects for working people are far worse

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 537

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →