The case for defending and democratising the block vote
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-10-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
The noted labour historian Lewis Minkin is a key member of Labour's Working Party on the relationship between the unions the party. This article by Minkin, abridged from 'New Socialist" magazine, September-October 1981, explains the history of the block vote; shows how the right-wing outcry against it is more sour grapes than a push for democracy; and suggests one possible way of making the block vote more flexible and democratic. We do not know if Minkin still supports the views presented here.
The "block vote" was not an organic growth within the TUC; up to 1890 the affiliated trades societies and trades councils voted by show of hands - one person one vote.
This arrangement involved various anomalies and caused resentment amongst some of the largest unions who felt that their membership should automatically entitle them to greater voting rights. Existing trade union practice gave them precedents for instituting a mechanism which ensured votes according to membership and entitled each union to display organisational unity.
But the thrust of reform also had a sharp political edge. Socialists, predominantly from the Independent Labour Party and working mainly in the New Unions, were pushing the TUC towards an independent political representation of Labour in the House of Commons. The Lib-Labs, who were particularly strong in the older and larger unions, sought means to hold them back.
Following the Congress of 1894, there came what Beatrice Webb at the time described as a coup d'etat. Without the prior approval of congress, except for an innocuous procedural resolution, the parliamentary committee (forerunner of the General Council) suddenly initiated three major changes in the TUC standing orders - each of which involved a set back for the socialists.
Under the new standing order no.8 delegates to the congress voted by cards on which the voting weight was equivalent to the number of members affiliated.
Thus the mechanism which the Labour Party was to inherit was instituted as part of an attempt by Liberals and anti-socialists to r1 abort the infant party.
These procedural changes could not stop the spread of collectivist and socialist ideas nor, given the actions of the judiciary, did it halt the move towards independent representation.
The Labour Representation Committee, which became the Labour Party, was set up after a resolution of the 1899 congress and the new party had an overwhelming majority of trade unionists as its affiliated membership. Consequently, it took over many existing trade union procedures as it evolved a constitution and standing orders the first being:
"Voting shall be by a show of hands but on a division being challenged delegates shall vote by cards which shall be issued on the basis of one card, for each thousand or fraction of a thousand, paid for to the Committee by the Society represented."
This was, and still is, compatible with an affiliated organisation splitting its votes. But in practice the unions (or most of them) cast their votes as blocks. Acceptance of these arrangements was eased by the fact that as some of the largest unions tended to stay aloof from the party there were no huge disparities in the votes or organisations. In 1900, out of 568,000 members represented, only five unions had more than 20,000; even the socialist societies of the ILP and the Social Democratic Federation could cast "mini' block votes of 13,000 and 9,000 each. Also, the arangements for elections to the executive were remarkably favourable to the socialist societies. At the first conference they took five of the twelve seats on the committee - plus the party secretary.
However, in 1917 a majority of the unions Mappouvu more flexible than of election and an trade unionists as its figure whilst the divisional parties grew in membership. The Home Counties Labour Association and the Constituency Parties Movement sought primarily to secure an independent and increased representation of local parties on the executive. Union resistance stimulated reformers to seek a wide range of other objectives. There was an attempt to secure a national meeting of the divisional parties - in some eyes a move to counter the union block vote with a divisional parties' block vote. And there was a wave of proposals designed to deal directly with the union block vote.
In the agendas of the conference of the late 1930s were resolutions that:
all delegates should have one vote; all organisations should have one vote; all votes should be hand votes unless a majority of not less than one third demanded a card vote; trade union representation should be confined to local affiliation; the votes of the constituency organisations should be expanded; the vote of individual unions should be split proportionate to members views. s it hannened the nninne nr to umous proveu to De was though; a new method the cy parties was agreed in 1937. But on the issue of the block vote the reformers got nowhere; not one of the proposals was navigated through the agenda controls. Nevertheless a range of options had been defined several of which were to re-emerge when antagonism again developed between union leaders, backbench MPs and constituency activists, A towards the Attlee government for its fter 1948 gratitude and loyalty felt social and industrial achievements, plus a fervent anti-communism, led leading figures on the General Council to organise their Labour Party activities to a much greater extent than previously. The organisation was based on meetings between leaders of the three largest unions, Arthur Deakin of the Transport and General Workers, Will Lawther of the Mineworkers and Tom Williamson of the General and Municipal Workers.
Their strength lay not only in the support they could elicit within their own unions but also amongst a wide range of smaller bodies.
And, much more than the left was prepared to acknowledge, they had support also within the constituency organisations. Political divisions ran through all sections of the party.
The overall strength of the right - an aggressively self-confident right - was the dominant feature at the conference. And it was reflected in a cross union alignment which outlived the union leaders who crated it.
The clearest sign of their effectiveness was that after 1948, with the exception of a minor vote in 1950, not one defeat was suffered by the platform at conference until 1960!
-The executive was overwhelmingly dominated by supporters of the parliamentary leadership - a position achieved mainly through trade union votes.
The block vote of those days was extremely intolerant and could be very harsh indeed when operating in tandem with leading members of the Parliamentary Party, one of whom was usually the chairman of the organisation sub-committee. For example, 1953 saw an official attempt by the General Council to stifle criticism of union leaders by Tribune, then. edited by Michael Foot. In the same year Mrs Eirene White, a 'moderate' member of the executive by anyone's definition, declined to stand for re-election because of the pressures which had been put on her by union leaders to toe the line.
Any MP who voted in parliament contrary to the decision of the Parliamentary Party risked expulsion from the party; controls over constituency party activities were tight.
It was in this context, with the block vote strikingly dominant and under severe criticism, that a change was instituted in the voting procedure at Conference. To appreciate the significance of the change it is important to note two little known points.
First, procedure for card voting at the Labour Party Conference was up to 1953, exactly the same as that still in use at the TUC. A union was normally issued with only one card; in a card vote union leaders showed the card to the tellers after the chairman had called out first 'for' then 'against". The vote was therefore public and fellow delegates could usually see which way a union was voting.
Second, though it was common practice for a union to cast its votes as a unit, there was a party facility for unions to have cards sufficient for them to split their votes and up to the early 1950s some of them did so.
The extent of this practice of split voting is difficult to unearth as there are no available party records. But it appears that the federal unions - the Mineworkers and the textile workers - occasionally did so.
More significantly, one of the oldest craft unions regularly split its vote.
The Amalgamated Society of Woodworkers claimed a card or each of its seven-man delegation who apparently voted in line with union regional opinion.
However, by 1953 a change in procedure initiated by the party made the facility much more difficult. That summer the BBC approached both major parties with a request to telerecord their conferences for the first time.
Morgan Phillips, the party secretary, was unhappy at the possibility that there might be 'embarrassments' if union leaders casting large votes appeared on the screen and he recommended the adoption of a system of ballot boxes, to make voting more discreet. The executive agreed to leave the change
----- pull-quotes -----
"The Labour Representation
increase for the constituen- Committee, which became the Labour Party, was set up after a resolution of
1899 congress and the new party had an overwhelming majority affiliated membership.