Socialist Organiser

Socialist Organiser, 1987 to 1992: the second part of the Socialist Organiser archive

Breaking the cycle

Socialist Organiser no. 535, 23 September 1992 · scan pp. 13–14 · about 970 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 13 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 13

poor and deprived life on one of ing tancy cars, wielding power by the dismal housing projects in guns and terror. It's a dangerous Brooklyn, has some of the same- life, probably short-lived, but Now when the shouting and strife are ended And each man's voice upon the darkness dies, Remember you have toiled for something splendid And keep the vision stainless in your eyes:

Be faithful to yourselves and those you fought for -Great hearts and generous hopes and patient hands: Swear that you'll never lose the ends you've sought for Till Brotherhood unites the martyred lamb.

Ithat ismoblerandışfrongıs cankedl besidennol nd volare crew/nedemith vicipry thpugnn ou ral Belinda Weaver reviews Straight out of Brooklyn A short film called "The few years ago, there was a death of the rat" . In it, a man beats his wife because his boss at work had given him a hard time. The wife, unable to strike back, beats their child, who in turn hits out at their dog. The dog chases a cat, and so the rat, the last in a long line of abuse, comes to a sticky end. "Straight out of Brooklyn" story of a black family living a hopelessness. Ray, the beatendown, alcoholic father, takes out his frustrations and hurt on his wife in nightly scenes of violence. Denis, their teenage son, wishes he had the courage to stop his father abusing his mother.

But all Denis has is dreams, dreams and schemes that have nothing to do with reality.

Denis and his friends, Kevin and Larry, have nothing to hope for; there's nothing for them, and thousands like them, but dead-end jobs or crime. Of the two, crime has the bigger appeal - the rewards are instant; there's no waiting.

They see drug-dealers on the streets, awash with money, drivcompared to it seems like the top.

pumping gas life, an elevator : to "Straight out of Brooklyn' succeeds brilliantly in showing society where the women hold families together, where girls become adults too soo and where boys grow up."

"Straight out of Brooklyn" is the first film of 19 year old Matty Rich, and it feels real. Rich, who grew up in the Brooklyn projects, acre upon acre of soulless tower blocks where the streets aren't safe, and the sound of gunfire is heard at night, has no answers for what he shows, but he knows how to show the problems.

Ray is a fearful figure, full of power and menace. When he's inside the small, seedy apartment, he's like a powder keg. Everyone tiptoes around him, hoping, praying for peace. Frankie, his battered wife, is defeated but watchful, always trying to head off trouble. You see her trying constantly to squeeze herself into a smaller space.

Anyone who has ever lived with domestic tyrant will identify with the tension of the family's life, the knotted stomachs at mealtime, the constant fear of explosion.

It's like the world outside, where hope is not an option. Only dreams, fantasies keep you going.

Denis had planned to get out, to go to college, to break the cycle of despair. But four, five years seems too long to him; he wants instant riches, instant relief, and makes a disastrous choice.

There are a few awkward moments in the movie, scenes that feel preachy or contrived, but for the most part "Straight out of Brooklyn" succeeds brilliantly in showing a society where the women hold families together, where girls become adults too soon, and where boys never grow up, never have to take responsibility. For many of the older men like Ray, drink is the only escape from a world that trashes them. It shows how much rage there is in people who have been kept down, and who've watched their children's dreams go down the drain. That rage, if properly channelled, could change the world. -But too often, it turns inward, into beatings and abuse, into drinking and self-hatred.

At the end, Matty Rich shows he knows how cycles of despair continue. "We need to change, he says. He's right. "Straight out of Brooklyn* shows how urgent that need is.

As an allegory for, or analysis of th society Eastwood sees around him -divided into frustrated, embittered, mutually hostile and destructive camps, apparently without any common ground or ability to see each others' points of view let alone bend or compromise Unforgiven certainly has its weaknesses. As a parable or warning about what happens when any ethical or civilised considerations give way to pure entrenched self-inter est or revanchist attitudes it function: I think, literally or not, as a warning against the dangers of authoritarianism and fascism.

In his own way I think that Eastwood is trying to say that in a world of absolutes, a world where people cannot, or refuse to bend or compromise or to accept that they have any common values or interests, the danger remains that the only way of reconciling the irreconcilable is by means of authoritarianism, force and violence. Lurking behind the plot of Unforgiven is as fine a portrayal of the components of the fascist mentality as you are likely to get, with sketches of the cult of violence, the revenge motive and revenge or malevolence masquerading as law and order or justice traced out, at least in a commercial film. Although, to be fair, despite its surprise box office success, this is really a film of a remarkably uncommercial nature, despite great performances from Gene Hackman and Richard Harris in a curious cameo.

This is a complex film, one that for once certainly can't be adequately dealt with in a short review, but I must say: it's really worth watchingClint E: a moral

Scan page 14

Socialist Organiser No. 535 page 14 "Proletarian" versus "bourgeois

----- pull-quotes -----

Those-who fight_for-labour by-Shegfried- Sassioon

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 535

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →