Anti-abortionists are not fascists!
Socialist Organiser1992 1992-09-23Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
To "no-platform" anti-abortionists is dangerous and wrong. Logically, it could be applied to a huge part of the Irish Republic G the ILP was a semi- time there was no room for an raffiti's allegation that that in the conditions of the Stalinist sect is totally independent class position. unfair. But their accommodation was There was certainly, during certainly no worse than that the Stalinist Third Period, in of Healy or Pablo. the early and mid '30s, a Until such time as your facStalinist faction within the tion has repudiated that part London federation of the ILP. of the past of orthodox (as On almost all issues the party well as revisionist) leadership sided with Trotskyism, it would ill The Stalinist faction left the Moreover, unlike the Fourth ILP to join the CP. They did International, the ILP in the this as the Stalinist line mid-'50s was led by people * mgad to the Popular Front, who insisted on proclaiming a policy very different from the aims of world revolution, those they had been barking. and arguing that socialists and so some members left the must oppese both camps in CP Immediately. A few drifted the Cold War. back to the ILP, but as many The ascusation "semijoined the Denzil Harber Stalinist*, for a group which It is true, certainly, that in of the evils of Stalinisme than the post-war years the ILP you did yasekes land which shrank: can you name a single maintained close links with leftist group (with the possi- those you would consider ble exception of the SPGB ultra-left: Mme Trotsky, that didn't? The whole of the Damen, Bordiga, Pannekoek, Left went through a period of CLR James, and Raya decline from 1948 to 1958, just Dunayevskaya) is absurd and Trotskyist members of the Editor's note: Yes, the ILP. accommodated to charge is absurd. I apologise Stalinism at the depth of the to readers for letting it slip Annual Conference agreed, by a substantial majority, to re-affiliate to the National Abortion Campaign.
The annual attempts to disaffili ate from NAC and the continued campaign to deny women the right to choose were again clearly rejected by Conference.
Unfortunate, and not quite welcome, was the successful attempt by women from the National Women's Committee and various left groups including the SWP and Socialist Outlook to "No Platform" the anti-abortionists.
A few, it has to be said, rather feeble and hopeless looking old men were giving out leaflets one morning as Conference began.
These advertised a lunchtime meeting, ostensibly on a drug used in the Third World, in reality an anti-abortion meeting.
The National Women's Whilst fully supporting your "Workers Charter" (SO 533) and accepting that the labour movement should be demanding a legal "right to organise" believe that its demands are incomplete in failing to raise the issue of workplace meetings in working time.
Many, if not the majority of, rank and file trade unionists, have other commitments which make it difficult to attend trade union meetings outside working hours. Many may be able to Committee, quite rightly I would say, produced a leaflet asking people to come t9 a protest picket of the meeting.
From here, things quickly weni downhill. The women didn't only distribute their own leaflet. calling for the picket. They launched a concerted attempt to prevent the anti-abortionists from distributing their leaflets, initially simply by asking people not to take them, then by obstructing them. I was a bit unsure about this, but worse wa to come.
The lunchtime meeting took place, or rather didn't, in a local hotel. The supporters of a woman's right to chose, who were in a majority of about 100 to 15, took over the meeting. The platform were initially denied the right to speak.
After a suggestion from a woman who was pro-choice but believed that anti-abortionists should not be denied the right te speak, a vote was taken. This vote was overwhelmingly in favour of denying the platform speaking rights.
The anti-abortionists, one a Tory member of NALGO's NEC, were booed, jostled and minority of activists at meetings which they do not go to or (often) can not attend.
I believe that any charter for trade union rights should include the right for trade unionists to attend workplace meetings in works time, without loss of pay (the interminable number of "management" meetings held without loss of pay would doubtless be cited in our propaganda.
Such a demand would completely undercut any spurious attempts by our opponents to label us "elitist" or "undemoPROVE obstructed until they gave the meeting broke up.
I think both these activities, denying them the right to speak HANDICAPPED and breaking up their meeting, were wrong. Of course, we should show the anti-abortionist CHYDREN bigots that women at DESERIZLED BE Conference welcome neither their presence or their views. But the right to speak should not be -CILLED. denied them. Anti-abortionists are not fascists, Socialists should not use the Life He ME tactic of "no-platform" against people who have different, even though pretty vile, political views. Apart from anything else, we could find it used against ourselves. Indeed this happened at Conference. After the morning's squabbles and the attempts at obstruction the anti-abortionist, everyone distributing leaflets or selling papers was immediately thrown out of the Conference Centre.
As the Socialist Organiser Conference bulletin pointed out, if we are to extend "no platform" to the anti-abortionists, we might well have to consider extending it further to a large section of the population of the Irish Republic! cratic". What we would then be campaigning for, loudly and clearly, would be the right of trade unionists to be actively involved in decisions about their pay and conditions and, crucially, to quote your existing charter, to play an active part in the process whereby their unions would "determine their own conditions and rule books in accordance with their own democratic procedures, free from any interference by the Peter Allen Glossup Trotskyists against it. become you to cast stones.
----- pull-quotes -----
PLATFORM his year, NALGO'S