Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

No cross-party on Maastricht!

Socialist Organiser no. 536, 1 October 1992 · scan p. 14 · Sean Matgamna · about 800 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

TIDE

Losing his seat on the National Executive Committee of the Labour Party, Dennis Skinner told the TV reporters that he would go on representing the left outside the NEC as he had done for twenty years inside it.

He spoke with restraint but with evidently strong emotion. In fact, Dennis Skinner personifies the crippling contradictions of the official Left - the contradictions which have wasted it down to its present sorry state.

Where raw direct working-class interests are involved, Dennis Skinner is a man of the left - a sincere, passionate, honest and incorruptible representative of working-class people in the Parliament of their exploiters and oppressors. That is what he knows himself to be, and what he wants to be. His removal from the NEC is therefore a blow for the left and a victory for the right.

But Dennis Skinner is also an opponent of the EC and, it seems, of any European unity. He has campaigned for decades, on and off, against "Brussels" and against "Europe" Skinner, who is something of a showman, presents himself in the House of Commons and to the press as a proud and unashamed Little Englander, someone who can't bear even to visit "Europe"

On this issue, Labour's best working-class left-wing leader comes across like a Daily Express blimp from the early 1950s, muttering into his tea about "foreigners".

Here too, he is sincere and passionate and incorruptible. But his politics are the opposite of working-class politics. There is nothing left-wing about them.

The John Smiths, the Gordon Browns, the Tony Blairs and the Margaret Becketts are in general not fit to polish the boots of Dennis Skinner - or of Tony Benn. But in their support for European unity they are right and the official left is wrong. They are progressive - where the ruling class is progressive - and the left is regressive and reactionary.

The only available bourgeois alternative - a divided Europe of narrowly egotistic nations and blocks of nations -is a great deal worse than the EC, and we should never forget it. It is not so long ago that wars like those we see now in ex-Yugoslavia were fought all across Europe.

Now that European unity looks a great deal less certain than it has in decades, this needs to be said again, plainly and clearly.

But Tony Benn talks about leading the left into a cross-party nationalist alliance to campaign against "Maastricht" and, in effect, against European unity! Nothing could be more calculated to poison the left and postpone its revival and recovery than this proposal. It would tie the left to the most backward part of the Tory Party, and spread chauvinism and confusion -incongruously laced with talk of socialism - inside the working-class movement.

We have been here before, back in 1975 when the Labour Prime Minister Harold Wilson held a referendum on Europe. His objective was to derail the then very powerful Left in the Labour Party and the trade unions, which was fresh and confident from a recent great victory over the Tories.

Wilson succeeded, with a vengeance! Led by Michael Foot, Tony Benn, the Communist Party, and Tribune - and followed, with wild and incoherent enthusiasm, by the politically boneless "revolutionary" left, such as Socialist Worker and the predecessors of Socialist Outlook - the left threw itself into campaigning for a no vote, in alliance with Tories and all sorts of freelance little-England nationalists.

While victory in the referendum would have gained nothing for the left or the working class, crushing defeat demoralised it, and discredited and weakened its political leaders. It was the turning of the tide for the Labour Left. Its later upsurge, in the early 1980s, took place against an unfavourable economic background, under the guns of a relentlessly attacking Tory government.

Commitment to European unity does not mean that socialists passively go along with everything the ruling class decides, for fear of lining up with the little Englanders, or that we should resign ourselves to leaving the particulars of how European unity is achieved, in the hands of an undemocratic. manipulating ruling class.

That is why Socialist Organiser has called for a referendum on Maastricht.

But not to fight for European unity in 1992 is to show yourself to have learned nothing from the history of this terrible 20th century. On this issue Benn and Skinner line up with reaction. We should not let them lead the left into another disaster like that of 1975.

The Left must say "yes" to European unity, and work to unite the labour movement across Europe so that we can one day make it a socialist Europe.

----- pull-quotes -----

"A cross-party campaign against European unity would tie the left the most backwai part of the Tory party".

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 536

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →