Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Why mothers get desperate

Socialist Organiser no. 536, 1 October 1992 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 619 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Some friends of mine have just started teacher training courses, and, as part of their introduction week, had a session on discipline. They were told that smacking was no longer an acceptable form of punishment, and that recent legislation in Scotland has brought parents into line with professionals such as teachers, childminders, etc, making smacking illegal.

The arguments against smacking are clear and indisputable: displays of violence by someone in a position of trust and power over a vulnerable minor are abuse, and can only teach children that aggression is condoned in adult behaviour as a way to succeed in confrontational situations. But what all the debate and propaganda against smacking fails to address is the circumstances of the "smacker"

While there are some parents/carers who believe in the old-fashioned doctrine of physical punishment as the best way to teach a child a lesson, most cases of smacking or other similar acts are an expression of desperation.

In a society that places (predominantly) women in the isolated and devalued position of sole carer for their child/ren, a prolonged and continuous bout of having practical and emotional demands made upon them can drive many women to behave in a way that is completely out of character and against everything they believe in and want to be.

The image of the always capable, loving, patient, educating and entertaining mother in her clean and tidy house with the dinner in the oven comes into stark contrast with the reality of most women's lives. Faced with the day-in, day-out tasks that are part of getting you and your child through the day in a constructive manner, you sometimes look around and see only failure in everything you try to do. The job of full-time carer calls for superhuman levels of sacrifice, compromise and understanding, impossible to sustain when dealing with poverty and lack of support and recognition in society. The most visible cause of this daily stress and struggle can easily, though wrongly, be seen to be the child screaming and clinging onto your leg. The hand can fly out against this child before you even realise what is happening.

The answer is not to increase the pressures on "What all the debate and to address is the circumstances of the 'smacker"."

women in this situation by providing a loud and clear 'tut' from society, but to give those women freedom from the trap of poverty, and to make available opportunities for women and children to have time for themselves away from each other. But we see no increase in benefit levels, and cuts in nursery provision. And to cap it all, this week in my area, is enrolment week for adult education courses where those at home and out of work can pursue interests and learn new skills. None of these courses have childeare provision. If you want a morning or afternoon off to study or engage in an alternative activity, you have to find someone to look after your child/ren yourself. Or pay the full amount for the childcare worker - something completely impossible on benefits or low income.

So, it's back to the home where you and your child get bored, frustrated and resentful. Your child only has you to take these feelings out on - where do you turn? Against your child? It is the capitalist system that imprisons women within their own four walls, with nowhere to turn and no escape. It is the capitalist system that deserves to get the full force of these women's anger at their situation. It is the capitalist system that should be imprisoned, beaten and buried once and for all.

Scan page 7

er

----- pull-quotes -----

WOMEN'S EYE

propaganda against "smacking" fails

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 536

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →