[pushed through a rule change which in effect…]
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-10-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
pushed through a rule change which in effect gave them complete control over the composition of the Executive.
Under the constitution of 1918, all seats on the committee, including those allotted to the new divisional ("constituency") Labour parties based on individual membership, were to be voted for by the whole conference and not by individual sections. And conference was markedly more trade union dominated as a result of the affiliation of larger unions and the growth of trade unionism. In January 1918 the socialist societies cast 48,000 votes, the divisional parties 115,000 and the unions 2,471,000. Union affiliation remained high until after the 1926 General Strike, whilst the divisional parties were relatively slow to expand At the drafting stage of the new constitution, in the conferences of 1918 and at the various conferences of the early 1920s, attempts were made to loosen the trade union grip and to undermine what was seen by some as the tyranny of the block vote'. They were all easily defeated A new situation emerged in the 1930s as filiation languished at a much lower
Scan page 11
Bill Morris him and the conference arrangements committee and it was implemented at the 1953 conference even though by this stage both the executive and the conference had rejected the presence of the cameras! It was not until 1955 that they were finally admitted.
This change in procedure had several consequences. It speeded up the process and made it more accurate. It also (once only one ballot box was in use) made it more difficult for delegates to see how their colleagues were voting. And it made it more difficult on grounds of practicality and expense for a union to claim a separate vote for each of its delegates.
Today, where once there was one card to each voting union eighty are used (40 for and 40 against). And where once it was accepted custom at head office that each union had the right to claim what cards it needed, it has now become conventional wisdom that splitting a delegation's vote between individuals John Edmonds public ownership. Overnight the general secretary of the Transport and General Workers' Union became "the bully with the block vote, and in the next two years a variety of proposals emerged from the right designed to neutralise or circumvent the manual worker unions' dominance over the conference.
On the left there continued to be objections to the block vote but now they gave a much reduced priority to reform. It was a tendency which, with some notable exceptions was to become even more marked in the 1970s.
The Wilson government embarked on a range of economic, industrial and foreign policies which not only alienated many constituency members, it stimulated a powerful reaction within the unions. There was a significant shift to the left in the policy and "In the 1950s the right the affiliated unions. It is common for one senior official (usually the general secretary) to play a key role in policy making. But this personal power of the boss can easily be exaggerated both by intra-union critics and by a mass media always prone to personalise issues and discover ogres in the labour movement. In even the most centralised unions, the most skillful and prestigious general secretary operates within a range of institutional and cultural constraints.
Since 1966 there have been defeats for the parliamentary leadership at the conference on a scale which has no parallel in party history. And the powerful campaign for constitutional reform has been a factor shaping the choice of leader and encouraging the departure of the Social Democrats.
If we are to seek root causes they can be found in the attitudes and policies of the parliamentary leadership in the 1960s, but there
Organiser
have reduced the number of unions represented at the conference from 88 in 1955 to 52 in 1980. Eight unions between them now cast 4,561,000 out of 6,450,000 union votes.
Contraction of union membership will reduce the affiliation of some unions but it is likely also to give added impetus to amalgamations which concentrate membership in a decreasing number of unions. Thus the practice of unions casting their votes as units which do not register minority votes is likely to look more incongruous and bring the practice itself increasingly into question.
This practice has a long history but as I have indicated it is not as long as is often supposed. it appears natural to trade unionism, but its inception at the TUC was a political manoeuvre which aroused considerable hostility for many trade unions. It has been the common practice but not as all-pervasive as is often thought. And if the traditions of distributing votes within a delegation died out in the 1950s, this had as much to do with the party as with the unions.
In future elections for leadership and deputy leaderships there is a pressing case for minorities to be registered. It is not the process where the trade union preponderance is at its greatest but it is the one which has the most public impact and the least industrial consequences. The media now give us the votes of particular candidates at union conferences; there is no evidence that this information harms the industrial solidarity of the unions concerned Apart from factional self-interest all previous attempts at block vote reform have been destroyed on the rocks of union autonomy. For this reason it is essential that any initiative for change comes from trade unionists, that each union interprets for itself its obligation to consult its membership, and that a system of split voting allows each union the flexibility to specify which decision-making forum will register its split votes.
What the party can do is what it did in 1953. It can change the system of card voting or at least in the case of electing the leadership specify how that procedure might evolve with union agreement. There is nothing to prevent the party suggesting a future ballot paper which not only specifies a total unit vote for checking purposes but gives a facility for organisations (constituency parties as well as unions) to write in the division of their votes.
I am aware that there are more comprehensive and neater solution to the whole problem of the block vote. But in this area we have to work with the grain of the movement's traditions. The Labour Party is always likely to appear an untidy and peculiar patchwork of individual and collective representation and of disparate governmental processes within a confederal structure. To wish it were otherwise is also to regret a labour history of unparalleled institutional creativeness.