Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Living nightmare

Socialist Organiser no. 535, 23 September 1992 · scan p. 14 · about 988 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 14 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 14

Serbian soldier surveys burning Bosnian village Slobodan Milosevic not one too? cleansing" is a maior aim of the scientist condemned Itional scientific views and who died in prison as a result? When and where did this happen? The Middle Ages, in some country ruled by the Inquisition? No! It happened in the "socialist paradise" that was Stalin's In 1930, Professor Nikolai Vavilov, the Soviet Union's foremost geneticist, became known to Western scientists when he presented a paper to the Second International Congress on the History of Science and Technology in London. This paper concerned the origins of world agriculture and, in particular, the discoveries of researchers from his institute, the Institute of Plant Industry in Leningrad.

Since the Soviet Union was a largely agricultural country and was recovering from civil war and trying to modernise, it was important to obtain new genetic stock agricultural practices result in the dying out of many of these varieties in their native habitats.

In 1930, Vavilov was the most important scientist in the Soviet Union, disposing of a colossal research budget. By the mid-1930s, the IPI had one of the richest seed banks in the world. All this was put in jeopardy by the triumph of a theory of genetics that owed more to the pre-Darwinian ideas of Lamarck.

Lamarck thought that the characteristics acquired by an organism during its life could be passed on to its offspring. This is like believing that if you developed huge muscles through weightlifting, your offspring would have huge muscles. Perhaps unfortunately, there is no way this can happen.

In the frenzied atmosphere of the Five Year Plans, it was easy for someone who promised big jumps in crop yields to come to the fore. Trofim Lysenko, an agronomist, argued that the painstaking work of the conventional geneticists, breeding fruitflies and doing statistical studies and selectwas accosted by a young woman on Charing Cross Road. Lots of eye contact.

"Excuse me sir". Sir? Me? Surely some error?

Looked over my shoulder, fully expecting to have made a mistake. The woman from the market research company mus be after some debonair chap. walking just behind me. But there's no one there...

No! She's talking to me!

Lots more eye contact. God, she's so sincere!

"Sir, have you seen this maga zine? Must be some motoring mag.

Aggh! No! It's Living Marxism! "Sir"? Out now! Believe me it's imbecilic! Yes, so off the wall, you need this magazine!

From the people who backed the scab Notts miners during the Great Miners' Strike of 1984-5.-. from the people who told you the labour movement is dead (despite the fact, that you know there are eight million trade unionists)... from the people who said Labourism is dead (despite the fact that you know Labour has 270 MPs)... from the people who laugh at bucket collections for strikers (despite the fact that you know a normal socialist wants strikers to win)... the RCH brings you... their Balkan line!

If you thought "Sink the Falklands Fleet" was calculated to wind up workers rather than stop the war.. if you thought campaigning to smash up the National Union of Students was something best left to the Tories... you will not be surprised at the RCP's ideas on the Balkans war — the main issue is western imperialism. Don't worry about "ethnic cleansing"! it's a Croatian invention.

Serbian imperialism? It does not exist!

Well, look, if the mining of Nicaraguan ports and aid to the Contras is US imperialism, why is Belgrade's military and political aid to the Bosnian Serbs and the occupation of Kosovo not Serbian imperialism?

"Kosovo? Uh? Vojvodina?' Where?" The Living Marxism seller did not know where they were, and did not care much either. Instead, the subject is changed: do I really believe wha I read in the press?

It was like listening to an old Stalinist — "Hungary '56? They were all fascists. You don't believe what you read in the press, do you comrade?" Well, yes, as a matter of fact I do believe the press, sometimes. do believe:

a. Kosovo exists;

b. it is largely Albanian, Quaintly, I also believe in the bourgeois democratic right of self-determination for such a people. Do the RCP believe tha Kosovo has the right not to be trodden on by a chauvinist pig like Milosevic? "Comrade, this is not the issue!" Yes, I know John Major is a war criminal - but why is Turning to the magazine. The war, it seems, really started because Germany recognised Croatia. The idea that this was the main factor in starting the war is bizarre. It takes responsibility away from the Serbian leadership for their nationalist drive from 1987-8Then follows a foul article co ering for the Serbian nationalists. Apparently the term "ethnic cleansing" was шусши vy we crauau gov- invantad hu tha Constion am ernment. Does "ethnic cleansing" not accurately describe what is happening no Does it not describe what the Serb chauvinists are doing?

No, says the article - these just population movements caused by war. Well, indeed! Without meaning to, the point conceded — because "ethnic war. The war was initiated by a Serbian government fighting for a Greater Serbia. That is, to clear the non-Serbs off conquered territory.

And what about Vojvodina in the north, away from Bosnia? There the "ethnic cleansing" goes on in a one-sided cold war of threats and intimidation against ethnic Hungarians.

Yes, the Croatians have a ble government, their own vamps anu tou own poucy or somas and thair num nolin af grabbing a chunk of Bosnia. But the context of the Croats nationalist government is the drive from Belgrade.

To muddy the waters, to fail to pinpoint responsibility, to cover for Milosevic, is to be truly idiotic. To do all this with Vatican City style pomp and pretentiousness - - that is to be truly RCP.

----- pull-quotes -----

IDIDITIWATCH By Mark Osborn

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 535

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →