The left and the ERM crisis
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-10-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
posters", boasted Socialist Worker of 26 September, reporting how they responded after the pound crashed on Wednesday 16 September. If only their ability to think about politics were as good as their printing press!
The Daily Telegraph was calling for Lamont to resign. The Mail was calling him *The Devalued Chancellor". What did Socialist Worker mean? Did they want Thatcher back? Or Heseltine in? prefer the vague populist slogan, "Major and Lamont must go".
They had to spell their ideas out a little in Socialist Worker of 26 September, but only a little: "We have a right to demand Labour and union leaders stop allowing Major off the hook and fight to get rid of this government".
The gist of Socialist Worker's coverage was that the Labour and union leaders would not fight. Socialist Worker would argue for socialism, support workers in European, not just a British, As ever, Socialist Worker was limited to the old "minimax" approach - calls to resist the bosses now, calls for socialism in the future, and no "transitional demands" which make a bridge from immediate resistance towards generalised socialist class struggle.
Militant had much the same "mini-max" approach, though it was bolder - "Tories' Crisis: "European capitalism in recession... will never achieve the international cooperation needed to reach the goals of Maastricht". This shows that "real, lasting European integration" cannot be achieved under capitalism, but only "in a socialist united states of Europe".
And so... Militant would side with the Thatcherites and the other capitalist "Euro-sceptics", and try to stall or reverse the limited bringing-down of frontiers could not even summon up enough vigour to call for kicking the Tories out - and it told its readers that the wreck of the Maastricht Treaty would ease the pressures on the working class.
Bryan Gould, it also said, *now has the same position on (Maastricht] as Tony Benn, Dennis Skinner, and Socialist Outlook'. Or, to put it another way round, Outlook has the same line on Europe as Labour's little-Englanders, old slogan "Britain out of the EC!"
They campaigned for "Britain Out!" through most of the 1970s and the early 1980s. Why not now? If the slogan is wrong now, when did it become wrong, and why wasn't it wrong in the 1970s?In fact the socialist slogan should always have been: "In or out, the fight goes on", or "No to the bosses' Europe, no to bosses' Britain, yes to European workers' unity!"
Scan page 13
n the iunior leaque Thirty years ago the world ous US attempts to topple on the point of breaking out. Cuban exiles. "Eyeball to attack Russian ships sailing when US president Kennedy "The Cuban Missile Crisis" Russian nuclear missiles (a special two-part edition of from Cuba.
Im is ladonna and C : the Belinda V leaver reviews A League of their own league of their own"
A is a film with a very soft centre. It's funny and appealing and it tugs the heartstrings in places, but it's amorphous. It doesn't say anything clearly. It doesn't shout its intentions; it whispers them from behind a hand.
Though it's about women in sport, stridently feminist it's not.
In the 1940s, with America in the war, the professional baseball leagues were short of players. Like industry, they filled the gaps with women, and professional American women's baseball had arrived.
There were good players around, but the league managers didn't want toughies. They wanted ladies, and pretty ones at that, to draw the Periscope went through an unforgettable week during which nuclear war seemed to be The US placed an embargo on Cuba and threatened to towards the island. crowds. With teams called the Peaches and the Belles, "allgirl" baseball had a hard time getting taken seriously.
"A league of their own" shows all this, but doesn't take a stand on it. Whenever it seems about to make a point (for instance, what the players felt about the silly uniforms and the girly poses; the fact that black "Though it's meant to largely about women playing a sport and gaini confidence, it doesn't sho much of the love of the game for itself, about the joy of excelling, of the physical challenge. All th joy seems to come from winning."
women were excluded), The film is made by a woman, BBC2's "Timewatch) will tell the story. "Defying Uncle Sam" (Wednesday 7 October) traces the numerCastro ranging from assassination attempts to a sponsored invasion by eyeball" (14 October) tells the story of the showdown, forced USSR boss Nikita Khrushchev to remove Penny Marshall, but she doesn't seem to know any more about women than her male director peers. The point of view isn't specifically female.
Though it's meant to be largely about women playing a sport and gaining confidence, finding themselves through their success, it doesn't show much of the love ol the game for itsell, about the joy of excelling, of the physical challenge. All the joy seems to come from winning.
This is a flaw, because the central character, Dottie, who's meant to be the star player of the team, is never established as best, and we don't really know how she feels about the game. She's meant to be torn between playing and being a wife to her soldier husband, but she isn't torn, or she doesn't appear to be. Marshall constantly lets things slip. If the other characters didn't tell us how much Dottie loves to play, would we even know?
The film is also poor on the history. At first the league games were ridiculed, and attendances were low. But with shrewd promotion, audiences picked up, and the games were a success, drawing crowds of 6,000 or more.
Marshall puts it all down to promotion, to advertising, not to the skill of the players themselves. Did it only succeed because it was advertised? Or did a reluctant public finally concede that these "girls" could play ball?
Some of the scenes have mould on them. In one, the drunken coach, Dugan, himself an ex-star, berates Dottie for leaving the team. The scene has appeared in about ten other movies I can think of, and underlines Marshall's conventional handling of the material. It's as if she thinks in cliches, or can only see conflicts the way other films have treated them.
When she can't think of what else to do, she throws in a laugh, piles on the sentiment, or hypes up the audience by having them root for the Peaches to win a game. The whole thing is cast in a winning/losing mold.
The conflict between the paragon, Dottie, and her kid sister, Kit, who's always lived in her shadow, is no exception. To find herself, Kit has to beat Dottie.
The film could have been more punchy. The baseball women came from farms and small towns and were suddenly thrust into the national limelight. Once the boys came marching home, they didn't want to take their bats and balls and head home; they wanted to keep playing. There must have been pressure about doing a man's job, about becoming "unwomanly"
But Marshall glides over that. No-one in the movie has any serious adjustment problems because Marshall never lets them take a stand. She blands out the characters so that they can do what she wants, so that she can make the story her way. That would be fine if she had a vision. She doesn't. She probably wanted to tell a story about women learning that they're as good as men, but then she edged away from it, and made this mish-mash instead It's not terrible. At times, it's a lot of fun, but in a league of its own, it's not.
Her n the whole, "Black and Blue" ("Screenplay"
BBCI) was quite progressive, as it tackled the issue of racism within the police force. But it did not go far enough, nor did it offer any solution. And once again all the black characters either took drugs, were thieves, or were "community figures".
The "hero". , the black undercover copper from Devon, is sent into a black neighbourhood to find out who killed the local community leader, but uncovers police corruption. While doing this he is harassed and abused by his "fellow officers".
The play steamrollered through institutionalised knows it. It needs to be tackled seriously." racism, corruption, riots and murders (there was a lot to take in!) What irritated me about it was that it offered no solution apart from the advice to "lodge a complaint" and to learn to ride the system.
Riding the system won't change anything as long as the police are controlled by the state and continue to do their dirty work.
Racism is rife in the police force, and everyone knows it. It needs to be tackled seriously.
The only way we can eradicate racism is to smash the system, united for socialism. The police do the state's dirty vork. This includes terrorising he black community
Scan page 14
Jrganise
----- pull-quotes -----
an to racis Television
"Racism is rife in the police force, and everyone