Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Keep the Link!

Socialist Organiser no. 536, 1 October 1992 · scan pp. 11–12 · about 543 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

"just can't be done". Ted the block vote system on strong hen as now, most union leaders defendtraditional grounds. It was an expression of the party's genesis as a trade union party. It was commensurate with the unions' financial contributions and it was an expression of trade union solidarity in line with their industrial practice.

For the politicians the argument had a much more partisan character. Whilst the left, so often in a minority, openly explored the iniquities of the arrangement, the right tended to view its use in terms of realpolitik... not perhaps the ideal way of deciding party policy... a bit anachronistic when viewed from the perspective of a modern social democrat... but nevertheless it preserved stability and continuity.. it helped keep the annual conference in harmony with the parlamentary leaders and it kept at bay those forces which Sydney Webb immortalised as *unrepresentative groups of non-entities dominated by fanatics and cranks and extremists".

This comfortable perspective was suddenly shattered in 1959 when Frank Cousins encouraged his union to oppose Hugh Gaitskell's policy on nuclear weapons and Cousins of the TGWU leadership of several unions; this was reinforced by the pattern of union growth, amalgamation and contraction.

By 1969, the old rightwing block vote had been shattered. Though in some important unions, notably the engineers, there has been a further change of leadership, the stable base of support for the parliamentary leadership has never been recreated.

A second less obvious development has been the changing pattern of power within is no doubt that institutionally the crisis in the party has been a crisis of the block vote. H foresee. It is doubtful whether the ow this will now develop is difficult to domineering and closely integrated block vote of the post-war years could be resurrected. It was a product of peculiar cold war circumstances and a set of attitudes towards authority which are fast being eroded. It absence may dismay those nurtured within its security, but for most of the party it is a liberating experience which opens up the possibility that the movement's rhetoric and its practices will move more into line.

Since the mid 1950s there has been a major change in the concentration of the votes at the conference. In the first place, there has been a transformation in the relative voting weight of the sections. In 1953 when the constituency parties' vote was at its peak of 1,307,000 it was 472,000 votes larger than any one single union.

Today as a result of the disastrous decline of membership in the late 1960s and the recent rise in union affiliation the constituency vote at 689,000 is not much more than half that of the Transport and General Workers alone.

Another disparity is likely to continue to increase in the next decade. Amalgamations A campaign has been launched in the Labour Party and trade unions to defend the unions' right to a say in the Labour Party.

Contact: KTL, 120 Northcote Rd, London E17, or phone Bob on 081-520 5386 or Tom on 071-277 7217

Scan page 12

Orgi

----- pull-quotes -----

wing saw the block vote as not ideal, but preserving stability and continuity. But when Fra

opposed Hugh Gaitskell, overnight he became the bully of the block vote!"

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 536

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →